Community and church authority
Obedience to leaders and shepherds
Berg ran the movement as an "army" and taught that members owed obedience and loyalty to leaders placed over them. He also wrote in 1988 that obedience was not absolute above Scripture and conscience. The Family's later Charter, as explained by Peter Amsterdam in 1998, set written limits on leaders' authority alongside discipline for those who broke its rules.
How the teaching developed
Berg said that members owed leaders allegiance and obedience as long as their overseers left them in charge, whatever their mistakes.
IF THEY CONTINUE TO BE LEFT IN CHARGE BY THEIR OVERSEERS, THEN YOU CONTINUE TO OWE THEM YOUR ALLEGIANCE, RESPECT, AND OBEDIENCE.
ML 143, Personal Visits--(part I)--Sin In The Camp ¶18
Berg wrote that obedience to leaders was not an absolute to be placed above reason, Scripture and conscience.
I still do not believe that these are total absolutes which must be put above reason, right, Scripture & personal conviction of God's Truth!
ML 2417, Obey Them That Have the Rule Over You!--"Trust and Obey," Pt. 2
A 1989 Letter told members to obey the rules of their officers as they would obey God.
if you want to obey God, you'd better obey us, & not just think it's some kind of an optional thing once you've joined the Army.
ML 2522, We're an Army!--A Sobering Lesson on Obeying God's Rules!
Peter Amsterdam wrote that the Charter restricts leaders' authority, while also requiring discipline for those who break its rules.
there are restrictions on the authority of leadership, and we have put that in place to keep our leadership from exercising too much authority over Homes and individuals, as some have in the past.
ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities
Compared with historic Christianity
Part of Berg vs the Bible. Bible quotations are from public-domain translations.
The group taught
Berg ran the movement as an "army" and taught that members owed obedience and loyalty to leaders placed over them. He also wrote in 1988 that obedience was not absolute above Scripture and conscience. The Family's later Charter, as explained by Peter Amsterdam in 1998, set written limits on leaders' authority alongside discipline for those who broke its rules.
Historic Christianity
Historic Christian churches teach respect and obedience toward rightful church leaders, citing passages such as Hebrews 13:17. They also teach that leaders are servants who must not lord it over the flock, and that God's commands come before human ones. Protestant confessions add that God alone is Lord of the conscience.
Where they differ
Berg taught strong obedience to leaders, at times equating it with obeying God, though in 1988 he said it was not absolute. Historic churches also ask for obedience to church leaders but place it under Scripture and conscience.
Bible passages
Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit yourselves: for they watch for your souls, as they that must give account, that they may do it with joy, and not with grief: for that is unprofitable for you.
Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men.
Neither as being lords over God's heritage, but being ensamples to the flock.
Creeds and historic statements
- Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), chapter XX, section 2: “God alone is lord of the conscience, and hath left it free from the doctrines and commandments of men”