Magazine article
Duke Magazine, Dec, 1970
Summary. A December 1970 magazine feature by Si Bloom, printed under the heading 'The Love Nuts' in Duke Magazine. In a humorous tone, it recounts stories of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century American religious communities and their leaders' sexual teachings, among them the Shakers, the Oneida community of John Humphrey Noyes and the followers of James Strang and Thomas Lake Harris. The article does not mention the Children of God.
Drafted with AI assistance from the item's text; not yet reviewed by an editor.
This is an outside publication, reproduced from the copy kept by an earlier archive for research and reference. Copyright remains with the original author or publisher.
DUKE MAGAZINE
December 1970
THE LOVE NUTS
Screwloose Prophets & Friends
By Si Bloom
On a hillside in central Illinois approximately sixty people gathered to listen to the "divine" word of the Invisible Presence. The men were heavily bearded and most of them wore the work clothes of farmers of the 1850's. The women, in their flowing but plain hoopskirts and modest bonnets, whispered excitedly to one another as they eagerly awaited the "inspired" words.
The Invisible Presence really was invisible, for he had withdrawn inside a life-size Ark which his disciples had built for him, and had resolved never again to be seen by human hands.
"Lo, I have had a revelation," he intoned. "It shall come to pass that there shall be born unto a virgin of our community a Messiah."
Fear and trembling from the audience.
"Yea, verily, a second Messiah," the Presence continued. "But first it shall come to pass that the virgin shall come unto me on the Ark in the dark of night. And I shall be the father of this Messiah."
More trembling from the faithful.
"And every virgin in her turn shall come to me," the Presence resumed. "And one among her, I know not which, shall be the mother of the Messiah."
Obviously phony? Well, of course. But the point is, the naive little group, which called itself the New Jerusalem, really believed the Invisible Presence. It never occurred to them to doubt for a moment that the Presence, who was really a faker named Curry Spragg, was telling them anything but the word of God.
And so, one after another, the virgins of New Jerusalem visited Spragg by night on the Ark. And one after another, he enjoyed and impregnated each of them.
One night, a jealous lover murdered Spragg, disposed of the body and escaped. And the interesting twist: Before the members of the New Jerusalem learned of the murder two smart young males decided to have a little fun by impersonating the Invisible Presence. For a while, they really had it made, until a few of the more knowledgeable females began to suspect that something new had been added. When the gals blew the whistle on the fraud that was being perpetrated, the New Jerusalem collapsed. But it was fun while it lasted.
All of which proves that, contrary to what many people think, free and easy sex was not invented by the hippies. A hundred years ago there were Yankee sex kooks who can be considered the rightful ancestors of today's make-out generation. There was only one difference: Whereas today's kids don't bother to look for excuses for their sex attitudes, the kooks of a century ago found it necessary to disguise their desires as religion, since they knew they couldn't sell just plain sex. They therefore dreamed up entire theologies as special vehicles for their way-out yens- theologies that usually ended up in hanky panky. The only trouble was that the hanky panky was often reserved for the leaders only. The rest of the boys in the sect were often restricted by weird rules and regulations that made it difficult for them to make out.
Consider, if you will, the antics of James Strang, the renegade Mormon preacher, in 1849, barnstormed to Eastern seaboard cities accompanied by his mistress, Elvira Field, disguised as his male secretary. In a dingy hotel room in Hartford, Connecticut, Strang smiled as he watched Elvira remove one by one, the items of male attire she was wearing.
"I want you to return with me to the Kingdom of Zion, on Big Bear Island," Strang said, holding Elvira close to him.
She smiled and returned his kiss. "I shall be happy to," she replied, "but what of Mary, your wife? How will she receive me?"
Strang looked at her the way he'd been looking at women ever since he was ten years old.
"My child," he said, "in the Kingdom of Zion a man may take several wives. We ask not how many. We ask only that he cherish and care for them. Do you understand?"
As she yielded to his embrace, Strang blew out the kerosene lamp.
On his return to his religious colony of 3,000 on Big Bear Island in Lake Michigan, Strang planned an amazing reversal of religious principle. He was, of course, not only married to Mary, but the father of several children by her. On the other hand, lushly built Elvira was too good to pass up. Could he divorce Mary? Hardly. But there was a way out.
He would have a revelation, during which "God" would command the Kingdom of Zion to practice polygamy, thus enabling Strang to have his cake and eat it, too. And lo, this is exactly what came to pass! No matter that Strang had been thundering against polygamy all his life. "God" had taken him aside and made him see the error of his ways.
Strang actually quoted from his "divine" revelation:
"All ages have shown an excess of women over men. As a result, many women have either been denied the sacred right of motherhood, or have been forced to marry inferior males. But in the lands where men may have several wives, healthy and intelligent women need not remain childless."
And now, "God" laid down the law to this new Moses:
"Therefore do I command my servant James to tell my people that the more wives a man hath, the more he shall prosper in Paradise."
How do you like them apples?
And to prove how earnestly he was obeying the "divine" will, Strang lived with five wives under the same roof. Each had her own quarters, each spent her fair share of time alone with hubby. He made only one demand of them: They had to eat and pray together.
Most of these phony prophets and religious fakers can be divided into two categories: those who were all for lots of sex and free love and those who preached celibacy and the evils of sex- for everyone but themselves.
In the 1830's, for example, Charles Finney's New England Perfectionists had a whimsical notion about the pleasures of the bedroom. They believed that man could only attain perfection in the face of maximum temptation. And what greater temptation than sex? So, after prayer meetings, the male and female Perfectionists began sleeping together just to see how much temptation they could really resist. Unfortunately, the flesh was a good deal weaker than the spirit. However, since statistics and complete records are lacking, we can only venture an educated guess as to what really went on in the name of sweet Perfection.
And now, consider Benjamin Purnell, founder of the House of David, who called himself the Younger Brother of Jesus. "Sexual intercourse must be avoided like the plague!" he thundered to the brethren and sistern. He got himself so worked up he just had to show a group of pretty parishioners just how evil sex could really be. So, while the men in the church starved for lovin', Purnell kept his own private harem, to whom he gave sex lessons- sometimes in private, sometimes in groups. It depended on his mood.
The strange thing about these Yankee sex kooks was that they managed to hornswoggle an amazing number of Americans into following their nutty religious theories, even to the extent of giving up their homes and following blindly wherever they were led.
Think the hippies are way out? In the 1830's, a man named John Humphrey Noyes preached that men should share their wives. "In a holy community," he thundered, "there is no more reason why sexual intercourse should be restrained by law than why eating and drinking should be!"
But Noyes was smart enough to realize that promiscuous sex relations could lead to an army of illegitimate children, so he taught what he called the doctrine of male continuence. In this difficult form of contraception the male abstains from ejaculation during a sexual contact. He does this purely by self-control, a talent the Noyes men seemed to have refined to such a degree that they could continue the sex act for hours without ever reaching a climax. How the women liked this technique we have no way of knowing.
But even more ingenious were the elaborate set of rules Noyes worked out for everyday polygamous living.
To begin with, a man could call on any woman he please, married or single. This was not only legal, it was encouraged. And all courting was usually done in the lady's bedroom.
When a man saw a woman he liked, he was supposed to make a verbal application to a special committee which acted as a sort of Court of Matchmaking. If the committee gave you their O.K. you could call on the lady of your choice and even stay all night with her, often sleeping three in a bed- along with her husband, naturally.
But if you were so impatient you couldn't wait for the committee's permission, it was all right to go ahead on your own, provided you made your application later.
The big sin, according to Noyes, was jealousy- possesiveness- wanting a woman for your own, instead of generously sharing her with your neighbor.
Noyes also had unusual ideas on the sex education of the young, notions which would give fits to every PTA in today's U.S.A. The course began with a series of introductory lectures on sex by Noyes himself. But that was only the beginning.
Then came the laboratory or practical part. Adolescent boys were taught the elements of sex by having relations with women members who were past the menopause. Girls were initiated by the older and more mature men of the colony, including- you guessed it- Noyes himself, who gave liberally of his time and energy in the good cause.
The only problem was the younger generation. They had their own ideas. They didn't like having sex with older people, much preferring their own age-group, for which you couldn't blame them. In addition, they were jealous and possessive. They didn't like passing their lovers around.
George Bernard Shaw called Noyes a genius. But many people still consider him a Yankee sex kook. It all depends on your point of view.
Then there was Thomas Lake Harris, who, in the 1860's, set up a nutty sex-colony in Broeton, New York- a settlement so crummy, unhygienic and way-out sexually that today's hippies seem clean and normal by comparison. The New York State legislature very nearly disbanded the colony as a public nuisance.
Harris really believed that little fairies lived in the breasts of women, where they sang songs, danced and had little cities and governments. Yet this weirdie actually persuaded 60 Americans to give him all their worldly possessions and live according to his crackpot dictates. One disciple, a prominent socialite, gave him $75,000. Another, an Englishman and a member of Parliament, forked over $100,000.
Harris did things like order a member of his sect to have relations with five different female members in one day. Harris himself had regular sex with no less than nine of his female disciples and was accused of relations with a 15-year-old girl.
Once, when a newly arrived female convert inquired about the identity of Lily Queen, one of the goddesses of the Harris sect, the mad preacher replied:
"Lily Queen is our Supreme Being. We all worship and adore her."
"But how do I pray to her?" the young lady persisted.
"You are to go to my room and get in bed with Lily Queen," Harris told her, resting his hand on the lady's arm affectionately. For a few seconds there was silence while she digested the suggestion. Then she asked the important question:
"While I am in bed with Lily Queen, Dr. Harris, what do you do?"
"Well, Lily Queen is inside of me," Harris said with a straight face, "and I, of course, stay in bed with you. By getting into my arms, you get into her arms, too. Understand, my dear?"
Harris learned a good deal about free love from the Robert Owens colony at New Harmony, Indiana, where, way back in the 1820's, they practiced love ‘em and leave ‘em and also onanism, which, according to the Bible, was the method of contraception preferred by Onan, who cast his seed upon the ground.
Owens planned a society in which the state would bring up all children, thus leaving adults free to love and change spouses whenever they pleased. He, too, believed in passing women around, or sharing the sex, as it were.
And just in case you think that love between the white and black races is relatively new, the Frances Wright sect, at Nashoba, Mississippi, was doing it about a hundred and fifty years ago.
In the Wright colony, marriages were arranged by a committee of elders. And when, on occasion, several candidates were named to be somebody's wife, lots were drawn to determine the winner.
If John Noyes and Thomas Harris were the extremes of sexual excess, the Shakers were the last word in sexual repression.
Led first by Ann Lee and later by Lucy Wright, the Shakers were so afraid of sex that their buildings had separate stairways so men and women wouldn't have to pass each other on the stairs.
The daily Shaker routine points up just how frightened of sex these poor people really were:
Every morning the men rose first and dressed with their backs to the center of the room, to avoid seeing each other in the nude. Then they marched out. One hour later, the women rose- a time lapse intentionally planned so they wouldn't see the men marching out with their chamber pots- a sight which might give the gals sexual thoughts.
Other Shaker anti-sex rules included the following:
If a Shaker had to shake hands with a "world's person" of the opposite sex, he had to report this contact to an elder before attending the next prayer meeting.
Men and women were not allowed to speak to each other unless a third party above the age of ten was present.
Cards left in the bedroom of visitors to Shaker villages asked married couples to abstain from physical relations while under the Shaker roof.
But just in case you've gotten the wrong idea, it wasn't marriage the Shakers objected to- just sexual intercourse. What they forgot was that you can't have one without the other...which is why there are no Shakers today.
An interesting ancestor of the Shakers was Jemima Wilkins, who, back in the 1780's, founded a sect she called- believe it or not- the Jemimakins. She, too, believed you could get married all right, but you had to stay away from sex relations with our mate. How you did this Jemima never explained. In fact, there was all kinds of talk about Jemima and a handsome British army officer.
A frequent diversion of Jemima's was to dress in a man's flowing cape and slouch hat and ride through the countryside on a white horse.
She called herself the Publick Universal Friend.
And let us not forget Father Rapp, founder of a sect that flourished from 1812 until 1832, in the communities of Harmony and Economy, Pa. Rapp's doctrine was that, since Adam had originally been a celibate and had gotten himself in trouble only when he dallied with Eve, the Rappites too should be celibates when it came to sex. People could marry, if they wished, but no hanky panky. Violations were punished by expulsion from the colony.
Father Rapp was a controversial figure. Some people called him a saint; others described him as a tyrant, a slaveholder and a dabbler in alchemy and Satanism. He was even accused of ordering the death of his own son for rebellious behavior.
In 1832, another sex kook, who called himself Count Leon, corrupted the Rappites with vivid tales of the joys of the marital bed. One hundred and seventy-six of the faithful deserted, followed the Count and formed their own colony. It marked the end of Father Rapp's little empire.
Mention should also be made of Cyrus R. Teed, another of the fakers who founded religious colonies based on celibacy for all but themselves. Calling himself God's Messenger, Teed set up his community in the 1890's, on a tract of land in Florida, given to him by a disciple. Here he lived in high style with three of his female disciples, who doubled as concubines, while the rest of the colony did without.
It is noteworthy that three-quarters of his followers were women and that all the faithful freely gave Teed everything they possessed. In addition, they accepted every word he preached, including the following Teedism:
"The earth is a sphere, but it is hollow, and man lives inside it with his feet pointing outward from the center, and with the horizon curving upwards on all sides, instead of downwards."
From which we conclude that the more you learn about the kooks who founded some of these way-out cults the more you decide that nothing about them is surprising- unless it is the number of people they were able to bamboozle. It seems that all they had to do was ask and they received, proving that there is no leader so flaky he can't find other flaky people to follow him.
In the early days of the Republic, these way-out tubthumpers founded so-called religions as masks for their own sexual desires. Today, similar weirdies start Anti-This-Or-That groups, hate clubs, or even lonely hearts societies. But it's still the same idea. Today's psycho would be yesterday's cult leader. We'd find his name on the list of Yankee Sex Kooks.