Beliefs and practices
The Law of Love: What It Taught and How It Was Used
What was the Law of Love in the Children of God?
The Law of Love was David Berg's teaching that, for believers, love replaced the law of Moses, so that whatever was done in unselfish love was lawful before God. From 1973 Berg applied it to sex, and it became the basis for sexual sharing among members and for Flirty Fishing. After years of documented harm, including the sexual abuse of children, the group added age and consent rules from 1986 onward but kept the principle itself.
Overview: what was the Law of Love?
The Law of Love held that Christians are freed from the Ten Commandments and the law of Moses, and that the only law left for them is love. In Berg's words, whatever was done in love was "lawful as far as God is concerned". The teaching was not limited to sex, but sex was where it made the movement most different from other Christian groups, and where it did the most damage.
- Official teaching
We have been freed from the bondage of the condemnation of sin by the law of love in Christ Jesus, so that if it is in love it is lawful as far as God is concerned.
ML 258, Revolutionary Sex - Official teaching
Whatever you do in love is the law--and that's all, that's it! God's only law is Love!
ML 592, God’s Only Law is Love! – What the Bible Says About True Free Love!
This article separates three things that are often run together: what the group's publications taught, what members reported doing, and what courts and the group itself later found. Sexual contact between adults and children is treated in its own section, because it was never simply an extension of adult practice: it was a separate harm, later banned and acknowledged.
Historical origins: when and why did it emerge?
Berg built the teaching on Paul's words that "all things are lawful" (1 Corinthians 6:12) and on New Testament passages saying that love fulfils the law. A Family history published in 1991 says Berg received the revelation about "All Things" around 1970 but shared it with the membership only in 1974.
- The group’s own account
It was in 1974, four years after Grandpa had first received the revelation about "All Things" that the Lord led him to share the news of this liberty in the Lord with the Family.
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships! - Official teaching
All of the many Scriptures on "all things" make it very clear that whatsoever is done in love is not sin, is no longer considered sin.
ML 2835, Why Do Ye Stone Us?
The first published statement was the Letter "Revolutionary Sex" (March 1973), followed by "The Law of Love" (March 1974). The same 1991 history says that by 1974 Berg and Maria had come to see sex as a tool for winning outsiders, which became Flirty Fishing.
- Official teaching
so that if it is in love it is lawful as far as God is concerned
ML 258, Revolutionary Sex - The group’s own account
meeting others' needs for love, romance & sex could even be used as a tool to reach & witness to & win outsiders to the Lord
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships!
Official doctrine: what did the documents say?
"The Law of Love" (1974) set out tests for any relationship: was it good for God's work, for the group and for the person? It said that sexual relationships outside the norm should have the willing consent of everyone affected, including the approval of leaders.
- Official teaching
3) Is it good for You? Does it glorify God, His Body and edify your own soul?
ML 302C, The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”! - Official teaching
any projected sexual associations SHOULD HAVE THE WILLING CONSENT OF ALL parties concerned or affected, including the approval of leadership and permission of the Body.
ML 302C, The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”!
In 1977 Berg went further. "God's Only Law Is Love" told members that they no longer had to keep the Ten Commandments. A reply he wrote to a newspaper the same month put the conditions as love, mutual consent and no harm to an innocent person.
- Official teaching
NO, WE DO NOT HAVE TO KEEP THE TEN COMMANDMENTS! For us they are no more! For us they are gone forever! Thank God!
ML 592, God’s Only Law is Love! – What the Bible Says About True Free Love! - Official teaching
As long therefore as it is in love with mutual consent and hurts no innocent one, it is lawful, according to God's own Word and His own Son, Jesus Christ!
ML 591, The 51 Errors of “Daily Notices”! – Of Santa Cruz, Tenerife, Canary Islands
Berg applied the teaching to marriage. In 1976 he said marriage made no difference to sharing partners with others for the Lord's work, and presented the sharing of his own wife as an example of sacrifice.
- Official teaching
Marriage makes NO difference whatsoever when it comes to sharing each other with the Lord & His work & others.
ML 1395, Real Love! – Sharing All! – Even Tho’ Married!
Distinctive features: how did it differ from mainstream Christianity?
Theological analysis: most Christian traditions agree that believers are not saved by keeping the law and that love fulfils the law. They do not conclude from this that acts the moral commandments forbid, such as adultery, become lawful when done in love. Historic churches read Paul's "all things are lawful" together with his next words, "but all things are not expedient", and with his warning not to use liberty as an excuse for sin.
- Theological analysis
All things are lawful unto me, but all things are not expedient: all things are lawful for me, but I will not be brought under the power of any.
1 Corinthians 6:12 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound? God forbid. How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein?
Romans 6:1-2 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
yet notwithstanding, no Christian man whatsoever is free from the obedience of the Commandments which are called Moral.
Thirty-Nine Articles (1571), Article VII ↗
Two features set Berg's version apart even from other antinomian movements in church history. It was tied to recruitment, through Flirty Fishing, and it was placed under leadership approval, so that a supposedly personal freedom also became a matter of organisational policy. A fuller comparison of the doctrine with the Bible is in Berg vs the Bible.
- Official teaching
including the approval of leadership and permission of the Body
ML 302C, The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”!
Practical application: how was it meant to shape members' lives?
According to the group's own 1991 history, sexual freedom under the Law of Love became general practice in the Homes after the 1978 reorganisation known as the RNR. Sexual sharing between members of a Home was presented as a sacrifice and an expression of love.
- The group’s own account
After the famous "RNR" (Reorganisation, Nationalisation Revolution) of 1978.
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships!
Flirty Fishing (FFing) applied the teaching to outsiders: members, mostly women, used sexual attraction and often sex to win converts and supporters. The 1995 English High Court judgment accepted that taking part was voluntary, but found that members were under very great pressure to do so. It also found that the group had been living in part on the earnings of prostitution. See the separate article on sexuality and marriage for Flirty Fishing in full.
- Legal finding
I accept that it was voluntary and that Berg had "said time and time again, FFing is not for everybody.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
There was, however, very great pressure on the disciples to take part in this "ministry."
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
They were knowingly living in part on the earnings of prostitution.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Practice varied. The publications do not show that every Home put every teaching into effect, and firsthand accounts differ by decade, country and Home. What the record does show is that the teaching was official, was repeated over many years and was backed by reporting systems and leadership expectations.
Historical development: how did it change?
Restrictions came in stages. In 1983 Berg supported a ban on sex between members of different Homes at area meetings, to stop the spread of disease. In September 1987 sex with newly met outsiders was banned and Flirty Fishing ended, with AIDS given as one reason.
- Official teaching
I THINK WE OUGHT TO MAKE IT A RULE TO BAN ALL INTER-HOME SEX AT ANY AREA FELLOWSHIPS to prevent catching or spreading disease
ML 1434, Ban the Bomb! – Inter-Home Sex! – And Its Bums & Bugs! - Leadership instruction
NOW THAT DAD HAS BANNED SEX WITH NEWLY-MET OUTSIDERS
ML 2346, Mama on the New AIDS Rules - Legal finding
As the spectre of Aids loomed over the world, Berg officially put an end to FFing in September 1987
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The principle itself was kept. After Summit '93 the leadership told members that the Family still believed in the Law of Love as much as ever, even though it no longer practised all its past freedoms. The 1995 Love Charter was presented as the structure through which members would live it.
- Leadership instruction
we still believe in the principles of the Law of Love as much as ever!
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love! - Leadership instruction
The Charter is the mechanism by which we can live the Law of Love.
ML 2963, THE LOVE CHARTER
The group's policy statement on sex, first issued in 1993 and updated in 1998, keeps the Law of Love as a principle members should strive to follow, now bounded by age rules and by the Charter.
- Later response by the group
All members shall strive to adhere to the principle that we refer to as the Law of Love.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Later response by the group
(Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex was first published March 1993 and updated November 1998.)
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex
Controversies and consequences
The gravest consequence was the sexual abuse of children. Peter Amsterdam, writing for the leadership in 1996, acknowledged that it had been wrong to proclaim sexual liberty without clear rules to prevent sexual contact between adults and children, and that Berg's 1980 discourse "The Devil Hates Sex" had opened the door to it.
- Later response by the group
We acknowledge that it was wrong to proclaim a teaching of sexual liberty (i.e., in 1976 and 1978) without establishing clear rules to ensure that sexual contact did not take place between adults and children.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Later response by the group
in 1980 Father David's statements in his discourse entitled 'The Devil Hates Sex' opened the door for sexual behavior between adults and minors
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
In 1995 Lord Justice Ward, after hearing evidence in an English custody case, found that there had been widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members, and that Berg bore responsibility for the doctrine that misled his followers. The same judgment found that the group had made determined efforts since 1986 to stop such abuse.
- Legal finding
I am totally satisfied that there was widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members of The Family
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Berg bears responsibility for propagating the doctrine which so grievously misled his flock and injured the children within it.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
has since 1986 made determined and sustained efforts to stamp out child sexual abuse and to prevent any inappropriate contact between adults and children
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The group's responses were not consistent. In 1988 Berg's tract "Child Abuse?!" renounced any writings that seemed to approve sex with minors, while claiming the group had never practised it. In 1993 a leadership statement banned all adult-minor contact but said this was because of the law, not because all such contact was necessarily a sin in God's eyes. Only in 1995 did Maria write plainly that sex with minors is wrong and that Berg bore responsibility for the harm.
- Later response by the group
"We do not approve of sex with minors, & hereby renounce
CHILD ABUSE?! - Disputed allegation
but we do not advocate nor practice sex between adults & minors!—And never have!
CHILD ABUSE?! - Leadership instruction
is not because we believe that all such contact is in itself necessarily a sin or crime in the eyes of God.
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love! - Later response by the group
the liberties we are granted under the Law of Love do not include sex with minors, that to have sex with minors is wrong.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US - Later response by the group
without clearly stated explicit restrictions that prohibited all sexual activity between adults and minors, it resulted in actions that caused harm to some children. He must therefore bear responsibility for the harm.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US
Among adults, critics and former members describe pressure to take part in sharing and Flirty Fishing, and the strain it placed on marriages. The leadership itself wrote in 2001 that there were still serious problems in how the sexual side of the Law of Love was practised.
- Leadership instruction
Hundreds of pages have been published on the Law of Love, and yet there are some serious problems in the implementation of the sexual side of it.
GN 965, Personal Checklist -- GN965
Sources and the limits of the evidence
The main primary sources are Berg's Letters "Revolutionary Sex" (1973), "The Law of Love" (1974) and "God's Only Law Is Love" (1977); the 1993 leadership statement on the Law of Love; the 1995 Love Charter; Maria's 1995 letter "An Answer to Him That Asketh Us"; and the 1993/1998 policy statement on sex. The main legal source is Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment, which examined many of these documents alongside testimony.
- Official teaching
AS IN MARRIAGE AND ALL OTHER SOCIAL RELATIONSHIPS WITH EACH OTHER, GOD'S LAWS OF LOVE ARE STILL THE SAME:
ML 302C, The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”! - Legal finding
THE RT. HON. LORD JUSTICE WARD DATED 19TH OCTOBER 1995
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The dates of some reforms are disputed in the group's own sources. Later publications give 1985, 1986 and 1988 for when adult-minor contact became grounds for expulsion. This article gives the range rather than choosing one.
- Later response by the group
Sexual contact between adults and minors has been an excommunicable offense since 1986.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Later response by the group
In 1988, 12 years ago, we made it excommunicable and it has remained so since then.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me
From teaching to reform
How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.
Berg teaches that love replaces the law of Moses and that whatever is done in love is lawful, including sex outside marriage.
- Official teaching
so that if it is in love it is lawful as far as God is concerned
ML 258, Revolutionary Sex - Official teaching
NO, WE DO NOT HAVE TO KEEP THE TEN COMMANDMENTS!
ML 592, God’s Only Law is Love! – What the Bible Says About True Free Love!
- Official teaching
Sexual sharing becomes general in the Homes after 1978, and Flirty Fishing is practised with outsiders under strong pressure to take part.
- The group’s own account
After the famous "RNR" (Reorganisation, Nationalisation Revolution) of 1978.
ML 2718, Questions and Answers on Sex, Freedoms and Relationships! - Legal finding
There was, however, very great pressure on the disciples to take part in this "ministry."
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- The group’s own account
Without clear rules, some adults sexually abused children; disease spreads among adults and marriages come under strain.
- Legal finding
I am totally satisfied that there was widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members of The Family
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Official teaching
to prevent catching or spreading disease
ML 1434, Ban the Bomb! – Inter-Home Sex! – And Its Bums & Bugs!
- Legal finding
Adult-minor contact becomes an excommunicable offence (dates given vary from 1985 to 1988); Flirty Fishing ends in 1987; in 1995 Maria says sex with minors is wrong and apologises; the 1998 policy keeps the principle under age rules.
- Later response by the group
We are sorry that we didn't and we're truly sorry if any of you young people were hurt as a result of it.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US - Later response by the group
No sexual activity is permitted for those under the age of 14.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Later response by the group
members over the age of 21 will be excommunicated for engaging in sexual activity with those under the age of 21.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex
- Later response by the group
How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.