Teachings vs. Experiences

Prophecy and Personal Decisions in the Children of God and The Family

How did prophecy shape members' personal decisions in the Children of God?

In the Children of God and The Family, prophecy was treated as a living voice of God that could guide decisions about marriage, moving, work, children and belief, first through David Berg's Letters and later through daily prophecies received by Maria, leaders and ordinary members. Publications told members to seek the Lord in prophecy before major choices and to give serious weight to prophecies their shepherds received for them, although from 2000 they also said that a prophecy affecting others could be questioned. Failed predictions, such as the 1993 timetable for Christ's return and the 1994 prophecies that Berg would be healed, led the group to describe prophecy as conditional.

What the group taught

From the beginning, David Berg presented himself as a prophet through whom God spoke. A 1969 prophecy addressed to him said that his mouth would be God's mouth, and in 1972 he told followers that ignoring God's Word through His prophet was the same as ignoring the voice of God. His Letters (the "Mo Letters") were the main channel of this authority.

  • Official teaching THOU SHALT BE UNTO THEM AS THE ORACLES OF GOD, & thy mouth shall be My mouth, & I will tell thee & thou shalt tell them that they may obey Me. ML 1363, Prophecies of David! – 1969-1982 (7/69)
  • Official teaching To ignore the Word of the Lord through His Prophet is to ignore the Voice of God Himself ML 155, The Laws of Moses (February 21, 1972)

Berg also taught that ordinary members could prophesy, but that his own revelations came first. In 1973 he wrote that being their prophet did not mean they could not prophesy. A guide he issued for testing prophecy, as summarised by a former member writing in 2002, included the question of whether a prophecy was approved by "God's chosen leadership", which tied personal revelation to the leadership's approval.

  • Official teaching since I am your leader and I am your prophet and God uses me as His channel, that doesn't mean that you can't prophesy ML 282A, Interpretation (December 2, 1973)
  • Firsthand account Is it approved by God's chosen leadership? Despise Not Prophesying? (April 2002) · former member's summary of Berg's Letter "Despise Not Prophesying!", 2002

After Berg's death in 1994, Maria (Karen Zerby) and Peter Amsterdam (Steve Kelly) turned prophecy into a daily practice for the whole membership. Maria described asking the Lord to speak in prophecy each morning as a "daily habit", and a prophecy published in 1997 said that all members could be "channels". Around 2000 to 2001 the "Keys of the Kingdom" teaching added that the group had access to a spiritual power no one had held before.

  • Leadership instruction As is our daily habit, this morning, after our praise and Word time, we asked the Lord to speak to us in prophecy. ML 3021, World Currents!--No.81 (11/95)
  • Leadership instruction This is My gift to My Endtime prophets, that all may prophesy, that all may be channels. ML 3134, Mama's Surprise (4/97)
  • Official teaching No one has ever had access to such power before. ML 3318, Explaining the Keys

Belief in this prophetic authority was a condition of full membership. The Charter's list of member responsibilities, as restated in 1998, required Charter members to believe that Berg was God's Endtime prophet and Maria his successor, and to accept beliefs that were "revealed" as well as Biblical.

What members were expected to do

Members were expected to seek prophecy before major personal choices. A 1996 question-and-answer Letter told them to pray about such matters as whom to marry, while warning them not to use a prophecy to pressure the other person. In 1998 leaders went further: young men who had fathered a child since late 1995 should have asked the Lord in prophecy whether to marry the mother, and couples unsure of their own objectivity could ask others to receive the prophecies for them.

Prophecy was also used for decisions about where and how a Home lived. Members' reports printed in a 1998 magazine describe a Home in Paraguay deciding through prophecy to tell its landlord that it would move somewhere cheaper. A 2000 series by Maria told Homes to hear from the Lord on matters they were about to vote on, and then vote after considering the prophecies.

Leaders received prophecies about members. The same 2000 series said that shepherds were responsible under the Charter for helping members apply their personal prophecies, and that members should give serious consideration to counsel the shepherds received for them. Under the Charter, continental officers decided the length of a member's excommunication after "hearing from the Lord in prophecy".

  • Leadership instruction Your shepherds are responsible under the Charter to counsel and direct you, and that includes helping you understand and apply the personal prophecies you receive GN 937, Understanding Prophecy (3/00)
  • Leadership instruction after prayer and hearing from the Lord in prophecy about the matter, may feel led to give them only partial excommunication ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities (7/98)

Prophecy reached into parenting and health. The 2000 series warned that following prophecy about health matters and emergencies "can be dangerous" if people clung to it out of pride, and told members to go back to the Lord, or to a doctor, when events did not go as a prophecy had indicated. The warning itself shows that prophecy was being used in decisions about illness.

What members experienced

Some members found the practice encouraging. A woman writing to Maria in 1997 said she had once avoided prophesying for fear of getting it wrong, but now felt fulfilled when others told her a prophecy she had received for them was "right on". Experiences varied by decade, country and Home, and the group's own magazines printed mainly positive accounts.

  • Firsthand account It's very encouraging to hear from someone that the prophecy you received for him or her was right on. GV 23, Grape Vine #23 (July 15, 1997) · letter printed in a Family newsletter, 1997

Others describe fear of doubting. Maria acknowledged in 1997 that members who doubted prophecies in the group's publications often worried that their shepherds would label them a "doubter" and rebuke them. A former member writing in 2003 recalled being taught to "absorb" new revelations rather than question them, and wrote that the uneasy feelings they had tried to suppress turned out, in their view, to be from God.

Prophecies about the future shaped long-term decisions. A woman who left in 1986 wrote that believing Jesus could return at any moment meant she set no goals, and that she deliberately dropped the expectation of 1993 because of its effect on her children. A man who joined in the group's early years wrote that he left over the failed Comet Kohoutek prophecy of 1973 to 1974, felt lonely and returned, and finally left in 1979.

  • Firsthand account When you believe Jesus is coming back any day, you don't set goals. There is Life After the Family (May 2002) · former member, written 2002
  • Firsthand account I knew I had to follow my intuition that nothing was going to happen in 1993 There is Life After the Family (May 2002)
  • Firsthand account I had left the group once before over the false prophecy Berg had given about the comet Kohoutek I Almost Didn't Make It (March 1998) · former member, 1998

Lord Justice Ward, in the 1995 English custody judgment, noted that a 1990s publication reporting prophecies at a leadership meeting stressed "obedience unto the words of David", and observed that such prophecy, unlike Berg's opinions, was meant to command obedience.

Where teaching and experience diverged

The most visible gap was between dated prophecies and events. Berg's 1972 Letter "The 70-Years Prophecy of the End" set out a timetable ending with Christ's return in the first half of 1993, and he said the Lord, not he, had set the dates. From 1980 he denied having firmly predicted 1993, and in 1989 he said the date might be premature. In 1993 a member's reflection published by World Services still recalled that the group had read 1993 as the year of Christ's return.

The second was Berg's death. Shortly before he died in 1994, a unit of World Services staff prayed for him and received prophecies that he would be healed and raised up. Maria explained afterwards that the prophecies had been accurate while Berg intended to stay, and that he had then changed his mind. A follow-up in the same publication concluded that prophecy was not a "written-in-stone" guide to God's will and that prophecies were conditional.

Personal guidance carried a tension the publications did not fully resolve. Members were told they could follow their own faith on decisions affecting only themselves, so long as these were in line with the Word and the Charter, yet shepherds were to help them interpret their prophecies and members were to weigh seriously what shepherds received for them. Whether this felt like guidance or control depended largely on the Home and its leaders. Prophecy as such was not presented as a tool of coercion, but it gave leaders' counsel the weight of a word from God.

  • Leadership instruction If the decision you're making is in line with the Word and the Charter, you can operate according to your own faith on personal decisions. GN 937, Understanding Prophecy (3/00)
  • Leadership instruction Your shepherds are responsible under the Charter to counsel and direct you GN 937, Understanding Prophecy (3/00)

Theological analysis: many Christian traditions, especially Pentecostal and charismatic churches, accept that God may still speak through prophecy, and the New Testament tells believers to test prophetic words rather than accept them unexamined. The group's 2000 teaching that prophecies could be questioned and checked by others is close to this. Where it departed from most traditions was in treating a living leader's revelations as binding "revealed" doctrine alongside the Bible, and in a biblical test of prophecy that most churches apply strictly: a prediction that fails is not from the Lord. Denominations differ widely on how much weight personal prophecy should carry.

  • Theological analysis Let the prophets speak two or three, and let the other judge. 1 Corinthians 14:29 (King James Version) ↗
  • Theological analysis Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world. 1 John 4:1 (King James Version) ↗
  • Theological analysis When a prophet speaketh in the name of the Lord, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the Lord hath not spoken, but the prophet hath spoken it presumptuously: thou shalt not be afraid of him. Deuteronomy 18:22 (King James Version) ↗

How the organisation responded

The group's responses to failed predictions came in stages. In December 1991 members were told to emphasise the signs of the times rather than dates when witnessing, and the 1992 Statement of Faith kept the Endtime sequence but gave no dates and asked for less firm adherence to it than to its other beliefs.

From 1996 the leadership described prophecy as one way among several of knowing God's will. A prophecy printed that year said prophecy was "not the all in all" and should walk alongside Scripture and godly counsel. In March 2000 Maria wrote that a decision based on prophecy could be questioned, and that members were free to question prophecies affecting others or their Home. The same series admitted that some prophecies would be influenced, incomplete or, rarely, tainted.

At the same time, Endtime prophecy was still to be received by faith. A 2001 message attributed to Jesus rebuked members who had begun to doubt that predicted events would happen. In the 2010 Reboot, according to a profile by TFI spokeswoman Claire Borowik, all TFI writings were withdrawn from circulation pending review. She also reports that in 2020 and 2021 the directors answered members' questions on whether the Covid-19 pandemic marked the start of the final seven years.

  • Leadership instruction Yet many have faltered in their vision and are being taken by surprise because they have begun to doubt that the things which I spoke of to you ML 3367, Attack on America (9/01)
  • The Reboot was introduced via eighteen comprehensive documents disassembling the previous organizational model and officially removing all TFI writings from circulation pending review. The Family International (2010-Present) ↗ · written by a TFI spokeswoman
  • in 2020 and 2021, they published two posts in response to members' questions regarding the Covid-19 pandemic, and whether this represented the beginning of the final seven years described in the Bible The Family International (2010-Present) ↗ · written by a TFI spokeswoman

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The main primary sources are Berg's Letters, Maria's "Jonah Phenomenon" Letter (1994), the 1996 Letters answering questions on prophecy, and the 2000 series "Understanding Prophecy", which set the rules for using prophecy in Homes. These show what members were told to do. They do not show how often prophecy actually decided a marriage, a move or a medical choice, and the archive holds no survey of this.

Firsthand accounts come mostly from former members writing on ex-member websites around 2000 to 2003, and from letters printed in the group's own magazines. The two sets tend to describe opposite experiences. This article quotes both and treats neither as the whole picture. The ex-member critique of Berg's prophecies quoted here is one person's argument, though the dates it lists can be checked against Berg's own Letters.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1969–2001

    Berg is presented as God's mouthpiece; after 1994 Maria teaches that all members may prophesy and should hear from the Lord daily.

    • Official teaching To ignore the Word of the Lord through His Prophet is to ignore the Voice of God Himself ML 155, The Laws of Moses (February 21, 1972)
    • Leadership instruction that all may prophesy, that all may be channels. ML 3134, Mama's Surprise (4/97)
  2. Practice · 1995–2001

    Members and leaders seek prophecy about marriage, moves, Home decisions, health and discipline, and shepherds receive prophecies for members.

  3. Consequence · 1973–1994

    Dated predictions fail (Kohoutek, the 1993 timetable, Berg's healing); some members stop planning for the future, and some leave over failed prophecy.

  4. Reform or response · 1991–2010

    Dates are dropped from witnessing; prophecy is described as conditional; in 2000 prophecies affecting others may be questioned; in 2010 all writings are withdrawn pending review.

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.