Community and church authority
Child discipline
Berg taught corporal punishment with the rod, citing Proverbs, and gave detailed advice on spanking young children in the 1970s and 1980s, though he said it was not the best answer for teenagers. The 1994 "Family Discipline Guidelines" made corporal punishment the exception, with witnesses and an age limit, and in 1995 Maria apologised to young people who had been harshly disciplined, including by prolonged "silence restriction" and isolation. Under the Charter, violence towards one's children is an excommunicable offence.
How the teaching developed
Berg cited Proverbs in support of using the rod and not stopping a punishment because a child cries.
WHY DO YOU THINK GOD SAYS, "SPARE NOT THE ROD FOR HIS CRYING"? (Pr.19:18) They start yelling long before you sock them with the rod,
ML 1712, Home Discipline ¶12
Berg said he seldom used corporal punishment on his own grown teenagers because it was not the best solution for teen misbehaviour.
I VERY SELDOM USED CORPORAL PUNISHMENT ON MY OWN TEENS AFTER THEY BECAME GROWN.
ML 2064, Dad on "Kidz Correction" ¶1
The "Family Discipline Guidelines" made corporal punishment the exception, to be used only after other approaches had failed.
Corporal punishment should be the exception and should only be resorted to if other approaches have not succeeded in bringing about the needed improvement,
ML 2919, Family Discipline GuidelinesWe strongly suggest that after age 13 corporal punishment no longer be given,
ML 2919, Family Discipline Guidelines
The Charter's rule against violent acts, as quoted by the Family in 1998, covers violence towards one's spouse or children and makes it grounds for excommunication.
If a Family member were to become violent with their mate or children, they would face excommunication.
Our Stance Against Physical Violence
Maria apologised to young people who had been disciplined harshly, naming excessive corporal punishment, prolonged "silence restriction" and isolation.
We have heard a number of testimonies of past excessive corporal punishment, prolonged "silence restriction" and/or isolation,
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US ¶54It was wrong, and we are truly sorry that any of you received any such treatment.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US ¶54
Compared with historic Christianity
Part of Berg vs the Bible. Bible quotations are from public-domain translations.
The group taught
Berg taught corporal punishment with the rod, citing Proverbs, and gave detailed advice on spanking young children in the 1970s and 1980s, though he said it was not the best answer for teenagers. The 1994 "Family Discipline Guidelines" made corporal punishment the exception, with witnesses and an age limit, and in 1995 Maria apologised to young people who had been harshly disciplined, including by prolonged "silence restriction" and isolation. Under the Charter, violence towards one's children is an excommunicable offence.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach that parents have a God-given duty to train and correct their children, drawing on Proverbs and on Paul's command that fathers bring up children "in the nurture and admonition of the Lord" without provoking them. Traditionally this was understood to permit moderate physical correction, while forbidding cruelty and anger. Churches today differ on corporal punishment: many Protestant bodies still allow it, while others, and recent Catholic teaching, stress non-violent discipline.
Where they differ
Berg's teaching on the rod echoes the traditional reading of Proverbs. The Family's 1994 guidelines and Maria's 1995 apology move towards the emphasis on restraint found in Ephesians 6:4 and Colossians 3:21; practices such as prolonged "silence restriction" and isolation, which Maria later called wrong, have no basis in the historic tradition.
Bible passages
He that spareth his rod hateth his son: but he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes.
And, ye fathers, provoke not your children to wrath: but bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.
Fathers, provoke not your children to anger, lest they be discouraged.
Now no chastening for the present seemeth to be joyous, but grievous: nevertheless afterward it yieldeth the peaceable fruit of righteousness unto them which are exercised thereby.
Creeds and historic statements
- Didache, chapter 4 (J.B. Lightfoot translation, modern-English revision; numbered 4:12 on this page): “You shall not withhold your hand from your son or daughter, but from their youth you shall teach them the fear of God.”