Teachings vs. Experiences

Inside the Children of God: Official Teachings vs. Members' Lived Experiences

What was life like inside the Children of God?

Life inside the Children of God varied greatly by decade, country, Home and generation, but most members lived communally, gave their time to missionary work and lived under strong expectations of obedience to David Berg's Letters and to leaders. Many describe real faith, friendship and purpose; many others, especially children raised in the group in the 1970s to early 1990s, describe separation from parents, harsh discipline, sexual abuse and limited education, and a 1995 English High Court judgment confirmed much of this. These comparison pages set what the group taught beside what members experienced, what courts found and how the group later responded.

What was taught, and what members experienced

Overview: what was life like inside the Children of God?

For most of its history the movement was a network of communal Homes in dozens of countries. Members shared money and possessions, witnessed and raised funds on the streets, read Berg's Letters and moved often. The 1995 English High Court judgment, which looked back over 25 years, noted that "many, many thousands" of people of many nationalities had belonged, living "in communities large and small and in countries near and far".

There is no single answer to what it was like. Former members themselves disagree: a 1996 open letter from the leadership noted that some look back on their time as positive and others as harmful. A teenager who gave evidence against the group in 1995 told the court: "I know there were things which were totally wrong but there were also happy times."

What the evidence does show is a recurring gap between the group's ideals and some members' lives. Ideals of love, family and freedom sat beside teachings that placed the group above private families, required obedience and, for a period, allowed sexual contact with children. Courts, scholars and the group itself have since documented both the harm and later reforms.

  • Official teaching There are no relationship restrictions or age limitations in His law of love. ML 999, The Devil Hates Sex
  • Legal finding Whereas the blame for the abuse which has occurred is to be laid at Berg's door, the credit for effecting change most probably can be given to Maria. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Why compare teaching with experience?

Publications alone can mislead in two directions. A policy on paper does not show that every Home followed it, and a harmful practice may never have been written down as policy. Testimony alone can mislead too, since one person's Home was not everyone's. Comparing the two shows where harm came from teaching, where it came from local leaders, and where the group's public account differed from what happened.

  • Legal finding I must not fall into the trap of attributing collective responsibility to The Family as a group when the faults and failings are those of an individual or individuals or even a commune or more than one commune. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

The comparison also matters because the group's own statements changed. Between 1988 and 1993 it publicly denied things it later acknowledged; in 1995 and 1996 its leaders apologised and accepted David Berg's responsibility for harm to children. Reading teaching, practice and response side by side lets readers see that change instead of only one moment in it.

  • Disputed allegation but we do not advocate nor practice sex between adults & minors!—And never have! CHILD ABUSE?! (12/88) · the group's 1988 claim, contradicted by its own later statements and by the 1995 judgment
  • Later response by the group And we accept that as the author of ideas upon which some members acted to the harm of minors in the Family, he must bear responsibility for that harm. ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS (2/96)

Experiences varied by decade, country, Home and generation

By decade. The early 1970s were colonies of young converts under a chain of leaders. After the 1978 reorganisation (the RNR) Homes scattered and shrank: in 1982 the group's own statistics gave an average Home size of 4.4 people. From 1988 Berg's "School Vision" gathered children into large schools and teen Homes. Just before the 1995 Love Charter the average Charter Home had 33 members, falling to 13.3 by early 1998. In 2010 TFI ended its communal model altogether.

By country and Home. A woman who lived in England, Greece, the United States, India and Thailand between 1972 and 1986 found leadership in England "fairly loose" compared with Asia. The 1995 judgment, too, found practices such as silence restriction spreading from particular teen Homes in Asia before reaching Britain. A young man raised in Thailand begins his 2001 account by noting that others who knew him "will have a totally different story to tell".

  • Firsthand account leadership was fairly loose in England and they had not been exposed to a lot of discipline and authority There is Life After the Family (May 2002)
  • Legal finding SPM said that this was begun in the teen home in the Philippines in about 1987/1988 Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Firsthand account Now I am sure that anyone who remembers me from The Family, at any time will have a totally different story to tell than me, but this is just life from my perspective. My Life Growing Up in the Family

By generation. First-generation members chose to join as young adults. Their children, the second generation, were born into the group: the judgment found that World Services became concerned about these teenagers only from about 1985, and by 1992 two-thirds of members were children. Second-generation accounts of the late 1980s and early 1990s are among the most critical in the archive. First-generation members who left in middle age describe a different struggle: starting careers without qualifications or work history.

Even within one Home, experience depended on age and role. The court found that young children were well taught, while older children's education was narrow and led to no further study. It also found that the group had changed a great deal by 1995: sexual excesses had been eradicated and harsh discipline was being curbed, though not yet fully.

How the A–E framework works

Each comparison page follows the same five steps, labelled A to E. A, what the group taught: Berg's Letters and official doctrine. B, what members were expected to do: rules, directives and policies. C, what members experienced: reported practice, testimony and court findings. D, where teaching and experience diverged: whether a harm was encouraged by doctrine, permitted by it, prohibited by it but practised anyway, or unrelated to it. E, how the organisation responded: dated denials, acknowledgments, apologies and reforms. A final section on sources sets out what the evidence cannot show.

Step D is the heart of each page. For example, the separation of children from parents followed directly from teaching that God breaks up "selfish" private families, while sexual abuse of children followed from published Letters but was later banned. Harsh discipline in teen programmes was encouraged in general terms but carried, in the court's words, "to excess" by those who ran them.

  • Official teaching BUT GOD'S IN THE BUSINESS OF BREAKING UP LITTLE SELFISH PRIVATE WORLDLY FAMILIES TO MAKE OF THEIR YIELDED BROKEN PIECES A LARGER UNIT--ONE FAMILY! ML 249, One Wife (October 28, 1972)
  • Legal finding Berg's enthusiastic endorsement of it has, as in so many things, been carried to excess by those who follow him. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Each page ends with a four-step chain (doctrine, practice, consequence, reform) that summarises the story with dates. The nine comparisons are: love and family; freedom and authority; protection of children; missionary service and childhood; the Law of Love and sexual autonomy; community and independence; prophecy and personal decisions; leaving the movement; and the second generation.

How to read the evidence labels

Every claim on these pages is linked to its evidence, and each piece of evidence carries a label. "Teaching" marks Berg's Letters and official doctrine, such as "One Wife" (1972). "Instruction" marks leadership directives and rules to members, such as Maria's 1993 letter on parents forsaking their children for the work. "Practice" marks what internal publications show Homes actually doing, such as statistics on Home sizes.

"Testimony" marks a firsthand account by a member or former member, referred to by role rather than name. "Legal" marks court findings, above all Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment. "Response" marks the group's later acknowledgments, apologies and reforms. "Own-account" marks the group's own description of itself, including its public statements of the early 1990s and TFI's websites today.

"Disputed" marks a claim that others contest, with a note saying who contests it. "Scholarship" marks academic research, and "journalism" press reports. "Theology" marks Bible passages and historic Christian texts used for comparison, always in a paragraph headed "Theological analysis". A label describes the kind of source, not whether it is true: an own-account statement may be accurate, and testimony may be one person's view of one Home.

Where testimony and official accounts conflict

The sharpest conflicts concern the late 1980s and early 1990s. In 1992 the group publicly described its children as receiving "superior care" and said that their Homes spared them physical violence. In 1995 the court found that silence restriction, isolation and corporal punishment had been used to excess in the same years, including in Britain. The group's own leaders then apologised for "excessive corporal punishment, prolonged 'silence restriction' and/or isolation".

  • They are mercifully spared having to endure verbal and physical violence OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE (June 1992) · June 1992 public statement
  • Legal finding The use of isolation and silence restriction was frequently carried to excess and children were damaged by their experience of it. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Later response by the group We have heard a number of testimonies of past excessive corporal punishment, prolonged "silence restriction" and/or isolation, ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US (9/95)

The group long treated critical former members as unreliable. Its 1993 statement on mind control said that hostile accounts came mainly from ex-members who had been deprogrammed or joined support groups. By 1996 its leaders accepted that some former members had been "treated unfairly, harshly, and in an unloving manner" and wrote that former members' views of the group varied widely.

The court weighed both sides. It found that the group had not always told it the truth, regarding itself as free to deceive persecutors, and that its UK spokesman's evidence on discipline was "neither full nor frank". It also tested witnesses on both sides, finding one former opponent of the group who had become its defender too inconsistent to rely on, and it gave weight to members who showed good relationships with outside relatives. These pages follow the same approach: they report each source for what it is, give the range where sources disagree, and never treat a published policy as proof of what every Home did.

  • Legal finding Consequently they regard themselves free to deceive the authorities and I have not always had the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth from The Family in the evidence they have presented to me. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding That evidence was neither full nor frank. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding There is such inconsistency in her account of things that have happened in the past - and in her case many years in the past - that I would not rely on much she told me. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding witness after witness produced bundles of photographs to convince me of the good relationship maintained with their system families. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The archive holds Berg's Letters and later leadership publications, the group's public position statements of 1992-1998, former members' accounts written mostly between 1997 and 2005, and Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment. It holds no surveys of members' experiences and few numbers on how many children were separated, disciplined or harmed. Testimony comes mostly from people who left, and the group's statements were often written for courts and the press.

For the period after the 2010 reorganisation, when TFI ended communal living and became mainly an online network, the archive relies on TFI's own websites and on scholarship, and has little firsthand testimony.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1968–1980

    Berg teaches love, communal sharing and revolution, but also obedience, the priority of the group over private families, and the Law of Love without age limits.

  2. Practice · 1970s–early 1990s

    Communal Homes, frequent moves, reports and correction; from 1988, schools and teen programmes away from parents.

  3. Consequence · 1970s–1995

    Harm to many children and some adults, documented by testimony and the 1995 judgment; others recall faith and happy times.

  4. Reform or response · 1986–2010

    Bans and purges (1986–1991), the Love Charter (1995), apologies (1995–96) and the end of the communal model (2010).

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.