Teachings vs. Experiences

Community vs. Independence: What Communal Life Gave and Cost Members of the Children of God

What were the benefits and costs of communal living in the Children of God?

Communal living gave many members of the Children of God (later The Family) a strong sense of belonging and purpose, shared child care and close friendships, and members and the group both describe these as real benefits. The cost was dependence: members gave up their possessions and outside jobs, built no savings, pensions or employment records, and leaders long shaped decisions about where families lived, which made leaving very hard. The group eased these rules from 1995, ended communal living as a requirement in 2010, and in 2012 offered older members a one-time retirement gift.

What the group taught: forsaking all to live as the early church

From its beginnings the movement taught that true disciples "forsake all" and live together as the first Christians did in Acts 2:44, holding all things in common. In 1970 Berg called this way of life the group's greatest witness. In 1980 he restated that new disciples should "bring it all with you but forsake it all to the Family". The group's 1992 Statement of Faith said members had found the "practical and spiritual benefits of cooperative communal living to be extremely advantageous".

Forsaking all had a financial meaning. A 1971 Letter said that converts with property or incomes "such as pensions" were to contribute them to the colony when they joined, and the Statement of Faith asked disciples to renounce "the vain pursuit of material wealth". Ordinary employment was discouraged: in 1971 Berg criticised other Jesus People because their converts were "still working at System jobs".

  • Official teaching it must be made clear that they are to contribute all their worldly goods to the Colony when they join, including such incomes, monthly, etc. ML 55, Letters IV (March 6, 1971)
  • A renouncement and forsaking of the vain pursuit of material wealth, as well as all other worldly and materialistic ambitions and endeavours. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH
  • Official teaching They haven't dropped out of the System! They're still working at System jobs ML 148, Jesus People?--Or Revolution (June, 1971)

The community also came before the private family. Berg wrote in 1975 that "the larger Family unity comes first" and is more important than a couple and their own children. This teaching is examined further in the article on forsaking all and communal living.

What members were expected to do

Members pooled what they had and lived "by faith": asking businesses for donated goods ("provisioning"), distributing literature for donations, and from 1974 sending a tithe to the leadership. The group's 1992 statement "Our Support" described its communities as "sharing everything we have" so that members could devote themselves to service.

Members' time and movements were organised by the community. A woman who joined around 1970, writing in 1999, described a colony that "ran on a very strict schedule, just like an army training camp". A man raised in the group, writing about the years up to 2000, said that members' time "was not considered our own" but was arranged by schedule managers. Until the 1995 Charter leaders also decided whether Homes moved and where.

Family decisions were also subject to the needs of the work. As late as 1993 Maria told a mother who was kept apart from her children by her duties that this was part of "forsaking mothers & fathers and children" for the work.

What members experienced

Many members found real benefits in communal life. The group's own accounts stress shared child care and a home where "someone is always home for the children", while admitting that raising children collectively "has both advantages and disadvantages". Lord Justice Ward, who heard more than 30 members give evidence, said he was "filled with admiration for their total dedication to their discipleship".

Former members also describe what they valued. One, writing in 2003 after leaving, said that "living together is great education to teach us to be unselfish". A man who left in 1979 listed the Bible classes, scripture memorisation and witnessing among the good things. A man raised in the group who left in 2000 wrote that he kept friendships with members, and shared a flat with an old friend from his years in Brazil; a man born in 1980 remembered his early Home in Bangkok as a happy one.

The financial cost was that members owned almost nothing of their own. The woman who joined around 1970 described how the group collected all her belongings when she "forsook all". A 1996 leadership answer acknowledged that most members no longer had personal emergency ("flee") funds, and that in the past shepherds had sometimes pressed members to give such savings to pay the Home's rent or bills. No wages were paid; as the man who left in 2000 put it, labour hours were "the prime currency" of the lifestyle.

Work and education records were the other cost. A first-generation member writing in 2003 described leaving "in your 40's or 50's with several kids and no marketable skills", with "no tax returns filed, no employment history" to show employers. A 2001 leadership checklist told members who wanted to remain full-time disciples that there was no room for higher education.

These costs made leaving hard. Ward was troubled by how frightening it must be for a young teenager, "perhaps in a foreign field", to be told to go elsewhere "when he has nowhere else to go". A woman who left in 1986 wrote that fear of an unknown future was what had kept her in for years, and that she was unusually lucky to have relatives who had saved money for her. Under the Charter a Home was not required to give a member who left it any share of its assets. A young woman interviewed in 2002 said some who left did not know "how to open a bank account".

Many rebuilt their lives. The first-generation member writing in 2003 knew former members who had become "nurses, teachers, academics, scientists, lawyers, musicians, computer experts", and the woman who left in 1986 found work in report writing at an engineering firm and later as an assistant to company presidents.

Where teaching and experience diverged

The lack of savings, pensions and work records was not a side effect but followed directly from the doctrine of forsaking all and dropping out of the "System". The community provided for members while they stayed; the cost fell on those who left, especially older members and young people raised in the group. Pressure on members' private savings was a further harm that the leadership itself acknowledged and in 1995 restricted through rules on Home votes.

Belonging inside the group could mean distance from family outside it. Ward found that contact with outside relatives "all depends on the level of acceptance, resignation or hostility" between them; many members kept loving contact, but a 1988 publication called close contact with unreceptive relatives "a waste of time".

  • Legal finding It all depends on the level of acceptance, resignation or hostility between the members and the outside families. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding it's really a waste of time to keep in close contact with them if they're totally unreceptive. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward · Maria's counsel as quoted from "The Jumbo Story" (1988) in the 1995 judgment

Communal life also changed a great deal over time. Large Homes of the 1980s and early 1990s gave way after the 1995 Charter to smaller ones: by 1998 the average Charter Home had fallen from 33 members to 13.3. Experiences varied by decade, country and Home, and those who found community life rewarding and those who found it confining were often describing different settings.

  • Reported practice CM Home size has gone down dramatically, from 33 members per Home just prior to the Charter to its present 13.3. ML 3159, Victory Review '97 (1/98)

How the organisation responded

The rules were relaxed in stages. In 1979 Berg accepted that members with young families might need a "System job" and witness in their spare time. The 1995 Charter gave members a Right of Mobility, allowed Homes to vote for members to take well-paid secular jobs, and set rules for personal savings.

By the late 1990s the group had a second tier of "Fellow Members" who did not have to live communally. In 1999 the leadership described them as not required to keep the Fundamental Family Rules or to "live communally and share all things". In 1996 Peter Amsterdam acknowledged that former members had felt abandoned and invited reconciliation.

In 2010, after a two-year review, TFI ended its communal model in the reorganisation known as the Reboot. Sociologists Eileen Barker and Sarah Harvey write that communal living was then "no longer required or even expected" and that members could seek secular employment. Adult membership fell steeply afterwards.

  • History ↗ · TFI's website: in 2010, after a two-year review, TFI undertook the Reboot and ended its communal model
  • Scholarly research Perhaps most significantly, communal living was no longer required or even expected; Children of God / The Family International ↗
  • Scholarly research In 2009, just before the Reboot, there were slightly under 7,000 adults (and 1,351 children); in 2010 there were 4,500 adult members, then the number fell by roughly 10 percent per annum to around 1,600 by 2020. Children of God / The Family International ↗

For older members who had spent decades without wages or pensions, a Veteran Members Care programme was created in 2012, offering resources and "a one-time retirement gift" for the move out of communal support, according to a profile written by a TFI spokeswoman. The archive does not document how much was given or how many received it.

  • A Veteran Members Care program was created to provide resources and a one-time retirement gift for senior members for their transition from the communal support system. The Family International (2010-Present) ↗ · written by a TFI spokeswoman

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The main sources are Berg's Letters on forsaking all, the group's 1992 public statements ("Statement of Faith", "Our Support", "The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children"), the 1996 Women in The Family statement, Charter questions and answers from 1995 and 1996, and Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment. Firsthand accounts are from former members writing between 1998 and 2003 and a 2002 press interview; the archive has fewer accounts from members who stayed and found communal life fulfilling.

  • Issued by World Services on the collective behalf of the fellowship of independent missionary communities commonly referred to as The Family OUR SUPPORT (October 1992)

Post-2010 developments rest on TFI's own website, a profile written by a TFI spokeswoman and a scholarly dictionary article. The archive holds no figures on members' savings, pensions or later employment, and does not document the size of the 2012 retirement gift.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1968–1980

    Disciples are to forsake all, give their goods to the community, drop out of System jobs and put the larger Family before the private family.

  2. Practice · 1970s–2000s

    Members pool everything and live by provisioning and donations, on schedules and in places set by the community and its leaders.

  3. Consequence · 1980s onward

    Members gain belonging and shared care but have no savings, pensions, tax or employment records, which makes leaving and later life difficult.

  4. Reform or response · 1995–2012

    The Charter allows mobility, secular jobs and personal savings (1995); communal living ends as a requirement (2010); a Veteran Members Care programme offers older members a one-time retirement gift (2012).

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.