Sexual ethics and safeguarding
Berg's relationship with Maria while married to Jane ("Mother Eve")
Berg took Karen Zerby (Maria), who joined his household as a secretary in January 1969, as a sexual partner while he was still married to Jane Berg ("Mother Eve"), and kept the relationship hidden from members. At the time ordinary members could not date without permission, could marry only with the leaders' approval, and were taught that sex was for married couples. In their own later account, "Our Love Story!" (1978), Berg and Maria described how the relationship began and how Berg insisted Maria stay when Jane objected; Berg cast Jane as the "Old Church" and Maria as his new wife, language from his first Letter of 1969. A 1991 Family publication confirmed that in the early years sexual sharing was for married members only, except for a few leaders who kept it secret, and the 1995 English High Court judgment found that the early rules barred sex outside marriage with only leaders exempt. Members were told that sex needed no permission only in 1978.
How the teaching developed
Histories by critics and former members say that in 1969 Berg began taking young women in the group as "wives", among them Karen Zerby, and that he cast Jane, his wife and the mother of his children, as the "old church". One calls Maria Berg's "personal secretary and mistress".
In 1969, Berg had begun taking several young women in the group as "wives."
The History of the Children of GodJane, the wife and mother of his children, was the "old church"
The History of the Children of Godwho was David Berg's personal secretary and mistress
Brief Historical Outline of the COG
Berg's first Letter, a prophecy contrasting an "old" and a "new" church, spoke of God taking "a new bride" in place of one who was "barren".
I will have a new bride who will love Me and obey Me and do My will and bear Me children, no longer barren as she was
ML A, Old Church New Church
Berg himself acknowledged the contrast when rebuking leaders: younger members were asking why they could not do what the leaders were doing.
Your lack of wisdom along these lines has even CAUSED SOME OF THE YOUNGER ONES TO STUMBLE and ask if you can do what you're doing, why can't they indulge in extramarital sex and smoke grass!
ML 143, Personal Visits--(part I)--Sin In The Camp ¶27
At the same time, the group's rules for ordinary members allowed no dating without permission, and marriage only with the leaders' approval.
and absolutely no dating without permission.
ML 0S, The Revolutionary Rules ¶1First, the two of you must agree on it, then apply to your elders for their approval
ML 260, Revolutionary Marriage!
Only in 1978 did Berg tell all members that no permission was needed for sex.
NO PERMISSION NEEDED FOR SEX!--If legal and with mutual consent.
ML 663, Happy Rebirthday! – RNR Rules!
In "Our Love Story!", Berg and Maria recounted that Jane brought Maria back from Tucson as a secretary, that Berg took three months to persuade her to join his "harem", and that their sexual relationship began in his motorhome ("the Cruiser") while Jane was out with her team. When Jane found out and objected, Berg had both women sleep with him and told Jane that Maria would stay.
They told me dear Eve had brought us a new secretary back from Tucson
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1it just took me three months to persuade her to join my harem as a permanent member!
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1I think that was the first place we ever made love was at that table!
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1Every night we kept staying in the Cruiser & Mother Eve kept taking her team out somewhere, & we got a little more ardent all the time!
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1I stayed back under the pretext of working, & we did work at night.
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1I'm not going to have this woman taking my place
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1I insisted on both of them sleeping with me, one slept on one side & one slept on the other.
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1IF YOU WANT TO GO, THAT'S UP TO YOU, BUT MARIA STAYS!
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1Maria would scramble out of my bed as fast as she could & back up in the top bunk & pretend to be asleep!
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1
Berg recalled that Maria came in January 1969, that he and Maria kept their relationship hidden from members while he was still married to Jane, and that he had not told Jane how he meant to "use" the secretary she had brought him.
Maria came early, in January of '69
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1Of course I didn't tell her how I was going to use her!
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1We were trying to keep it pretty well undercover that Maria & I were together, because we didn't want to cause anybody with weak faith to stumble or anything
ML 1358, Our Love Story! ¶1
In 1983 Berg wrote that he had prayed to be delivered from Jane within weeks of their marriage, and called her the "Old Church, Old Wife" and Maria his "new" wife.
I hadn't been living with Eve more than a few weeks when I began to realise she was not the one!
ML 1474, It Wont Be Long Now! ¶72I asked the Lord, "My God, deliver me from this woman!"
ML 1474, It Wont Be Long Now! ¶72MOTHER EVE HAD BEEN OUR OLD CHURCH, Old Wife, but Maria was our new, beautiful, young, sexy, naked wife who loved sex & loved love-making & loved me wildly no matter what I did!
ML 1567, My Birthday Tribute to Maria! ¶272
A 1991 Family publication confirmed that for the group's first eight or nine years sex was for married members only, while a few leaders already had sexual freedom and kept it quiet.
For our first eight or nine years, there was very little if any sexual sharing within our Homes, except for those who were married
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships!there was no sharing, except in just a few rare cases by just a few leaders
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships!But these leaders usually kept these "All Things" affairs very "hush hush," thus the average Family Member knew nothing about them.
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships!
In the 1995 English custody judgment, Lord Justice Ward found that the early rules allowed no sexual involvement outside monogamous marriage, and that Berg made himself the exception.
I am not sure how Berg managed to make himself the exception to the rule but he found some scriptural justification for it.
Judgement of Lord Justice Wardthe liberty to engage in sexual relationships outside marriage was one taken only by the leaders
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
A 1996 Family paper on women in the group described Maria as Berg's wife who had started out as his personal secretary.
his wife Maria, who started out in the movement as his personal secretary
Women in The Family -- April 1996
Compared with historic Christianity
Part of Berg vs the Bible. Bible quotations are from public-domain translations.
The group taught
Berg took Karen Zerby (Maria), who joined his household as a secretary in January 1969, as a sexual partner while he was still married to Jane Berg ("Mother Eve"), and kept the relationship hidden from members. At the time ordinary members could not date without permission, could marry only with the leaders' approval, and were taught that sex was for married couples. In their own later account, "Our Love Story!" (1978), Berg and Maria described how the relationship began and how Berg insisted Maria stay when Jane objected; Berg cast Jane as the "Old Church" and Maria as his new wife, language from his first Letter of 1969. A 1991 Family publication confirmed that in the early years sexual sharing was for married members only, except for a few leaders who kept it secret, and the 1995 English High Court judgment found that the early rules barred sex outside marriage with only leaders exempt. Members were told that sex needed no permission only in 1978.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that marriage is an exclusive, lifelong union of one man and one woman, and treat sexual relations with someone other than one's spouse as adultery, a grave sin. They also hold church leaders to a stricter standard: the New Testament requires an overseer to be "the husband of one wife" and above reproach.
Where they differ
By Berg's and Maria's own published accounts, Berg began a sexual relationship with his secretary while married to Jane, kept it hidden from her at first, and then had both women share his bed over her objection. He later presented the change of partner in prophetic terms ("Old Church" and "new bride"). In the historic churches' teaching this is adultery, and it would disqualify a church leader.
Bible passages
Thou shalt not commit adultery.
Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not commit adultery: But I say unto you, That whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart.
Marriage is honourable in all, and the bed undefiled: but whoremongers and adulterers God will judge.
A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach;
Creeds and historic statements
- Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), chapter 24, section 1: “Marriage is to be between one man and one woman: neither is it lawful for any man to have more than one wife, nor for any woman to have more than one husband at the same time.”