Community and church authority
Honesty with outsiders: "deceivers yet true" and "Selah" security
From the early 1970s some colonies and Homes were "Selah", kept secret from outsiders for security, and members were told not to disclose their links to the group in such places. Berg taught, under the phrase "deceivers yet true" from 2 Corinthians 6:8, that lying or deceiving could be justified in emergencies such as saving a life. In 1983 he said honesty was the best policy and warned against needless lies, while allowing members to withhold or give a misleading impression of the truth for security.
How the teaching developed
By 1971 some colonies were designated "Selah" and were not named in the group's own reports.
possibly because some of them were supposed to be Selah. These could have been reported without naming them
ML 129, Details
In "Deceivers, Yet True!" Berg said God and his prophets had sometimes used deceit, and that lying to save a life was justified in extreme emergencies.
If you have to lie to save a life, I think it's worth it!
ML 1248, Deceivers, Yet True!But I certainly don't recommend it & it would be in the absolute extreme emergency
ML 1248, Deceivers, Yet True!
Berg told members that honesty was the best policy and warned against lying, while saying they need not tell the whole truth for security reasons.
I've always said that the truth is the best policy, honesty is the best policy. Lying is just not right!
ML 1400, To Lie? – Or Not To Lie? – That is the Question! ¶1You don't have to tell everything you know, & for the sake of security you don't always have to tell the whole Truth.
ML 1400, To Lie? – Or Not To Lie? – That is the Question!
A 1994 Persecution Jewels issue acknowledged that critics focused on the group's "deceivers yet true" teaching and replied that everybody lies at times.
Our enemies sure make a big deal about our little doctrine of "deceivers yet true"!
ML 2935, Persecution Jewels!--No.15
Compared with historic Christianity
Part of Berg vs the Bible. Bible quotations are from public-domain translations.
The group taught
From the early 1970s some colonies and Homes were "Selah", kept secret from outsiders for security, and members were told not to disclose their links to the group in such places. Berg taught, under the phrase "deceivers yet true" from 2 Corinthians 6:8, that lying or deceiving could be justified in emergencies such as saving a life. In 1983 he said honesty was the best policy and warned against needless lies, while allowing members to withhold or give a misleading impression of the truth for security.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that lying is sinful and that believers should speak the truth. Augustine held that every lie is a sin, and this strict view shaped much Western teaching; other writers allowed concealment, silence or (in some Catholic moral theology) mental reservation, and some Protestant ethicists have defended deception to protect life in extreme cases. 2 Corinthians 6:8 is usually read as describing how the apostles were wrongly regarded as deceivers, not as permission to deceive.
Where they differ
Berg's 1979 teaching that God and his prophets used lies, and his reading of "deceivers yet true" as a principle, differ from the mainstream reading of 2 Corinthians 6:8 and from the general prohibition of lying. His 1983 counsel to avoid lies but withhold or shade the truth for security resembles the minority traditions that allow concealment.
Bible passages
Wherefore putting away lying, speak every man truth with his neighbour: for we are members one of another.
Lie not one to another, seeing that ye have put off the old man with his deeds;
By honour and dishonour, by evil report and good report: as deceivers, and yet true;
Creeds and historic statements
- Augustine, Enchiridion, chapter 22 (about 420): “But every lie must be called a sin, because not only when a man knows the truth”