Teachings vs. Experiences
Freedom and Authority in the Children of God: Teaching vs. Experience
Were members of the Children of God free, or controlled by leaders?
The Children of God presented itself as a revolution that freed young people from a corrupt "System" and from church rules, and it repeatedly said members were free to leave. In practice members were expected to obey leaders and Berg's Letters, report on themselves, accept correction and avoid "murmuring", and the 1995 English High Court judgment found intense pressure to conform, especially on children. The 1995 Love Charter limited leaders' authority and gave members a right to move between Homes, though leaders could still discipline those who broke its rules.
What the group taught
From the start the movement spoke the language of liberation. Young converts were dropping out of a society Berg called the "System" to join a revolution for Jesus, and in 1973 he described the faith as a religion of "real liberty, real freedom of the Spirit and the flesh" that could not be judged by flat rules. In 1977 he answered critics that every member was "free to leave at any time".
- Official teaching
We have real liberty, real freedom of the Spirit and the flesh! So how are you going to judge anything by making any flat-out rules that are all-inclusive and cover everything?--You can't!
ML 292, Women In Love - Official teaching
as every member of our Family knows, they are free to leave at any time they wish and can go back home or wherever they want to go
ML 591, The 51 Errors of “Daily Notices”! – Of Santa Cruz, Tenerife, Canary Islands
Alongside this, Berg taught obedience. In 1971 he told members that they owed leaders "ALLEGIANCE, RESPECT, AND OBEDIENCE" as long as those leaders stayed in charge. By 1989 he was describing the group as an army in which obeying the officers was the same as obeying God.
- Official teaching
IF THEY CONTINUE TO BE LEFT IN CHARGE BY THEIR OVERSEERS, THEN YOU CONTINUE TO OWE THEM YOUR ALLEGIANCE, RESPECT, AND OBEDIENCE.
ML 143, Personal Visits--(part I)--Sin In The Camp - Official teaching
if you want to obey God, you'd better obey us, & not just think it's some kind of an optional thing once you've joined the Army.
ML 2522, We're an Army!--A Sobering Lesson on Obeying God's Rules!
Berg was also the prophet whose Letters were "the Word". When he dismissed the whole leadership structure in the 1978 reorganisation (the RNR), he said the Letters themselves would now be the leaders and would "be obeyed better". The teaching did have a limit: in 1988 Berg wrote that obedience to leaders was not an absolute to be put above Scripture and conscience.
- Legal finding
I think the letters are going to be the leaders and will be obeyed better if they don't have any upper officers interfering.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Official teaching
I still do not believe that these are total absolutes which must be put above reason, right, Scripture & personal conviction of God's Truth!
ML 2417, Obey Them That Have the Rule Over You!--"Trust and Obey," Pt. 2
What members were expected to do
Members were expected to accept the Letters, follow Home schedules, and avoid "murmuring" (voicing doubts or criticism). A 1989 list of offences that could lead to excommunication, quoted in the 1995 judgment, included unbelief in the Letters, criticising Berg, the Family or the Letters, and "failure to obey leadership". The judge heard evidence of a saying that "a suggestion is an order in love".
- Legal finding
3. Critical of Dad, Family or the letters.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Failure to obey leadership: insubordination and rebellion against leadership cannot be countenanced in any man's army.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
This reference to a suggestion confirms evidence I received that "a suggestion is an order in love."
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Excommunication backed the rules up. A 1982 compilation quoted Berg saying that although he could not force anyone to obey, he held "a few trump cards": the Letters would be withheld from those who refused to cooperate.
- Leadership instruction
I CANNOT FORCE YOU TO OBEY, BUT I HOLD A FEW TRUMP CARDS--& THOSE ARE THE LORD'S LETTERS, which we shall withhold from those who refuse to cooperate
ML 1323, Excommunication Rules & Procedures!
Members also reported on themselves. Homes sent monthly report forms (TRFs) with statistics to leadership, and from the late 1980s "Open Heart Reports" (OHRs), written confessions of one's spiritual state and "needs work on", were widely used, especially with teenagers. Before 1995, leadership also decided or approved where members lived and where Homes moved.
- Leadership instruction
WE HAVE GREATLY CONDENSED & SIMPLIFIED THE TRFs both for the benefit of the Family as well as for our stats sake
ML 1121, The Voluntary Stats!! – What We Need To Know! The “vclstat” Ltr - Legal finding
OHRs - open heart reports - were widely used as a means of forcing confession with the result that the children were made to feel guilty if they did not confess.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - The group’s own account
Leadership would counsel Homes as to whether they should or shouldn't move their Home, or what Area they should move to, even how many bedrooms they should have or whatever!
FSM 278, FSM 278 CHARTER QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS--PART ONE DO --QUESTIONS RELATING TO THE CHARTER, ANSWERED BY WS LEADERSHIP - Leadership instruction
Clearance on a Prime Ministry level would be necessary to transfer disciples from one city to another
ML 335C, The French Connection!
What members experienced
Experiences varied by decade, country and Home. A woman who joined in England in 1972 and left in Thailand in 1986 found that leadership in England had been "fairly loose" compared with Asia, where couples in her Home were made to write nightly reports. A man who was a member from 1969 to 1979 recalls that ordinary members were not even allowed to date while leaders kept other freedoms hidden, and that fund-raisers were sometimes not allowed home until they had collected enough.
- Firsthand account
leadership was fairly loose in England and they had not been exposed to a lot of discipline and authority
There is Life After the Family - Firsthand account
getting us to write nightly reports and be introspective
There is Life After the Family - Firsthand account
Since the rest of us were not even allowed to date
I Almost Didn't Make It - Firsthand account
If you didn't make enough money you were not allowed to even return home sometimes until you did.
I Almost Didn't Make It
The heaviest control fell on teenagers in the late 1980s and early 1990s. The judge found that OHRs left children in a trap: if they confessed nothing they were proud, and if they voiced doubts they were murmuring. A young man raised in Thailand, writing in 2001, describes OHR forms so long that they were "impossible to fill out without lying extensively".
- Legal finding
If they had no NWO (Needs Work On) they were said to be self righteous and proud: if they expressed their doubts and their antipathies, then they were murmuring. Either way they could not win.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
The long one was about 4 pages of small print and was impossible to fill out without lying extensively.
My Life Growing Up in the Family
Adults were also publicly corrected. In 1991 the Letters published the confessions of a young married musician placed on a correction programme, who had written: "I feel I have very little freedom and I can't do anything without permission". The judge was troubled by his public humiliation and by a choice that "virtually amounted to a denial of choice": confess, or leave for the outside world.
- Legal finding
I feel I have very little freedom and I can't do anything without permission
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
The starkness of the choice offered which virtually amounted to a denial of choice
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Not every observer saw control. A child psychiatrist called by the mother in the 1995 case did not think she was "unduly influenced" by anyone in her Home, and a psychologist who tested a small sample of children found them confident and emotionally healthy, though the judge gave his opinions reduced weight. Former members also describe gains: one writer who left in middle age credits the group with "great training in scripture memorization" and with teaching unselfishness.
- Legal finding
I did not have the impression that she was unduly influenced either by anyone at the house or, "faith" excepted, by external forces of some kind.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
The fact that Dr Lilliston seems to have viewed The Family through his rose coloured spectacles, reduces the weight I can place upon his opinions, but I do not discount them entirely.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
the Family does give great training in scripture memorization and living together is great education to teach us to be unselfish
Amazing Thoughts Since I Left the Family
Where teaching and experience diverged
The claim that members could leave at any time was true in a narrow sense: people did leave, in large numbers. But the teaching made leaving costly. Berg wrote that God was angry with "backsliders", and in 1984 told murmurers to "get out". The judge pointed out what this meant for teenagers born into the group, often in a foreign country with no outside family: they had "nowhere else to go".
- Later response by the group
Many of them, for a variety of reasons, have felt led to leave the Family and pursue other courses in their lives.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Legal finding
If you don't like it here, for God's sake, get out and go some place else where you like it better.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Official teaching
ONE REASON WHY GOD GETS SO ANGRY WITH BACKSLIDERS IS THAT THEY'RE SUCH A TERRIBLE TESTIMONY AND SELDOM EVER BACKSLIDE ALONE!
ML 313C, Backsliding! - Legal finding
I am troubled that there seems a woeful lack of appreciation just how terrifying it must be for the young teenager, perhaps in a foreign field, to "go some place else where you like it better" when he has nowhere else to go.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The pressure to conform was not an accident of a few Homes. It followed from the teaching that obedience to leaders and the Letters was obedience to God and that doubt was spiritual danger. The judge summed up the effect: because obedience was "a clarion call" and murmuring "a cardinal crime", members could not voice criticism of Berg. He found "the intensity of pressure on adult and child alike to conform" concerning, while accepting that communal life needs some discipline.
- Legal finding
Since obedience was a clarion call and since murmuring was a cardinal crime, members faithful to him were unable to articulate criticism of him.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
So, speaking generally, is the intensity of pressure on adult and child alike to conform.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Communal life breaks down unless its members accept a large measure of discipline and refrain from carping criticism because it is destructive.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Critics and some former members describe this as mind control or brainwashing. The group rejected the charge in March 1993 in a long statement that called such theories a myth used against minority religions and said ex-members' accounts were shaped by deprogrammers. That statement is the group's own position; the 1995 judgment did not use the language of mind control but did find real pressure, fear of expulsion and public humiliation, especially of children. Scholars of new religions are themselves divided on the brainwashing model, as the group's statement notes.
- Later response by the group
The Family resolutely denies that as a group or as individuals we insidiously control the thoughts and actions of our members.
OUR RESPONSE TO ALLEGATIONS OF MIND CONTROL AND BRAINWASHING - Disputed allegation
recriminative attitudes are exhibited primarily by ex-members who have been deprogrammed or have otherwise been involved in ex-member support groups
OUR RESPONSE TO ALLEGATIONS OF MIND CONTROL AND BRAINWASHING - Legal finding
Undue pressure was placed on children by the traumatic testimonies and the fear that any raising of doubt would lead to expulsion from The Family and banishment to the system caused apprehension.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Theological analysis: the group could point to Hebrews 13:17 ("Obey them that have the rule over you"), a text many churches also cite. Mainstream traditions usually balance it with Acts 5:29 ("We ought to obey God rather than men") and 1 Peter 5:3, which warns leaders not to be "lords over God's heritage". The Reformed Westminster Confession states that God "alone is lord of the conscience". Berg's own 1988 caveat comes close to this; the 1989 claim that obeying officers was obeying God does not, though churches differ widely in how much authority they give their clergy.
- Theological analysis
Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit yourselves: for they watch for your souls, as they that must give account, that they may do it with joy, and not with grief: for that is unprofitable for you.
Hebrews 13:17 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men.
Acts 5:29 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
Neither as being lords over God's heritage, but being ensamples to the flock.
1 Peter 5:3 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
God alone is lord of the conscience, and hath left it free from the doctrines and commandments of men
Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), chapter XX, section 2 ↗
How the organisation responded
Structures changed several times. The 1978 RNR dismissed the old chain of leaders, and the 1981 Fellowship Revolution introduced leaders elected by members. The judge found, though, that Berg and his inner circle kept control through the Letters. A leadership summit in 1990 moved decisions to teams, which the judge called "the beginning of the end of Berg's supremacy".
- Legal finding
with a pyramid of leadership this time elected by the members rather than imposed from above
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
He, with his inner cabinet, was in sole control.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
It was the beginning of the end of Berg's supremacy.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
In 1993 Maria invited teenagers to air their complaints. Their requests, quoted in the judgment, included to "eliminate meaningless rules", more choice in their ministries and fewer double standards. In a letter to the judge, Peter Amsterdam said the group was committed to "as much openness as possible".
- Legal finding
eliminate meaningless rules, and to apply the legitimate ones less legalistically.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
As leader of The Family, I would like to affirm that we are committed to a long term policy of fostering as much openness as possible, both within our communities and in our relations outside.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The Love Charter, in force from 1 April 1995, was the biggest change. It gave members a "Right of Mobility" to move to another Home or country, or start a new one, on thirty days' notice, and it set written limits on leaders. Maria told members they could move "whenever you want to". In 1996 Peter Amsterdam wrote that leadership had "greatly curtailed its authority" over Homes and individuals.
- Leadership instruction
This means that you could personally initiate a change of Homes or fields if you wish, as outlined in the Love Charter.
FSM 266, FSM 266 / FN 375 DO 1995 Family Birthday Celebration--Special Issue! - Leadership instruction
You have the Right of Mobility, you have the right to move whenever you want to.
ML 2978, Serve One Another in Love!--Mama's Epilogue to the Love Charter - Later response by the group
Family leadership has greatly curtailed its authority over Family Homes or individual members.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
Authority did not disappear. In 1998 Peter Amsterdam complained that freedom had been "carried to the extreme" and reminded regional officers that disciplining members who broke the Charter was their duty. Members on partial excommunication lost their right of mobility, and in 2003 members in Brazil had their right to change countries suspended as a punishment. In 2010 TFI ended required communal living (see Community vs. Independence).
- Leadership instruction
there are restrictions on the authority of leadership, and we have put that in place to keep our leadership from exercising too much authority over Homes and individuals, as some have in the past.
ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities - Leadership instruction
the freedom to exercise individual rights has been carried to the extreme
ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities - Leadership instruction
you would lose your right of mobility
ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities - Leadership instruction
their right of mobility to change countries has been suspended until they have passed through the six months of chastisement
GV 156, Grape Vine #156 - The group’s own account History (The Family International website) ↗
Sources and the limits of the evidence
The main sources are Berg's Letters on leadership and obedience (1971, 1988, 1989), the 1982 excommunication rules, the group's March 1993 "Response to Allegations of Mind Control and Brainwashing", the 1995 Love Charter and its 1998 commentary, and Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment. The judgment's section on control relies heavily on internal publications and on witnesses from both sides, whom the judge assessed individually.
- Later response by the group
Issued March 1993
OUR RESPONSE TO ALLEGATIONS OF MIND CONTROL AND BRAINWASHING - Legal finding
(a) how control was exercised by the leadership;
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
How much control members felt is hard to measure and changed over time. Former members' accounts, and the group's 1993 statement, each have a stake in their account. This article does not judge the brainwashing debate; it sets the group's denial beside court findings and testimony. The archive contains no survey of current or former members on how free they felt.
- Later response by the group
There is a great diversity in the way those previously in the Family feel about the Family and their time as members.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
From teaching to reform
How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.
Berg teaches liberation from the "System" but also obedience to leaders and to his Letters as obedience to God.
- Official teaching
YOU CONTINUE TO OWE THEM YOUR ALLEGIANCE, RESPECT, AND OBEDIENCE.
ML 143, Personal Visits--(part I)--Sin In The Camp - Official teaching
if you want to obey God, you'd better obey us
ML 2522, We're an Army!--A Sobering Lesson on Obeying God's Rules!
- Official teaching
Reports, confessions, public correction and excommunication for murmuring; leaders decide where members live.
- Legal finding
Murmurers, troublemakers and bad apples. Excommunicate them.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - The group’s own account
Leadership would counsel Homes as to whether they should or shouldn't move their Home
FSM 278, FSM 278 CHARTER QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS--PART ONE DO --QUESTIONS RELATING TO THE CHARTER, ANSWERED BY WS LEADERSHIP
- Legal finding
Intense pressure to conform, fear of expulsion among teenagers with nowhere else to go, and public humiliation.
- Legal finding
the intensity of pressure on adult and child alike to conform
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
when he has nowhere else to go
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- Legal finding
Team decision-making (1990); Love Charter limits on leaders and Right of Mobility (1995); end of required communal living (2010).
- Leadership instruction
You have the Right of Mobility, you have the right to move whenever you want to.
ML 2978, Serve One Another in Love!--Mama's Epilogue to the Love Charter - The group’s own account History (The Family International website) ↗
- Leadership instruction
How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.