Berg vs the Bible
The teachings of David Berg, Maria (Karen Zerby), Peter Amsterdam, the Children of God and The Family International, set beside what historic, mainstream Christianity has taught on the same question.
The group’s side is drawn from its own publications, quoted and linked. The historic side is drawn from the Bible and from widely shared statements of faith such as the Nicene Creed and the major confessions, noting where Christian traditions themselves disagree. Open any belief for the full comparison, the passages each side cites, and how the group’s teaching changed over time.
Authority and revelation
David Berg as God's Endtime Prophet ("Moses David", "Father David", "David of the End")
The group taught
From 1971 Berg taught that he was the "Endtime David" foretold in Bible prophecies, a prophet whose Letters carried God's message for the last days.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that God spoke through the prophets and finally and fully in Jesus Christ, and that the public revelation given through the apostles is complete.
Exalted titles for living leaders ("Queen of Heaven", "Queen Maria", "King Peter")
The group taught
The group's publications applied royal and Marian titles to living leaders.
Historic Christianity
Catholic and Orthodox churches honour Mary, the mother of Jesus, above all other saints; the Catholic Church calls her Queen of Heaven, for example in the Eastertide anthem Regina Coeli, and Orthodox worship honours her as Theotokos (God-bearer) with royal imagery.
Bible passages
Government, law and "God's law over man's law"
The group taught
Berg taught that laws restricting witnessing were the devil's laws and need not be obeyed, and he described man's laws as often contrary to God's.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that civil government is ordained by God and that Christians should obey lawful authority, pay taxes and pray for rulers.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Maria (Karen Zerby) as prophetess and Berg's successor
The group taught
Berg's publications called Maria a prophetess from 1971 and said in 1980 that his "mantle" would fall on her when he died.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches do not recognise a line of succession for prophets.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Prophetic authority: the MO Letters, "the Word" and continuing prophecy
The group taught
From 1969 David Berg ("Moses David", later "Father David" or "Dad") issued letters presented as prophecies and as messages from God to his followers; the group called this body of writing "the Letters" or "the Word".
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that God's public revelation was completed in Jesus Christ and the apostolic witness, and that no later prophecy can add to or correct it.
Bible passages
The Bible and "new wine" (newer revelation over "old bottles")
The group taught
Berg called new revelations "new wine" and church people "old bottles" who could not hold it.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that the faith was "once delivered unto the saints" and that Scripture is inspired and authoritative.
Bible passages
The Holy Spirit as a female "Queen of Love"
The group taught
From 1981 Berg taught that the Holy Spirit is the female, mother person of the Trinity, which he portrayed as God's "Queen of Love".
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches confess the Holy Spirit as the third Person of the Trinity, "the Lord, the giver of life", worshipped with the Father and the Son.
Bible passages
The Trinity and the nature of God
The group taught
In 1975 Berg said he did not believe in the "so-called Trinity" while believing in Father, Son and Holy Ghost, and suggested the Son did not exist as such until he became man.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches confess one God in three Persons, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, equal and eternal, as set out in the Nicene and Athanasian Creeds.
Bible passages
God, Christ and salvation
Jews and Israel
The group taught
Berg taught that the promises to Abraham belong to believers in Jesus by faith, so that his followers, not "flesh-and-blood" Jews, were God's true Israel.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that the Church shares in the promises made to Abraham through faith in Christ, and many have held that the Church is the new or true Israel.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Salvation by grace and eternal security ("once saved, always saved")
The group taught
Berg taught that salvation is a free gift received by grace through faith, by asking Jesus into one's heart, and that once received it can never be lost.
In the group’s own words
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that salvation comes by God's grace through Jesus Christ and is received by faith, and that baptism and a continuing life of faith belong to it.
Bible passages
Sexual ethics and safeguarding
Berg's relationship with Maria while married to Jane ("Mother Eve")
The group taught
Berg took Karen Zerby (Maria), who joined his household as a secretary in January 1969, as a sexual partner while he was still married to Jane Berg ("Mother Eve"), and kept the relationship hidden from members.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that marriage is an exclusive, lifelong union of one man and one woman, and treat sexual relations with someone other than one's spouse as adultery, a grave sin.
Bible passages
Birth control and having children
The group taught
Berg taught from 1973 that God opposed every form of birth control and that members should leave the number of children to God, praising Catholic teaching on this point.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that children are a gift from God and that marriage is ordered to procreation; until the twentieth century Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant churches all opposed contraception.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Children and sexuality: early publications and later renunciations
The group taught
Between 1977 and 1980 Berg taught in Letters that children were made to enjoy sex, that God intended marriage at 12 or 13, and that there were "no relationship restrictions or age limitations" in the Law of Love.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches have always condemned the sexual use of children.
Bible passages
Flirty Fishing (FFing)
The group taught
Flirty Fishing was a method of witnessing in which female members used sexual attraction, and at times sex, to win converts and supporters.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that sexual intercourse belongs only within marriage, and they count prostitution and sex outside marriage as sins.
Bible passages
Homosexuality
The group taught
Berg consistently taught that sex between men was forbidden by Scripture, while saying in 1973 that the Bible did not forbid sex between women.
In the group’s own words
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches have taught that homosexual acts, by men or by women, are sinful, citing passages in Leviticus, Romans 1 and 1 Corinthians 6.
Church teaching
Marriage: "One Wife" and the sharing of mates
The group taught
In "One Wife" (1972) Berg taught that God breaks up private families to make one larger Family, which he called "One Wife", the Bride of Christ.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that marriage is a lifelong union of one man and one woman, instituted by God, and that sexual relations belong only within it.
Nudity
The group taught
Berg taught from 1969 that Adam and Eve became ashamed of nakedness only after the Fall, and that shame about nudity comes from sin or from the Devil rather than from God.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that the human body is good as God's creation and that Adam and Eve were naked without shame before the Fall.
Bible passages
Sex outside marriage: adultery and fornication
The group taught
Berg taught that the "Law of Love" replaced the Ten Commandments, so that sex outside marriage was lawful when done "in love".
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches, Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant alike, teach that sexual relations belong only within marriage between a husband and his wife.
Bible passages
Sin, repentance and "all things are lawful"
The group taught
Berg read 1 Corinthians 6:12 to mean that Christians are free from the Mosaic law and that whatever is done in love is not sin; this underlies the Law of Love.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that Christians are freed from the ceremonial law of Moses but remain bound by the moral law summed up in the Ten Commandments and the commands of Christ.
The Law of Love
The group taught
The Law of Love is the group's teaching that, for believers, love replaces the Mosaic law, so that whatever is done in unselfish love is lawful before God.
In the group’s own words
- ML 258: Revolutionary Sex (March 27, 1973)
- ML 302C: The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”! (March 21, 1974)
- ML 591: The 51 Errors of “Daily Notices”! – Of Santa Cruz, Tenerife, Canary Islands (July 1977)
- ML 592: God’s Only Law is Love! – What the Bible Says About True Free Love! (July 29, 1977)
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that love fulfils the law (Romans 13:10), and most hold that Christians are freed from the ceremonial law of Moses but remain bound by its moral law, summed up in the Ten Commandments.
Bible passages
Community and church authority
Breaking up families and leaving children for "the Work"
The group taught
Berg taught that God was "breaking up private families" to form one larger Family, that the group came before "the tiny private selfish family unit", and that forsaking one's children for the Lord's work was a sacrifice God rewarded.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that children are a gift from God, entrusted to their own parents, who are responsible for providing for them and bringing them up in the faith.
Child discipline
The group taught
Berg taught corporal punishment with the rod, citing Proverbs, and gave detailed advice on spanking young children in the 1970s and 1980s, though he said it was not the best answer for teenagers.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that parents have a God-given duty to train and correct their children, drawing on Proverbs and on Paul's command that fathers bring up children "in the nurture and admonition of the Lord" without provoking them.
Bible passages
Church attendance, the Sabbath and "Churchianity"
The group taught
From 1968 Berg attacked "Churchianity", meaning church buildings, Sunday services and denominations, and called his followers out of the churches.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches confess "one holy catholic and apostolic Church" as a visible body with ministry and sacraments, and expect believers to gather for worship, mainly on Sunday, the Lord's Day, in memory of the resurrection.
Communal life and "forsaking all": discipleship, Homes and leadership
The group taught
From 1968 the group required full-time disciples to "forsake all": to leave jobs, possessions and family ties, give their goods to the group and live communally in "colonies", later called "Homes".
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches point to the shared life of the Jerusalem church (Acts 2 and 4) as an example of generosity.
Bible passages
Divorce and remarriage
The group taught
Berg said in 1973 that the group did not believe in divorce if it could be avoided, but in 1975 he taught that divorce by mutual consent was scripturally permissible, with freedom to remarry.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that marriage is meant to be lifelong and that divorce is contrary to God's design.
Education and schooling of children
The group taught
In 1975 Berg taught that Family children needed only a basic education and that even senior high school was unnecessary.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that parents are the first educators of their children and must raise them in the faith, a duty drawn from Deuteronomy 6 and Ephesians 6.
Honesty with outsiders: "deceivers yet true" and "Selah" security
The group taught
From the early 1970s some colonies and Homes were "Selah", kept secret from outsiders for security, and members were told not to disclose their links to the group in such places.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that lying is sinful and that believers should speak the truth.
Church teaching
Leaving the group: "backsliders" and excommunication
The group taught
Berg taught that "backsliders" who left full-time discipleship faced God's anger and harmed others, while also saying members were free to leave.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that church discipline, up to excommunication, exists to correct and restore an offender and to protect the church, and that it should be used for serious and persistent sin.
Bible passages
Money, "provisioning" and the tithe
The group taught
The group lived by asking for donated goods and services ("provisioning"), by gifts from new members who "forsook all", and later by selling or distributing literature for donations.
In the group’s own words
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that believers should give generously and willingly to support the church, its ministers and the poor.
Church teaching
Obedience to leaders and shepherds
The group taught
Berg ran the movement as an "army" and taught that members owed obedience and loyalty to leaders placed over them.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach respect and obedience toward rightful church leaders, citing passages such as Hebrews 13:17.
Bible passages
Required reading of "the Word" (the Letters)
The group taught
In Family usage "the Word" means both the Bible and the Letters of Berg and Maria.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches encourage the faithful to read and study Scripture, and many traditions have set times of prayer and reading.
Bible passages
Church teaching
The roles of women and men
The group taught
Berg taught that wives should submit to their husbands as the Church submits to Christ and, in 1975, that because Eve led the way to the Fall woman could no longer be trusted with equality and man must be "the boss".
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that men and women are equally made in God's image and equally redeemed in Christ (Galatians 3:28).
Church teaching
"The System": separation from mainstream society
The group taught
From 1968 Berg called mainstream society, its churches, schools and jobs "the System" and urged converts to drop out of it and form a new society.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that believers are to be distinct from "the world" in the moral sense, resisting sin and conformity to its values, while normally living within ordinary society, family and work.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Work and secular ("System") employment
The group taught
Early Berg letters treated ordinary jobs ("System jobs") as a sign that a convert had not truly dropped out, though Berg allowed exceptions.
In the group’s own words
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that ordinary work is honourable and that believers should normally support themselves and their families by it.
Bible passages
Church teaching
End-time prophecy
End-time prophecy: the Antichrist, the Great Tribulation and predicted dates
The group taught
From its beginnings the group taught that it was living in the Last Days.
Historic Christianity
The historic creeds confess that Christ will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead.
Bible passages
Heaven and the afterlife (the "Heavenly City")
The group taught
Berg taught that the New Jerusalem of Revelation 21-22 is a literal golden city shaped like a pyramid, 1500 miles high, which will descend to a renewed earth, with the saved inside and other nations outside.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian creeds confess the resurrection of the body and the life of the world to come, in which the redeemed will live with God for ever.
Bible passages
Hell, judgment and a second chance after death
The group taught
Berg taught that the Lake of Fire purges rather than punishes forever, that most of the unsaved will eventually live outside the Heavenly City, and that God gives a "second chance" after death or in the Millennium.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian creeds teach that Christ will return to judge the living and the dead and that the outcome is everlasting life or everlasting punishment, with death ending the time for repentance.
Church teaching
The Comet Kohoutek prophecy (1973-74)
The group taught
In late 1973 Berg linked the approaching comet Kohoutek to coming judgement on America and suggested it might cause earthquakes and the fall of the United States.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that Christ will return and judge the world but that the day and hour are not revealed.
Bible passages
The rapture, the Millennium and the Heavenly City
The group taught
Berg taught a rapture of believers after the Great Tribulation, not before it, followed by the Marriage Supper of the Lamb, God's wrath on the Antichrist, and a thousand-year reign of Christ on earth in which the saints rule over survivors.
Historic Christianity
The historic creeds teach that Christ will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead, that the dead will be raised, and that his kingdom will have no end.
Bible passages
Spiritual practices
Angels, spirit helpers and departed saints
The group taught
Berg claimed to talk regularly with spirits and to be guided, and at times taken over, by them: his chief "spirit helper" was Abrahim, said to be a departed gypsy king, who Berg said spoke through his mouth and "possessed" his mind.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that angels and the faithful departed are real, but that Christians relate to the unseen world through God in Christ, not by seeking out spirits for contact or messages.
Bible passages
- Hebrews 1:14 concordance
- Deuteronomy 18:10-11 (part) concordance
- Colossians 2:18 (part) concordance
- Revelation 19:10 concordance
- Hebrews 4:16 concordance
- Leviticus 19:31 concordance
- Deuteronomy 18:10-12 concordance
- Isaiah 8:19-20 concordance
- 1 Chronicles 10:13-14 concordance
- 1 John 4:1 concordance
- Acts 16:16 concordance
- Acts 16:18 concordance
- Galatians 5:20 concordance
Berg's continued communication after his death (1994)
The group taught
After Berg died in October 1994, Maria taught that he was still leading the Family from the spirit world and speaking to her and to members.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that at death the faithful go to be with Christ to await the resurrection.
Bible passages
Communion (the Lord's Supper)
The group taught
Communion was the one ceremony Berg kept, held informally in Homes with bread and wine and led by any member, including children.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches celebrate the Lord's Supper (Eucharist) as instituted by Christ, usually every Sunday or regularly, led by an ordained minister.
Bible passages
Divine healing, medicine and doctors
The group taught
Berg taught divine healing by faith and at times compared relying on medicine and doctors with trying to be saved by works, though in 1970 he allowed medical help for emergencies beyond the group's skill.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that God can and does heal in answer to prayer, and they pray for and anoint the sick (the Catholic and Orthodox anointing of the sick).
Bible passages
Church teaching
Fasting and days of prayer
The group taught
Berg recommended fasting with prayer for stubborn illness and demon possession and, from 1978, a monthly Family day of fasting and prayer.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches practise fasting as a discipline joined to prayer and repentance, following Jesus' teaching and the apostles' example.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Loving Jesus (the "Bride of Christ" revelation)
The group taught
The Loving Jesus revelation, issued by Maria and Peter Amsterdam in Good News magazines in late 1995 and early 1996, teaches that each believer, man or woman, is personally the bride of Jesus.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that the Church as a whole is the Bride of Christ (Ephesians 5, Revelation 19 and 21) and that Christian marriage is an image of that union.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Music and its role in the faith
The group taught
Music was central to the group from its coffee-house beginnings: Berg said songs were for moving people to respond to the message, not for entertainment, and the group used bands, records and radio shows such as "Music with Meaning" to witness.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that singing psalms, hymns and spiritual songs is part of worship and of teaching one another.
Bible passages
Personal prophecy as a daily practice ("hearing from the Lord")
The group taught
Berg's early ministry relied on prophecy and "hearing the Voice of God", and he taught that members could prophesy.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches accept that the Holy Spirit gives gifts, and the New Testament speaks of prophecy in the early Church.
Bible passages
Prayer, prayer vigils and speaking in tongues
The group taught
Berg encouraged speaking in tongues and prophecy in meetings and described praying in tongues himself.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that all believers should pray, privately and together, in the name of Christ, and they use set forms such as the Lord's Prayer alongside free prayer.
Bible passages
Church teaching
Spirit helpers and communication with departed spirits
The group taught
From 1970 Berg said a departed spirit he called Abrahim, a Gypsy king, spoke through him as his "spirit helper".
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that angels are ministering spirits sent by God and that the faithful departed are with Christ.
Bible passages
Church teaching
The Devil, demons and spiritual warfare
The group taught
Family publications describe the Christian life as constant spiritual warfare against Satan and his demons, and early Letters gave steps for casting out demons, including from members who defied leadership.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that the Devil and demons are angels created good who fell by their own choice, that they tempt and oppose people, and that Christ has defeated them.
Bible passages
Church teaching
The "Keys of the Kingdom"
The group taught
Family publications around 2000-2001 taught that Jesus had given the Family full access to the "keys of the Kingdom", a spiritual power members could call on by name in prayer.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches read Jesus' words to Peter about the keys of the kingdom (Matthew 16:19) as a grant of authority to the Church.
Bible passages
Water baptism
The group taught
Berg taught that water baptism is an outward sign only, a Jewish custom not required today, and that the baptism of the Holy Spirit replaces it.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches treat baptism with water in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit as commanded by Christ and as the rite of entry into the Church.
Bible passages
Witnessing, "litnessing" and evangelism
The group taught
The group regarded witnessing, preaching the gospel to everyone and leading them to pray to receive Jesus, as its main purpose.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that the Church is sent to proclaim the gospel to all nations and that all believers should be ready to explain their faith.
Bible passages
Church teaching