---
title: "New Wine and Old Bottles"
archive_id: 103546
date_as_printed: "Jan 2005"
date: 2005-01-01 (precision: month)
author_as_printed: "Ethan Davidson"
canonical_url: https://childrenofgodarchive.org/archive/documents/103546/new-wine-and-old-bottles
text_kind: original text (archivist markers removed; see the HTML page for them)
---
# New Wine and Old Bottles

[u1] New Wine and Old Bottles by Ethan Davidson

[u2] Jan 2005

[u3] New Wine and Old Bottles

[u4] by Ethan Davidson

[u5] "Insanity in individuals is the exception. But in groups, nations, and ages, it is the rule." Fredric Nietzsche

[u6] "If madness is gladness, and sanity pain, then I'd rather be crazy 'cause the whole world's insane." David Berg 1975 was a strange year for me.

[u7] I turned 12, and the hormones were really hitting me. I tried marijuana alcohol, and a couple of other drugs. I moved with my family from California to Hawaii. And I started training for my Bar Mitzvah, the traditional initiation into manhood that Jewish boys have at 13.

[u8] I was given books of Jewish short stories and Jewish history to read, and I read them.

[u9] But, I was given a lot of mixed messages. My father had converted to an obscure Japanese religion. My mother and stepfather were hippies who dabbled in Tibetan Buddhism. Yet, my mother wanted me to declare myself as identifying as Jewish, and I didn't feel that I could. I argued with my parents constantly.

[u10] I became very interested in the topic of religion. I wanted to learn as much about it as I could, and I was not content to just learn from books. I wanted to experience them. And I did.

[u11] At my peak, I was hanging out with, and participating in, seven religions at once. Judaism, Catholithism, Tenrikyo (my father's group), The Hari Krishnas, Mormons, Tendai Buddhists, and the Children of God.

[u12] I was, in short, cult bait. Somebody was going to get me, and it turned out to be COG.

[u13] I was attending seventh grade at a junior high school in Kaneohi, Hawaii. I didn't fit in very well with the local culture, with its hostility towards howlies (Caucasians.)

[u14] I was noticing girl, but was not well suited to the suggested ways of dealing with them, school dances, dating, "going together," and so forth. Physical contact interested me, but social rituals did not.

[u15] Then I met Elisha. She was blond, cute, 14 years old, and a member of COG. She started talking to me regularly, giving me pamphlets, and inviting me to events in Honolulu.

[u16] The pamphlets were written by a man named "Moses David," and were called Mo letters. At first, they didn't particularly impress me.

[u17] But I went to the events in Honolulu on Saturday nights, and they were fun.

[u18] They sang songs. They danced to strobe lights, which I had never seen before, and they were way cooler (and older, and more attractive) then the seventh graders at the junior high school dances.

[u19] They were Christians, but they did humorous sketches involving dirty words, thus showing that they were not boring square, normal Christians. (As a child of Jewish hippies, I would have rejected them if they had been.)

[u20] Best of all, they greeted each other with a "holy kiss." What that meant was that the males and females all kissed each other, on the lips. I had my first kiss there.

[u21] The women also hugged you and said, "I love you."

[u22] So, they were fun. The theology was another matter.

[u23] I had never been around fundamentalist Christians before, so I didn't recognize the standard evangelical (and Pentecostalist) belief system. But I did recognize the New Left rhetoric, lifted directly from the counter cultural views of the time. Nixon was a fascist. The government of the United States an evil "system" abhorred by God, and those in the mainstream were "systemites." Hippies were superior to the mainstream. Sex was healthy and good.

[u24] All this confirmed that they were not boring, ordinary Christians.

[u25] We sang on street corners, not ashamed to embarrass ourselves.

[u26] We went to the movie "Jesus Christ Superstar" and at the end, chanted "Revolution for Jesus" and threw our fists in the air.

[u27] We were filled with the Holy Spirit and talked in tongues.

[u28] As for Moses David (David Berg), he was a prophet, and his words came directly from God.

[u29] I knew what a prophet was. It hadn't crossed my mind that one could exist in modern times. But, logically, why not? If God talked to people back then, why not now?

[u30] One Mo Letter that had a particular effect on me was a sort of how to on having God talk to you. Mo believed that anybody could do it. He used the metaphor of a baby breastfeeding. A baby creates a vacuum in his mouth. Then, he sucks, and his mouth fills with milk. Similarly, one could create a vacuum in ones mind, "suck," and ones mind would be filled with the word of God.

[u31] I tried it, and it worked. God talked to me.

[u32] "God talked to me" I later told Elisha "just like you're talking to me."

[u33] "Well what did you expect" she asked "lightening and thunder?"

[u34] One might think that this perspective would lead to a sort of anarchism. If anybody can hear God's voice, how can anybody be above anybody else?

[u35] But this was not Cog's view. I later learned of a Mo Letter called "seven ways to know God's will.

[u36] At the top of the list were the Bible and Mo Letters. Next were the directions of COG leaders. Personal prophecy was at the bottom of the list, if it didn't contradict any of the above.

[u37] I didn't know that yet. In fact, God was telling me that I was a prophet, destined to start my own religion. I didn't really want to follow Moses David; I wanted to imitate him.

[u38] Ironically, however, the thought of being a prophet terrified me. I knew that it would involve "persecution." But, I believed it was God's will for me, so I started writing all my prophecies down in a book (which I later lost.)

[u39] While all this was going on, I studied for, and had, my Barmitzva. And my parents prepared to go to India for six moths, to work for the Dali Lama (leader of Tibetan Buddhism.) I was supposed to go with them.

[u40] At the last minute, they changed their mind about taking me. I was really angry,

[u41] I did go to Japan for two weeks with my father, on a pilgrimage to Tenri City, the sacred city of the Tenrikyo faith. A self-proclaimed "prophetess" also founded this religion, in the 19th century. This experience reinforced my belief in the prophet-based perspective.

[u42] I enjoyed that, but then, I moved with him to Richmond, California. This was a dreary, conservative, lower middle class, suburb. My father was on welfare. His health was failing. His housemate and landlord was blind, so the walls were white and blank, with nothing on them. I was very bored.

[u43] I met the COG representatives in the local mall. I started going to their events in Oakland. Now they had no competition, except the local churches. So, when they asked me to join, I was almost ready.

[u44] First, I had to go to the bathroom to ask God if it was the right thing to do. God said yes. It was the right thing to do, because it would be good training for me in my ultimate destiny, starting my own religion.

[u45] Of course, I didn't tell them that. I told them I was willing to join.

[u46] And I did. But because I was underage, and my parents were not in the group, I became what was known as a "Catacombs member."

[u47] When a person joined COG, the normal thing for them to do was to quite their "system job," cut most ties with their past life, and go devote themselves totally to working for the group. They moved into a group house, and were quickly relocated to another part of the country, or world.

[u48] But some people were not able to do this. This included: underage, first generation members like me, and people in the military or in prison. Also, some people made a lot of money off their "system jobs." In that case, Mo decided it was better to let them keep them.

[u49] So, we became "catacombs" members, named after the early Christians who had to meet in caves. Literally "underground." We participated as much as we could.

[u50] I went to the Oakland every day after school, and also spent my weekend there. I went to various locations, mostly shopping malls, "Witnessing," that is, giving out "Mo letters" and asking for donations.

[u51] I also went on road trips, where we hitch hiked to various nearby locations and slept in sleeping bags outside. It felt like wild freedom to me, even though all we usually did when we got there was hand out Mo Letters and ask for donations.

[u52] In one Mall, I met a woman who was doing pretty much the same thing, raising donations for her prophet. Except, her prophet was named Jim Jones, and her organization was "The Peoples Temple." She raised more money than I did, but she hated the competition.

[u53] I made myself obnoxious at school by "witnessing" to everybody, but I didn't win any real converts.

[u54] I gave up drugs, except for an occasional drink of wine (the drug of choice in COG. Hey, Jesus did it.)

[u55] My father later told me that when he visited the group, he was struck by all the beautiful women telling him "I love you" and was tempted to join himself, for that reason alone.

[u56] This technique, as I later learned, was called "flirty fishing." It was very effective, even at this point, when it was all (so far as I could tell) a big tease, and didn't lead to actually having sex with these women.

[u57] Well, at thirteen, a tease was good enough for me.

[u58] The year was 1976, It was the bicentennial, and Moses David had written a Mo letter strongly implying that America would be judged on July 4.

[u59] On July 4, early in the morning when it was still dark, we were all woken up. Told "good revolutionaries don't ask questions", we were driven somewhere. We were pretty sure that something heavy was going down, that God was judging America.

[u60] He wasn't. We went to a campground and spent the weekend splashing around in the lake. When we got back, much to our embarrassment, America was still there, and unchanged.

[u61] A young woman I had a crush on was moving to Argentina, and I wanted to go to. But my father wouldn't let me.

[u62] In fact, most of the COG was leaving the country, because we were still convinced that God was going to judge America soon.

[u63] When my mother and stepfather returned from India, I moved back in with them, and they were not at all pleased with the situation.

[u64] Not sure what to do with me and my non-stop witnessing mouth, they suggested I go to a large commune in Tennessee, where a friend of theirs was living. This Utopian hippie commune known as The Farm (with it's own grandiose "guru," Stephan Gaskin) had taken on the project of taking in troubled teenagers.

[u65] I counseled with my COG leaders, and they decided I should go. Since I couldn't leave the country, it would be a relatively safe place to be when Gods judgement came.

[u66] Part of there decision was probably based on the fact that I was not very useful to the group. I didn't bring in new converts, didn't raise much money, and my conversation kept wandering off topic, so that they kept having to say "lets talk about Jesus."

[u67] Still, I went to Tennessee thinking of myself still as a member of COG. They sent me Mo letters, and I, in turn, wrote them letters, annoyed The Farm adults and turned off girls who were attracted to me with my Witnessing.

[u68] However, isolated geographically from the group, I did make friends with some of the other teenagers on The Farm.

[u69] The turning point came when I was offered a hit off a joint. Since COG forbids drug use, I knew that if I smoked the joint, I was could no longer consider myself a member. I smoked it, and went off on a different trip.

[u70] I came back in 1977, and visited them one more time. They tried to get me back into it, invited me to litness in the mall, but I just couldn't.

[u71] #

[u72] My adolescence and early adulthood remained turbulent. I wandered from place to place and trip to trip and drug to drug. The drugs got stronger and stronger, the behavior got weirder and weirder.

[u73] The idea of me as a prophet remained dormant in my mind. In retrospect, it seems that a lot of the motivation behind my drug use was to suppress this idea.

[u74] It all came back to me when, at age 23, I decided to get off drugs. This led me to participating in 12 step programs. And this led me to confront the "G word," God, and in particular, the third step. "We made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him."

[u75] This made me panic. God, as I understood Him, was a voice in my head that would tell me that I was a prophet, and would make me go around proclaiming myself as such to everybody, leading to isolation, ridicule, harassment, perhaps even institutionalization.

[u76] Clearly, the spirituality of the 12 step programs was not going to be simple for me. I learned that you can use anything you want as your higher power. So I used a variety to things, the group, time, and Gods and Goddesses from non-western, polytheistic belief systems.

[u77] My own belief system went from agnosticism to neo-paganism to Buddhism. Currently, I consider myself a Buddhist, though I can not be a fundamentalist about this, nor any other belief system. That is to say, I can not say that God (or Buddha, or anybody) said it, I believe it, and that settles it. Every idea has to be subject to my own intellect and my own direct experience.

[u78] And that goes triple for anybody who is still alive.

[u79] I believe it is an error to consider a dead person as a flawless speaker of absolute truth. But if that person is still alive, it is not just an error, it is gravely dangerous, for, as we all know, power corrupts.

[u80] That is why 12 step programs have, in addition to the steps, the "Traditions." These are specifically designed to keep the groups from deteriorating into personality cults, for the danger of them doing so has long been recognized.

[u81] The concept of the prophet is, therefore, a very dangerous one. I have experienced many cults, and I have also worked with schizophrenics, and been told, time after time, a variation on the same story. "I'm God." "I'm Jesus." "I did battle with Satan and defeated him."

[u82] It became a matter of much interest to me how the concept of "The Prophet" came into the world. So, I started to study the topic.

[u83] The early Hebrews were probably a polytheistic group which worshiped many Gods and Goddesses. None were "supreme" and thus, none were infallible. Each had mediums who channeled the deities, allowing them to temporarily posses his or her body. Many primitive religions are structured this way, and millions of people all over the world still practice spirituality of this sort.

[u84] Eventually, Yaiwsts who wanted only their God worshiped hijacked the religion. Other deities were either assimilated in (they were considered to be another name of Yawieh) or their worship was suppressed. Yaway was considered to be infallible, all knowing, all-powerful, and all good. It stands to reason that his prophets were also infallible, that there words were the words of God himself. Anybody who didn't obey these words was evil and would be punished.

[u85] However, there were also "false Prophets" and "lying spirits." And it was very difficult, if not impossible, to tell, except in retrospect, which was which. This puts all of us in a hell of a dilemma.

[u86] #

[u87] Every now and then, I heard rumors about COG. The media refereed to them as "The kiddy porn cult". I dismissed most of this as media hype.

[u88] I wrote my memories of my time in COG, concluding, "later, I heard that they were molesting children. But I didn't see any of that. I cursed my bad timing."

[u89] In light of what I have since read, I don't think I'll make that joke anymore. It doesn’t seem funny now.

[u90] Of course, boys are different from girls. People who join a group willingly are different from those born into it. And thirteen-year-olds are definitely different from three-year-olds.

[u91] I met them one more time, in 2004, at a Rainbow Gathering. Now they called themselves "The Family." Once again, a young woman who started talking to me drew me in.

[u92] For old time's sake, I asked that they sing their most popular song, "you got be a baby." Which they did. In several languages.

[u93] "You got be a baby. You got be a baby. You got be a baby to get to heaven. Jesus said You got be a baby. You got be a baby. You got be a baby to get to heaven."

[u94] Evan this song, which sounded so innocent and sweet, so longer seems that way in light of what I have since read, especially in the tract "The raising of Davidito."

[u95] It seems that while COG basically treated adults like children, it also treated children, and even real babies, like little adults.

[u96] All these memories came back to me recently when the news stories about Ricky Rodrigez hit the newspapers. This led me to the Internet, and to the web site movingon.org, for second generation COG members who have left the group.

[u97] Of course, I couldn't understand all the references they made. I didn't get all the jokes in "100 reasons why it's great to be a systemite."

[u98] But, in light of how short-lived my involvement with COG was, and how long ago, it was, it was strange how many of the references I did get.

[u99] I admired the courage, intelligence and creativity of these young, second generation, former members.

[u100] There was, however, one thing that disturbed me.

[u101] There were a number of positive references to drinking, and drugs. In fact, the web site contains a rather large section dedicated to the discussion of recreational drug use.

[u102] Well, if there is one thing I remember about people who lined cults, including COG, it is that a lot of them had a history of drug abuse. Many of them followed the ideology of the time, which was that taking a lot of phsycadelics was the best way to "get rid of your ego."

[u103] The overused and poorly understood word "ego" was used to mean arrogance and selfishness, but also, a basic sense of self, a concept of who you are. The hippies who succeeded in "smashing their egos" with the help of a lot of drugs often found out that they weren't capable of managing their own lives. So, many of them drifted into organizations that would take care of them, and give them a structure. And, these organizations recently had their own techniques for keeping the ego (or pride, as they said in COG) in a smashed state, even when members had lived for years drug free.

[u104] So, it is sad to me to see that the cycle seems to be, in some cases, repeating itself. And I appeal to "second gen xfam" to be very, very careful. Learn from the mistakes of your elders, and try not to repeat them.

[u105] #

[u106] In the 1970s, David Berg liked to refer to the younger generation, the hippies and COG members, as "New Bottles." This was a reference to something Jesus had said, that you can't put new wine in old bottles, because the old bottles would break. So, the older generation, the "systemites," were "old bottles." When somebody seemed shocked by our weird behavior, we would say that we "broke his bottle."

[u107] I remember one guy talking about the future. "By that time" he said "the next generation will be The Revolution, and we'll be the old bottles."

[u108] Unlike most COG prophecies, this one came true. The second generation is leading a new revolution. And the older ones are the ones who "bottles" are being "broken."

[u109] But they thought that the next revolution would be a continuation of their own. They didn't count on it being what Communists call "a counter revolution."

[u110] But it is. The new wine is flowing. The old bottles are being broken. All this is inevitable. I can only suggest try not to drink too much, or to cut your feet on the broken glass.
