Sexual ethics and safeguarding
Children and sexuality: early publications and later renunciations
Between 1977 and 1980 Berg taught in Letters that children were made to enjoy sex, that God intended marriage at 12 or 13, and that there were "no relationship restrictions or age limitations" in the Law of Love. From about 1985 the leadership told members to stop adult-minor sexual contact, mainly because it was illegal. In 1988 Berg renounced writings that seemed to approve it, but as late as 1993 leaders said the Letters "weren't wrong" and that such relationships were not "inherently wrong in principle". Only from 1995 did the Family call adult-minor sex wrong and a sin and accept that Berg bore responsibility for harm to children.
How the teaching developed
In "Child Brides!" (ML 902) Berg argued that God intended people to marry at about 12 or 13 because they can then have children, and suggested that where the law did not allow such marriages young people could live together and have children anyway. The Letter was later purged from the Family's library.
I've said before that I think the Lord must have been in favour of marriage at about 12 or 13 because you're first able to have children at that age.
ML 902, CHILD BRIDES!If the System won't permit us to let them actually legally get married at that age, why not just let them live together & have children anyhow?--So what?
ML 902, CHILD BRIDES!
In "My Childhood Sex!" (ML 779, marked "Adults Only") Berg described his own sexual experiences as a small child, including contact initiated by a babysitter, as natural and harmless, and argued that God intended children to enjoy sexual feelings from an early age.
IF THE LORD MADE IT TO FEEL GOOD AT AN EARLY AGE, WHY NOT ENJOY IT?
ML 779, My Childhood Sex! – Doin’ What Comes Naturally!SO I STARTED AT AN EARLY AGE & ENGAGED IN SEX ALL MY LIFE, but I don't think it's hurt me, thank the Lord!
ML 779, My Childhood Sex! – Doin’ What Comes Naturally!
In "The Devil Hates Sex" (ML 999) Berg said that the Law of Love had no age limits, that sex practised in love was not wrong whatever the age of the person, and that only man-made law forbade it. The 1995 English court judgment and the Family's own 1996 letter both singled this discourse out.
There are no relationship restrictions or age limitations in His law of love.
ML 999, The Devil Hates SexThat there's nothing in the world at all wrong with sex as long as it's practised in love, whatever it is or whoever it's with, no matter who or what age or what relative or what manner!
ML 999, The Devil Hates Sex
According to a 1992 Family statement, an internal memorandum in 1985 told members that adults were not to have sexual contact with children.
For the record, we want to say that we do not agree to adults having sexual contact with children. The Family should just not do it.
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE
According to the 1995 English court judgment, a January 1985 News Flash told under-age children not to undress when dancing on video, giving outsiders' anger as the reason and dismissing concern about child sex as "rot".
under aged children were urged not to take their clothes off when dancing on video because: "You could hardly touch a more sensitive nerve in most of the systemites to enrage them and have them want to lynch you on the spot than to bring up child abuse, and child sex, and child pornography, and all that kind of rot."
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
An internal memo, "Liberty or Stumblingblock?" by Sara, told adults to stop sexual contact with children and young teens. The main reasons it gave were that such contact was illegal and that teen questionnaires showed it had harmed the young people; it allowed that older teens of legal age might be "a different story" and asked readers to destroy it. When the 1992 public statement quoted this memo, these qualifications were left out.
we want to say that we do not agree with adults having sex with children. The Family should just not do it, mainly because it's illegal.
Liberty or StumblingblockAnd even though teen sex with adults may be tolerated in some countries, we are against it for young teens in the Family as its fruit is more bad than good.
Liberty or Stumblingblock(After reading this four- pager, please destroy it immediately.
Liberty or Stumblingblock
Later Family publications say that in 1986 sexual contact between adults and minors was made an excommunicable offence. A 2000 letter by Maria instead says it was banned in 1986 and made excommunicable in 1988.
Sexual contact between adults and minors has been an excommunicable offense since 1986.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERSIt is clear that 14 years ago, in 1986, Dad and I put a ban on any adult/minor sexual activity. In 1988, 12 years ago, we made it excommunicable and it has remained so since then.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me ¶92
In the official statement "Child Abuse?!" Berg renounced any writings in the Family that seemed to approve sex with minors and forbade it.
We do not approve of sex with minors, and hereby renounce any writings of anyone in our Family which may seem to do so! We absolutely forbid it!
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE"We do not approve of sex with minors, & hereby renounce
CHILD ABUSE?!
In "Flirty Little Teens, Beware!" (ML 2590) Maria said that within the Family there would be "very little possibility of genuine abuse" from sex with minors, and gave illegality as the first reason for abstaining.
Sex with minors, which they always term "child abuse," although in our loving Family there would be very little possibility of genuine abuse.
ML 2590, Flirty Little Teens, Beware!--"Flee Youthful Lusts!"--2Tim.2:22 ¶25besides the fact that it is illegal & we must keep the System's rules
ML 2590, Flirty Little Teens, Beware!--"Flee Youthful Lusts!"--2Tim.2:22 ¶25
A public Family statement acknowledged that earlier publications seemed to condone adult-minor sexual contact and that members of some fellowships may have acted on them, while denying that children were involved in Flirty Fishing.
why did some of your former fellowships previously publish articles that seem to suggest that you condoned or even promoted sexual contact between adults and minors?
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSEcertain members of a few fellowships may have taken a literal interpretation of some of the controversial ideas expressed concerning sex and children
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE
An internal publication for leaders at Summit '93, attributed to Maria, said the Child Abuse Statement had not been forthright, and that sexual contact with minors was forbidden because it was illegal and had not borne good fruit, while maintaining it was not wrong in God's eyes.
I'm sorry that we couldn't come out a little more forthrightly in the Child Abuse Statement
Summit '93 Mama Jewels #2 ¶129But in the present moral climate of the World today it is wrong for us as it hurts the Work of God.
Summit '93 Mama Jewels #2 ¶133
"Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!" (ML 2858, by Peter Amsterdam and Apollos) said relationships between adults and anyone under 21 were prohibited, but that the Family did not believe all such relationships were "inherently wrong in principle" according to Scripture. It described age-of-consent laws as man-made.
we do not believe that all such relationships are inherently wrong in principle, according to the Scriptures.
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!Any thinking person can see that such rules & laws are man-made & are not absolute.
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!
Maria wrote that after complaints from young people in 1986 such contact was made an excommunicable offence, and that rules should have been in force much earlier.
In 1986 after some of our young people complained about some adult sexual contact, Dad and I slammed the door on any and all such activity by making it an excommunicable offense.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US ¶52we should have had rules in effect much earlier that would have prevented any of our children from being hurt.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US ¶52
In "An Answer to Him That Asketh Us" (ML 3016) Maria said that the freedoms of the Law of Love do not include sex with minors, that such sex is wrong, and that literature published earlier had opened the door to adult/minor contact.
the liberties we are granted under the Law of Love do not include sex with minors, that to have sex with minors is wrong.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US ¶46lit was published that challenged the barriers between adult/minor sexual contact, opening the door to some members crossing over that barrier.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US ¶51
In a letter to the judge in the UK case, reprinted for members, Peter Amsterdam acknowledged that proclaiming sexual liberty without clear rules had been wrong and that Berg's 1980 discourse "The Devil Hates Sex" had opened the door to sexual behaviour between adults and minors.
We acknowledge that it was wrong to proclaim a teaching of sexual liberty (i.e., in 1976 and 1978) without establishing clear rules to ensure that sexual contact did not take place between adults and children.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERSin 1980 Father David's statements in his discourse entitled 'The Devil Hates Sex' opened the door for sexual behavior between adults and minors
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
In a letter reprinted for members, Peter Amsterdam accepted the English court's request that the Family acknowledge Berg bore responsibility for harm to minors from ideas in his writings, naming "The Law of Love" and "The Devil Hates Sex".
And we accept that as the author of ideas upon which some members acted to the harm of minors in the Family, he must bear responsibility for that harm.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
The Family's policy statement forbids any sexual abuse or exploitation of children, and a 2000 publication restates that earlier writings were renounced and ordered destroyed.
We are diametrically opposed to any form of sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of children whatsoever
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sexhave been officially categorically renounced and forbidden, and all printed materials deemed objectionable have been ordered by our founder, Father David, to be removed from use and destroyed.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me
In "None of These Things Move Me" Maria said that all adult/minor sexual contact is sin, results in excommunication, and that this overrides anything written earlier.
all adult/minor sexual contact is sin. We consider it as such. It is wrong and results in excommunication.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me ¶94This overrides anything that was ever written suggesting otherwise.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me ¶93
Compared with historic Christianity
Part of Berg vs the Bible. Bible quotations are from public-domain translations.
The group taught
Between 1977 and 1980 Berg taught in Letters that children were made to enjoy sex, that God intended marriage at 12 or 13, and that there were "no relationship restrictions or age limitations" in the Law of Love. From about 1985 the leadership told members to stop adult-minor sexual contact, mainly because it was illegal. In 1988 Berg renounced writings that seemed to approve it, but as late as 1993 leaders said the Letters "weren't wrong" and that such relationships were not "inherently wrong in principle". Only from 1995 did the Family call adult-minor sex wrong and a sin and accept that Berg bore responsibility for harm to children.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches have always condemned the sexual use of children. Early Christian texts such as the Didache list the corruption of boys among grave sins alongside murder and adultery, and the churches teach that adults have a special duty to protect children. Modern Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant bodies treat the sexual abuse of minors as a grave sin and a crime that must be reported to civil authorities.
Where they differ
By the Family's own later account, some of Berg's publications raised the possibility of adult-minor sexual contact, which is wholly contrary to the historic consensus. The renunciations of 1988, the 1995-96 apologies and the 1998 policy bring the group's stated position into line with that consensus, though the 1992 statement still presented the earlier material mainly as an explanation rather than a doctrinal error.
Bible passages
But whoso shall offend one of these little ones which believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea.
And whosoever shall offend one of these little ones that believe in me, it is better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and he were cast into the sea.
For, brethren, ye have been called unto liberty; only use not liberty for an occasion to the flesh, but by love serve one another.
Flee fornication. Every sin that a man doeth is without the body; but he that committeth fornication sinneth against his own body.
Creeds and historic statements
- Didache, chapter 2 (J.B. Lightfoot translation, modern-English revision): “You shall do no murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not corrupt boys,”