Beliefs and practices

Obedience and Leadership in the Children of God: Shepherds, Reports, Discipline and the Charter

How much obedience did the Children of God require from members?

For most of its history the Children of God taught that obeying David Berg's Letters and the leaders placed over members was obedience to God, and leaders or the Letters decided where members lived, whom they could form relationships with, what work they did and how children were schooled. Written reports, open confession of faults and discipline up to excommunication enforced this. From 1995 the Love Charter limited leaders' authority and let members move Homes on their own decision, and after the 2010 Reboot membership required little more than a monthly report and offering.

Overview: how much obedience did the group require?

From the early 1970s Berg described the movement as an army and taught that members owed obedience to the leaders placed over them, even when those leaders made mistakes. In 1989 he told members that obeying the group's officers was the same as obeying God. The English High Court, reviewing the group's writings in 1995, found that the heavy emphasis on obedience meant members were likely to submit to Berg's writings rather than reject them.

The degree of control was never fixed. Leadership was rebuilt several times: a hierarchy known as the Chain in the early 1970s, its abolition in 1978, a structure of elected area leaders from 1981, the World Services administration under Berg and Maria, the Love Charter of 1995, a system of boards in 2001, and the 2010 Reboot, after which TFI describes itself as an online network. Experiences varied by decade, country and Home, and this article separates what the publications required from what members and courts reported.

Historical origins: the army, the colony and the Chain

In the early years the group was run as a hierarchy. Lord Justice Ward described a World Council of Ministers appointed by Berg, mainly from his own family, above a ladder of bishops and regional, district and colony shepherds. A woman who was a member in the 1970s, writing in 1999, remembered that permission for decisions passed up this ladder to a top leader when a local leader could not answer.

  • Legal finding There was a structure of ministers, bishops, regional shepherds, district shepherds and finally colony shepherds. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Firsthand account All permission was given, after authorization of a top leader if the his under-leader could not answer. My experience with the COG/Family (1999)

The same account describes how doubting a leader was treated as doubting God. When she disputed a leader's accusation, she was told to fast alone in a bedroom and pray to be shown her sin. She also recalls that couples could not begin a relationship without leadership's permission.

Decisions about where members lived were also made above them. In 1975 moving members from one city to another required clearance at the highest level, and in 1995 World Services recalled that leadership had once advised Homes on whether to move, where to go and even how many bedrooms to have.

Official doctrine: what the documents said about obedience

In January 1978 Berg's "Re-organisation Nationalisation Revolution" (RNR) abolished the Chain, saying it had become "a Chain of Command and Slavery". In its place he announced a direct rule from the top: Homes would elect their own leaders by secret ballot, but would be supervised through his Letters, which would tell them exactly what to do.

Berg's own statements pulled in two directions. In February 1988 he wrote that obedience to leaders was not an absolute to be placed above reason, Scripture and conscience. Yet in July 1989, when tightening discipline, he listed unbelief in the Letters, criticism of him or the Family, and "murmuring" among offences for which people might be excommunicated. Ward heard evidence that in the group "a suggestion is an order in love."

The 1995 Love Charter wrote both sides down. Peter Amsterdam's 1998 commentary said it restricted leaders' authority so that they could not exercise too much control over Homes and individuals "as some have in the past", while also requiring discipline of those who broke its rules. It also listed belief that Berg was God's Endtime prophet and Maria his anointed successor among members' responsibilities.

  • Leadership instruction there are restrictions on the authority of leadership, and we have put that in place to keep our leadership from exercising too much authority over Homes and individuals, as some have in the past. ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities (7/98)
  • Leadership instruction Believe that David was God's Endtime prophet, and that Maria is God's chosen and anointed successor, who has inherited David's mantle, as God's prophetess. ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities (7/98)

Distinctive features: reports, open hearts and peer accountability

Written reporting ran through every level of the group. A 1991 leadership publication explained that members wrote Open Heart Reports (OHRs), teens wrote teen shepherd reports, Home leaders filed a monthly report form (the TRF), and area officers reported up to Berg and Maria. Members were expected not only to report activities but to "pour out our hearts on paper". New rules that year made two OHRs a week compulsory for adults and at least three for teens.

Correction was meant to be followed up through these reports. Guidance from a 1990 leadership summit described correcting someone with a serious problem as involving further meetings, reading lists of Berg's Letters and reading the person's OHRs to make sure they changed.

The 1995 judgment found that for teenagers in the special training programmes OHRs became a means of forcing confession: a teen with nothing to confess was called proud, while one who voiced doubts was accused of murmuring. Teens learned that doubts told to shepherds were met with prayer, but the same doubts shared with friends were punished. In one school children were required to name the peers with the greatest spiritual problems in their reports.

  • Legal finding OHRs - open heart reports - were widely used as a means of forcing confession with the result that the children were made to feel guilty if they did not confess. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding to reveal doubts in the OHR's to the shepherds was permissible activity which was treated with prayers whereas revealing the same doubts to his peers was murmuring Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding The children had been required to report on each other in their Open Heart Reports. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Theological analysis: the obligation to obey church leaders is common ground among Christians, who cite Hebrews 13:17. Most traditions, however, also teach that leaders must not lord it over the flock (1 Peter 5:3), that believers must obey God rather than men when the two conflict (Acts 5:29), and, in the words of the Westminster Confession, that God alone is lord of the conscience. The group's teaching agreed with the first point; Berg's 1988 caveat echoed the others, but his 1989 equation of obeying officers with obeying God departed from them.

Practical application: how decisions about life were made

Before 1995, decisions about moves, relationships and ministries were commonly referred to leaders. Maria's 1997 review of the Charter said it had been introduced because people wanted more control over their own decisions, moves and relationships, and wanted to follow the Lord without being constrained by leadership or peer pressure. She said the Charter had made senior teens, young adults and adults take more personal responsibility for these choices.

Under the Charter, decisions passed largely to each Home's voting members, who elected a teamwork (the Home's leadership team) and set Home rules, including the standard of child discipline. A member who disagreed was expected either to cooperate or to move to another Home. Visiting Servants (VSs) were to enforce the Charter but not to make decisions for Homes.

Work and education were shaped by the same structure. In 1995 World Services said a Home could choose to have members take well-paid secular jobs if they kept the rules. A young man born in the group, writing in 2003 after leaving in December 2000, said he had asked his overseers several times to be allowed to study, and that getting a Home's vote for time off to pursue a degree was "just unheard of" in his experience.

Historical development: from the Chain to the Reboot

The RNR of 1978 dismissed the Chain leaders; the group's 1991 history puts their number at about 300. Ward found that many Homes then broke up, and that between 1978 and 1981 leadership control was lax. Berg's "Fellowship Revolution" of April 1981 gathered Homes into area fellowships, which Ward described as a pyramid of leadership elected by members. Beneath the surface, he found, command stayed with Berg, Maria and their inner circle throughout.

By the early 1990s Berg and Maria were served by World Services (WS), with continental offices (CROs) and national, district and Home shepherds below them. Ward noted that local teamworks were elected by members over 16 by secret ballot, with the stated purpose of spreading responsibility and providing checks against abuse.

  • Legal finding Berg and Maria were served by 'World Services' (WS), the administrative branch of which has Peter Amsterdam and Gary as the senior personnel. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding The purpose of 'team work' is to spread the burden and responsibility of decision making and to provide checks and balances against abuse. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

The Love Charter took effect on 1 April 1995. Area shepherds stepped down on 15 February 1995, and members gained a "Right of Mobility": after thirty days' notice they could change Homes or fields, or start a new Home, on their own decision. Maria told members they had "the right to move whenever you want to", while urging them to pray before using it.

Leadership soon pushed back towards firmer discipline. In 1998 Peter Amsterdam wrote that many members had stressed their rights over their responsibilities, and that CROs and VSs had a duty, not an option, to discipline those who broke the Charter. In 2001 a new structure of national, regional and international boards was introduced, modelled on Acts 6. In 2010 TFI's Reboot ended the communal model and streamlined the Charter; according to a profile by a TFI spokeswoman, it shrank from 310 pages to thirty, with minimal requirements including a monthly report and offering.

Controversies and consequences: discipline, punishment and leaving

Discipline ranged from correction and reading assignments to excommunication. A 1982 compilation of rules quoted Berg that he could not force obedience but would withhold the Letters from those who refused. Under the Charter, continental officers decided on partial or full excommunication; a partially excommunicated member lost their vote in the Home and their Right of Mobility.

  • Leadership instruction I CANNOT FORCE YOU TO OBEY, BUT I HOLD A FEW TRUMP CARDS--& THOSE ARE THE LORD'S LETTERS, which we shall withhold from those who refuse to cooperate ML 1323, Excommunication Rules & Procedures! (November 1982)
  • Leadership instruction Everyone needs to realize that if someone commits an excommunicable offense, the Charter demands they be excommunicated. ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities (7/98)
  • Leadership instruction you would not be a voting member of the Home, you would lose your right of mobility ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities (7/98)

The harshest discipline fell on teenagers. Ward found that in the teen camps and "Victor" programmes of the late 1980s and early 1990s, silence restriction was used as punishment, children were isolated, put to punitive labour and beaten with paddles, and that these methods spread through the group because of the high degree of reporting to World Services. He required WS to ban corporal punishment, compulsory silence, isolation and abuse of the open heart report system. Children's experiences are covered in the article on children, family and education.

  • Legal finding I am totally satisfied that putting the children on silence was used as a means of punishment Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding This ranged from quite savage beatings with paddles especially in the Victor camps and in Macau Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding Given the high degree of reporting to World Services and the distribution of the information throughout the group, I am in little doubt that there was a cross-fertilisation of many ideas. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding banning and outlawing paddling, compulsory silence, isolation, dire emotional threats, abuse of the open heart report system Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Leaving was officially free but spiritually costly. Berg wrote in 1977 that members were free to leave at any time, yet he also taught that God was angry with "backsliders". In 1987 Maria acknowledged that some people had been wrongly excommunicated and that some could not survive in the Family through the fault of others, particularly past leaders such as the Chain.

Former members describe different relationships with this authority. A woman who left, writing in 2002, said that what drew her was a wish to be told what to do, and contrasted it with the hard choices her own children later made with confidence. Ward noted that most former members looked back "more in sorrow than in anger", while a vocal minority were deeply hostile.

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The main primary sources are Berg's Letters on leadership (1971 to 1989), the RNR Letters of 1978, "The Fellowship Revolution" (1981), the 1991 leadership material on reporting, the Love Charter (1995) with its Questions and Answers and Peter Amsterdam's 1998 commentary, and "The Board Vision" (2001). The 1995 Ward judgment is the main independent source on how authority and discipline worked in practice, though it concentrates on the late 1980s and early 1990s and on teenagers.

The archive holds few internal documents after 2003, so the working of the 2001 boards and the post-2010 structure rests mainly on TFI's own websites and on a profile written by a TFI spokeswoman. Firsthand accounts differ widely by decade, country and Home, and the number of members affected by any particular practice is not documented.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1971–1989

    Berg teaches that members owe obedience to leaders over them and, in 1989, that obeying the group's officers is obeying God.

  2. Practice · 1970s–1994

    Leaders or the Letters decide moves, relationships and ministries; members write regular Open Heart Reports, and dissent is treated as murmuring.

  3. Consequence · Late 1980s–early 1990s

    Teen programmes use forced confession, silence restriction, isolation and corporal punishment; a court condemns these methods in 1995.

  4. Reform or response · 1995–2010

    The Love Charter limits leaders' authority and grants a Right of Mobility (1995); the 2010 Reboot ends the communal model and cuts the Charter to minimal requirements.

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.