Beliefs and practices

Forsaking All and Communal Living in the Children of God

What did "forsaking all" mean in the Children of God?

"Forsaking all" meant that a full-time disciple gave up job, possessions and family ties, handed everything to the group and lived communally in "colonies" (later "Homes"), relying on donations, literature sales and provisioning. David Berg based it on Jesus' words in Luke 14:33 and the shared life of the early church in Acts. Communal Homes sent tithes to the leadership, a second tier of non-communal "Fellow Members" was recognised in the 1990s, and communal living stopped being required at the 2010 Reboot.

Overview: what did "forsaking all" mean?

From its first years the group asked converts to drop out of ordinary society and "forsake all": to leave their jobs, studies and families, give their money and belongings to the group and live with other members in communal houses. Berg called this way of life the group's "greatest witness" against the churches. The Family's Statement of Faith later quoted Jesus: "whosoever he be of you that forsaketh not all that he hath, he cannot be My disciple" (Luke 14:33).

  • Official teaching OUR GREATEST WITNESS IS OUR EXAMPLE OF DROPPING OUT AND FORSAKING ALL WHICH IS A CONDEMNATION OF THE CHURCHES ML 0J, Not a Sermon, But a Sample (July 3, 1970)
  • Leadership instruction So likewise, whosoever he be of you that forsaketh not all that he hath, he cannot be My disciple OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication

Forsaking all shaped almost every part of members' lives: where they lived, how they earned their keep, whom they answered to, and how they related to their own families. It remained the standard for full members, called Charter Members from 1997, until the 2010 reorganisation known as the Reboot ended the communal model.

Historical origins: where did it come from?

The pattern was set at the start. At the group's Christmas meeting in Huntington Beach in 1968 a prophecy thanked God for those who had "forsaken houses & families" to join "Thy Family". After the move to the Texas Soul Clinic ranch in 1970 the group spread through "colonisation", sending teams to set up communal colonies in new cities, and by 1972-73 colonies were spreading worldwide.

Berg presented the communal colony as a return to the early church and as a protest against conventional Christianity. In June 1971 he dismissed the wider Jesus People movement because its converts were "still working at System jobs" and had not left their churches. Joining meant handing everything over: Letters of 1975 and 1977 told colony leaders that a new disciple's next step was to fetch "all his stuff and his bank accounts and his money" and "turn it over then and there".

Official doctrine: what did the documents say?

The Statement of Faith treats full-time discipleship as a calling modelled on the apostles. It lists its demands: utter devotion to Christ, winning others, renouncing "the vain pursuit of material wealth", and putting God's will above the wishes of family. A separate article commends "cooperative communal living" on the model of the church in Acts, where believers "had all things in common".

  • Leadership instruction A renouncement and forsaking of the vain pursuit of material wealth, as well as all other worldly and materialistic ambitions and endeavours. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication
  • Leadership instruction The first Church's unselfish, cooperative lifestyle, in which "all that believed were together, and had all things in common" (Acts 2:44) OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication

Berg described the ideal as giving 100 percent. In July 1980 he wrote that the group had always preached "forsake all", bringing everything and giving it to the Family; tithing, by contrast, was "God's second best", an easier way for those not willing to give all.

A 1992 statement for outsiders, "Our Support", explained the economics. Members had "forsaken all, including material possessions" and lived in communities "sharing everything we have"; instead of a salary they "live by faith", relying on gifts from supporters, much as other religious workers do. It argued that secular jobs would leave no time for full-time ministry.

  • We love Jesus above all else and all others, and have forsaken all, including material possessions and worldly ambitions, to follow Him in obedience to the Scriptures: OUR SUPPORT (October 1992)
  • We live in communities, as the early Christians did, sharing everything we have. OUR SUPPORT (October 1992)
  • if we worked at secular jobs from 9 to 5, we wouldn't have the time nor energy to be able to concentrate full-time on ministering the Gospel to others. OUR SUPPORT (October 1992)

Distinctive features: how did it differ from other Christians?

Theological analysis: Christian tradition has long honoured those who give up property to follow Christ, from the shared life described in Acts to monastic orders and communal groups such as the Hutterites, and most churches accept that ministers may be supported by those they serve (1 Corinthians 9:14). Mainstream churches have, however, read the call to forsake all as a special vocation, not a test of every believer, and have taught that ordinary work and care for one's own household are Christian duties (2 Thessalonians 3:10; 1 Timothy 5:8). Early Christian writers describe believers living within society "as sojourners". The group's insistence that true disciples leave jobs, schools and families, and its view of other churches as part of "the System", went beyond these traditions.

Berg did leave room for people who would not forsake all. He told members to value supporters, whom he called "kings", and wrote in 1976 that "not everybody can forsake all and leave home": someone had to be friends and protectors. The Statement of Faith likewise accepts that full-time discipleship "is not possible for everyone". This distinction later became the basis for the two tiers of membership.

  • Official teaching not everybody can forsake all and leave home and everything. Somebody's got to be our friends and kings and supporters and protectors! ML 542, Don’t Drop Out! – Drop In! (August 1, 1976)
  • Leadership instruction However, we recognise that pursuing this course is not possible for everyone. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication

Practical application: provisioning, literature and the tithe

Colonies lived on what they could ask for or raise. In 1972 Berg described the means of support as "provisioning" (asking businesses for donated goods and services), scrounging and donations; by 1975 he said the sale of literature alone was supporting the colonies. An early member, recalling Puerto Rico in 1972, wrote that new works were opened "literally by faith", with housing and food obtained through prayer and asking.

Money also flowed upward. In 1972 Berg said he would not demand a tithe, but in July 1974 he asked each colony to send "at least ten-percent" of its total income to the leadership. Lord Justice Ward found that each colony tithed 10 percent of its income, including money received from Flirty Fishing. In the 1980s Homes had to meet minimum tithes to receive the group's internal literature; in 1985 Berg announced a return to a straight 10 percent from the following January, and 1989 rules again set a minimum of $100 for internal (DO) publications.

Members held almost nothing personally. Ward, writing in 1995, said he knew little about the central finances and had some evidence that the organisation had acquired considerable wealth through Flirty Fishing, publications and videos, but found that the UK Homes had "no surplus of money" and lived at a standard that was "by no means lavish".

  • Legal finding I know little about the financial management and have some evidence that the organisation has acquired considerable wealth through Flirty Fishing, through its publications and recently through its expanding video ministry. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding I am quite satisfied that within the homes in this country, there is no surplus of money Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Secular work was discouraged but slowly accepted. In January 1979 Berg allowed that members with young families might need a "System job" and could witness in spare time, and in 1995 World Services said that under the Charter a Home could choose to have members take well-paid jobs. Even so, a 1997 prophecy still linked taking a System job with losing the vision to witness.

Historical development: from colonies to an online network

The communal structure was reorganised several times. In the 1978 RNR Berg dismissed the "Chain" of leaders, renamed colonies "Homes" and their shepherds "servants", and in 1981 the Fellowship Revolution grouped Homes into area fellowships. Members linked to the group but not living in its full-time communal ("DO") Homes were known as "TRF Supporters". In January 1997 the leadership announced that DO members would be renamed Charter Members and TRF Supporters would get a new name; they became Fellow Members.

The 1995 Love Charter loosened the large communal households. Maria described it as freeing members from "the restrictions of a large, institutionalized Home". By the end of 1997 average Charter Home size had fallen from 33 to 13.3, and Fellow Members made up 25 percent of the total. A 1999 Letter described Fellow Members as not required to keep the Fundamental Family Rules or "live communally and share all things", while insisting that the standard for full-time disciples was unchanged.

  • Leadership instruction the restrictions of a large, institutionalized Home, or leadership, tradition or peer pressure have made it impossible for you to operate in full faith ML 2963, THE LOVE CHARTER (1/95)
  • Reported practice CM Home size has gone down dramatically, from 33 members per Home just prior to the Charter to its present 13.3. ML 3159, Victory Review '97 (1/98)
  • Reported practice Our FM population now makes up 25% of our combined CM/FM membership. ML 3159, Victory Review '97 (1/98)
  • Leadership instruction you don't have to live communally and share all things ML 3257, The Shakeup 2000 – the S2K (7/99)
  • Leadership instruction the spiritual requirements for us as Christians and full-time disciples remain the same. ML 3365, Are You a Disciple? (9/01)

The end of required communal living came in 2010. A 2009 newspaper report still described about 15,000 members "in small communal centers in 90 nations". TFI's own history page says that in 2010, after a two-year review, it reorganised in what it calls the Reboot, ended its communal-based model and streamlined its charter. Sociologists Eileen Barker and Sarah Harvey write that communal living was then "no longer required or even expected" and that members could take secular jobs. TFI now describes itself on its website as an online Christian network.

Controversies and consequences

Separation of families. The forsake-all teaching extended to family ties. In "One Wife" Berg said God was "breaking up private families", and in 1983 he called giving up one's children for the work "the supreme sacrifice". In 1993 Maria counselled a leader kept apart from her children that this was part of forsaking "mothers & fathers and children" for the work. In 1995 Ward found that "the heavy compulsion of the forsake all doctrine" made family separations more likely and that "Forsaking all was harmful" to children. The 1995 Charter gave every child the right to live with at least one parent.

Pressure to give. Ward cited a 1988 Letter titled "IRFers Beware: If you fail to tithe, God will take a collection!", which presented the violent death of a former member as what befell those who lapsed. Critics' histories allege that some converts were asked to claim inheritances early to fund the work; the archive has no Family document confirming this.

  • Legal finding 'IRFers Beware: If you fail to tithe, God will take a collection!" Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Disputed allegation It is alleged that on a number of occasions, new converts were even asked to collect their inheritance before it was due Brief Historical Outline of the COG (Feb 18 2002) · allegation in a critical history (2002), not confirmed by Family documents in this archive

Leaving with nothing. Because members had given up possessions, careers and education, leaving was hard. An anonymous former member, writing in 1999, recalled emptying bank accounts and resigning from work on joining. A first-generation member who left in middle age wrote in 2003 that many left "in your 40's or 50's with several kids and no marketable skills", and began as a dishwasher. The same writer stressed that many had gone on to become nurses, teachers, academics, lawyers and business people.

The 2010 change had its own cost. Barker and Harvey report that adult membership fell from slightly under 7,000 in 2009 to about 1,600 by 2020.

  • Scholarly research In 2009, just before the Reboot, there were slightly under 7,000 adults (and 1,351 children); in 2010 there were 4,500 adult members, then the number fell by roughly 10 percent per annum to around 1,600 by 2020. Children of God / The Family International (CDAMM) ↗

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The main sources are Berg's Letters on discipleship, finance and organisation (1970-1985), the Statement of Faith and the 1992 statement "Our Support", Charter-era statistics in "Victory Review '97", Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment, and former members' accounts. For the period after 2010 the archive holds no internal documents; the account relies on TFI's own website and on Barker and Harvey's scholarly article.

  • TFI: Our History ↗ · TFI's official website; states that in 2010, after a two-year review, TFI reorganised (the Reboot), ended its communal model and streamlined its charter
  • October 1992 OUR SUPPORT (October 1992)

Much remains undocumented. The archive does not show how central funds were managed or spent, what happened to property that members handed over when they later left, or how support for older members worked after 2010. Experiences of communal life varied widely by decade, country and Home, and Ward's financial findings were limited to the UK Homes he examined.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1968–1992

    True disciples must forsake all, hand over their possessions and live communally like the early church; tithing is "God's second best".

  2. Practice · 1970–2010

    Members live in colonies and Homes supported by provisioning, literature and donations; each Home tithes to the leadership and secular jobs are discouraged.

  3. Consequence · 1970s–2000s

    Families are separated for the work, members accumulate no savings, skills or work records, and leaving means starting again with little.

  4. Reform or response · 1995–2010

    The Charter shrinks Homes and recognises non-communal Fellow Members; the 2010 Reboot ends the communal model and allows secular work.

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.