Sexual ethics and safeguarding
Flirty Fishing (FFing)
Flirty Fishing was a method of witnessing in which female members used sexual attraction, and at times sex, to win converts and supporters. The group presented it as a sacrificial form of God's love. Berg and Maria began it in 1973-74. Letters from 1974 to 1978 described and promoted it, and by the late 1970s it was practised in Homes in many countries. In 1987 sex with newly met outsiders was banned and replaced by distribution of "Daily Food" booklets ("DFing"). The Family's 1992 and 1993 statements described the ending but defended the ministry. The 1995 UK judgment found that the practice had become prostitution and had harmed children who were aware of it.
How the teaching developed
Berg's letter "The Flirty Little Fishy" was among the first letters on the practice. According to the 1995 judgment, Berg and Maria began it with people they met at a London dance club late in 1973. A 1991 Family publication dates the start to 1974.
One of the earliest letters was "Flirty Little Fish" in January 1974.
Judgement of Lord Justice WardBy 1974 the Lord had begun to show Grandpa & Mama that meeting others' needs for love, romance & sex could even be used as a tool to reach & witness to & win outsiders to the Lord.
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships!
Berg taught that FFing was only a means to winning souls. He told members not to lose sight of that goal.
WE'RE TRYING TO WIN SOULS WE'RE NOT JUST TRYING TO GET GUYS IN BED.
ML 535, The Little Dog Dream! ¶37Sometimes some people really get their eyes off the goal and on the method. They get their eyes off the end and on the means.
ML 535, The Little Dog Dream! ¶40
Berg presented FFing as a way of showing men that God loved them.
That's why FFing is so important, it's so important because it shows the men that God really loves them
ML 699, You Are the Love of God! ¶6
Family news in 1979 reported FFing in many regions. A 1991 Family publication says Berg wanted all Homes to take it up and that leaders' reluctance contributed to the 1978 reorganisation. The 1995 judgment accepted that taking part was voluntary but found that members were under strong pressure to do so.
LATIN AMERICA & SOUTHERN EUROPE ARE AGAIN LEADING THE WORLD IN FFING with Asia, Africa & the Pacific not far behind.
ML 833, The Latest News! ¶10Grandpa made it very clear to us that the Lord wanted all of our Homes to pioneer & learn to use this radical new outreach method
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships!I accept that it was voluntary and that Berg had "said time and time again, FFing is not for everybody.
Judgement of Lord Justice WardThere was, however, very great pressure on the disciples to take part in this "ministry."
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
In 1987 sex with newly met outsiders was banned, and Daily Food distribution (DFing) replaced FFing. AIDS was given as one reason. A June 1992 Family statement says all its fellowships agreed that month to end sexual intimacy in witnessing.
NOW THAT DAD HAS BANNED SEX WITH NEWLY-MET OUTSIDERS, our folks are going to discover real quick how effective the DFing Word Revolution can be!
ML 2346, Mama on the New AIDS RulesIn September of that year, all of our fellowships agreed that all forms of sexual intimacy in witnessing to non-members should be completely discontinued.
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSEAs the spectre of Aids loomed over the world, Berg officially put an end to FFing in September 1987
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
After Summit '93 the leadership said FFing had been fruitful and that its principles remained true, though the method had changed. It claimed over 100,000 people had been won through FFing.
This was a ministry which was tremendously fruitful, with over 100,000 people won to Jesus
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!The Letters & the spiritual principles behind FFing are as true today as they ever were!
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!
The 1995 UK judgment found that the organisation had been living in part on the earnings of prostitution through FFing. It found the practice had harmed children in the Family, who knew of it. It was satisfied that the practice had ceased.
They were knowingly living in part on the earnings of prostitution.
Judgement of Lord Justice WardI also find it disturbing that The Family cannot see that the practice of FFing was harmful to the children in The Family.
Judgement of Lord Justice WardI am satisfied that the practice has indeed ceased.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The Family's 1998 policy statement forbids prostitution. It states that since 1987 full-time members may not have sex with anyone outside Charter membership, on pain of excommunication. Later publications (1998-2001) still list sex with outsiders as an excommunicable offence.
since 1987, full-time members, under penalty of excommunication, are not allowed to have sexual relationships with those who are not Charter members of The Family.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex11) A lack of the fear of the Lord concerning breaking excommunicable rules such as sex with outsiders.
ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities ¶11
Bible passages the group cited
The passages the group itself used to support this teaching, with where it cited them. This is not an interpretation of those passages.
- Matthew 4:19
Recollecting how in the Gospel of St. Matthew 4:19, Jesus said to his disciples, "Follow me and I will make you fishers of men"
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- 2 Timothy 2:4
we wouldn't have gotten as enticed or "entangled in the affairs of this life"--2Tim.2:4.
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!
- Exodus 15:26
And He also wanted to protect the Family from the "diseases of the Egyptians."--Exo.15:26.
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!
Compared with historic Christianity
Part of Berg vs the Bible. Bible quotations are from public-domain translations.
The group taught
Flirty Fishing was a method of witnessing in which female members used sexual attraction, and at times sex, to win converts and supporters. The group presented it as a sacrificial form of God's love. Berg and Maria began it in 1973-74. Letters from 1974 to 1978 described and promoted it, and by the late 1970s it was practised in Homes in many countries. In 1987 sex with newly met outsiders was banned and replaced by distribution of "Daily Food" booklets ("DFing"). The Family's 1992 and 1993 statements described the ending but defended the ministry. The 1995 UK judgment found that the practice had become prostitution and had harmed children who were aware of it.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that sexual intercourse belongs only within marriage, and they count prostitution and sex outside marriage as sins. Christian moral teaching also holds that a good purpose, including winning converts, does not make a wrong act right. Catholic moral theology states this explicitly, and Protestant ethics usually grounds it in Romans 3:8. Evangelism is understood to work by preaching, witness and service. There is no recognised strand of historic Christianity that approves sexual contact as a method of evangelism.
Where they differ
Berg taught that FFing was a means of winning souls and of showing men that God loved them. He and Maria began the practice in 1973-74, and the group presented it as sacrificial love. This departs from the historic consensus that limits sex to marriage and holds that good ends do not justify wrong means. The group banned sex with newly met outsiders in 1987. Its 1993 statement still called FFing fruitful and its principles true. Its 1998 policy statement forbids prostitution and sex outside Charter membership, a rule that matches historic teaching more closely in practice, though the stated basis is different.
Bible passages
Marriage is honourable in all, and the bed undefiled: but whoremongers and adulterers God will judge.
For this is the will of God, even your sanctification, that ye should abstain from fornication: That every one of you should know how to possess his vessel in sanctification and honour;
Flee fornication. Every sin that a man doeth is without the body; but he that committeth fornication sinneth against his own body.
Creeds and historic statements
- Didache (late 1st or early 2nd century), chapter 2, tr. M. B. Riddle (Ante-Nicene Fathers): “you shall not commit pederasty, you shall not commit fornication, you shall not steal,”
- Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), chapter 24, section 1: “Marriage is to be between one man and one woman: neither is it lawful for any man to have more than one wife,”
- Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992), paragraph 1753: “A good intention (for example, that of helping one's neighbor) does not make behavior that is intrinsically disordered, such as lying and calumny, good or just.”
Further research
- ML 293 "The Flirty Little Fishy"
- ML 309 "Beauty and the Beasts"
- "King Arthur's Nights" series
- ML 535 "The Little Dog Dream"
- ML 605 "The Right to Witness"
- ML 699 "You Are the Love of God"
- "FFers Handbook" (1977)
- ML 2313 "The FFing/DFing Revolution"
- ML 2346 "Mama on the New AIDS Rules"
- search: ESing, DFing, "Jesus babies"