Teachings vs. Experiences

Growing Up in the Children of God: The Second Generation

What was it like growing up in the Children of God?

Growing up in the Children of God meant being raised from birth as a missionary in communal Homes, usually schooled at home on the group's own materials, often moved between countries and sometimes separated from parents. Many second-generation members describe warmth, music, languages and a strong sense of purpose, but courts and the group itself later acknowledged serious harms in the 1970s to early 1990s, including sexual abuse of children, harsh discipline and isolation, and limited secondary education. Experiences varied widely by decade, country and Home, and from 1995 onwards the group apologised and introduced children's rights, compulsory schooling and, in 2010, formal education.

Childhood identity and religious formation

Children born into the group, the "second generation", were raised to see themselves as part of a revolutionary Endtime army. In 1973 Berg wrote that the children being born would "never have known anything but our kind of life", and he told members that the children belonged to everyone: "They're our children!" A 1992 public statement compared them to the boy Samuel, dedicated to God's service from childhood, while saying the final choice of service was theirs.

  • Legal finding The little ones being born will never have known anything but our kind of life! Judgement of Lord Justice Ward · Berg's 1973 Letter "New Bottles", as quoted in the 1995 judgment
  • Official teaching They're our children! Not your children or my children--they are our children, God's children! ML 292, Women In Love (December 20, 1973)
  • Our children, like young Samuel in the Bible, grow up in a lifestyle totally dedicated to full-time service for the Lord. The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children (April 1992)
  • We raise our children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, but leave the ultimate choice of service up to them. The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children (April 1992)

Faith was formed through daily "Word time" (group reading of Berg's Letters and the Bible), memorisation, singing and witnessing. Some who grew up in the group say this gave them a clear identity. One second-generation member wrote in 1996 that witnessing as a child had taught them what being in the Family meant. Others found the hours of group reading tedious and say they learned to look as if they were listening.

Education

Berg taught in 1975 that the group's children needed only a basic education and that even senior high school was unnecessary. Children were taught at home or in the group's own schools, using a curriculum built around the Bible and the Letters. The group publicly defended home schooling in 1993 as giving children close, caring supervision.

Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment gave a mixed assessment. He found that young children received a wholly satisfactory education and often learned to read, write and count earlier than their peers, and he accepted a local authority's report that one Home's educational needs were being met. But he found no evidence of any child going on to further education, and called this "a limitation on the full development of the child".

Policy changed after 1995. The Charter gave children under 16 a right to an adequate education, and in 1996 Maria said home schooling was best but not the only way. In 2003 a Charter amendment made it compulsory for young people to receive an education leading to a high school diploma. Scholars report that after the 2010 Reboot children were to receive formal education rather than home schooling.

  • Later response by the group Children under the age of 16 have the right to sufficient time, opportunity and educational materials to receive an adequate education ML 3066, OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION
  • Later response by the group it is now compulsory that Family young people receive an education enabling them to obtain a high school diploma. GV 157, Grape Vine #157 (June 15, 2003)
  • Scholarly research members could seek secular employment; and children were to have a formal education rather than home schooling. Children of God / The Family International ↗

Relationships with parents and authority

Berg taught that the wider Family came before the "private selfish family unit", and Lord Justice Ward found the call to "forsake all" weighed heavily on parents. In 1993 Maria wrote to a leader separated from her children by her work that this was part of forsaking all, including children forsaking their parents for the privilege of membership.

Separation was common in some periods. A young man raised in Thailand recalled that under the late 1980s "School Vision", children were grouped by age in separate Homes and he saw his parents once a month. A woman who left in 1986 wrote that children at that time were being dealt with harshly and separated from their parents, and that this was why she left with hers. Many children also had many adult carers besides their parents, which some recall warmly.

  • Firsthand account This meant that I would be moving away from my parents for the first time, and we were to get to see our parents once a month My Life Growing Up in the Family
  • Firsthand account It was a time when The Family children were really being dealt with harshly for any kind of aberrance and separated from their parents There is Life After the Family (May 2002) · former first-generation member and mother, writing in 2002

The 1995 Charter gave every child the right to live with at least one parent if they wished, though children of couples who both served in the leadership's World Services units were placed with guardians.

Missionary work and childhood responsibilities

Children took part in the group's missionary work from an early age: singing in shows, handing out literature and helping raise funds. Some recall this with pride. Second-generation contributors to a 1996 Family magazine recalled walking through trains handing out literature as some of their earliest memories, and said they had learned languages and confidence with strangers.

Older children and teenagers also carried adult work, including the care of younger children. A former member raised in the group described Home life as cleaning bathrooms, fund-raising, proselytising, office work, childcare or shepherding. A former member who gave evidence in the English case said children grew up "in a one way street" with no thought of doing anything except being a missionary.

Discipline and control

Berg taught corporal punishment with the rod, citing Proverbs. In the late 1980s and early 1990s special programmes for teenagers seen as rebellious, known as "Victor Programmes", used "silence restriction" (a ban on speaking), isolation and long sessions of reading. Lord Justice Ward found that isolation was used to dominate and punish children, that children at a camp in Macau were put to excessive hard labour, and called the Macau regime a shameful example of the end justifying the means.

Firsthand accounts describe how this felt. The young man raised in Thailand recalled being put on silence restriction as a child for being "foolish", and having to write detailed "Open Heart Reports" on his progress. He also wrote that some carers sincerely cared for the children and that one school was run "very professionally and well".

Leaders saw some of the danger at the time. Maria wrote that strict treatment could produce "perfectly behaved children who are really quite screwed up"; Lord Justice Ward commended the words but doubted they were fully practised. The 1994 discipline guidelines made corporal punishment the exception, and in 1995 Maria apologised for excessive corporal punishment, prolonged silence restriction and isolation.

Abuse and safeguarding failures

The sexual abuse of children is the gravest harm in the second generation's history, and it is treated here separately from adult sexual practice. Lord Justice Ward found in 1995 that there had been widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members, and that Berg bore responsibility for the doctrine that misled his followers. He also found that since 1986 the group had made determined efforts to stop it.

  • Legal finding I am totally satisfied that there was widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members of The Family Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding Berg bears responsibility for propagating the doctrine which so grievously misled his flock and injured the children within it. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding has since 1986 made determined and sustained efforts to stamp out child sexual abuse Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

The group's acknowledgments came over several years. In 1995 Maria wrote that rules to protect children should have been in place much earlier and apologised to any young people who had been hurt. In 1996 Peter Amsterdam acknowledged that it had been wrong to proclaim sexual liberty without clear rules protecting children. In 2000 Maria wrote that all adult-minor sexual contact was sin and grounds for excommunication.

These acknowledgments came after years of harm, and not always fully. Lord Justice Ward criticised the leadership for presenting the Macau teen camp to its own members as a rural idyll. A former member writing in 2003 said that the abuse testimonies posted by second-generation adults on ex-member sites had been enough to make up their mind to leave. This article does not repeat the details of those accounts. TFI told A&E in 2018 that it has a zero-tolerance policy on the abuse of children.

  • Legal finding The Family now try to rewrite the truth not just to the outside world but more importantly to their own members Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Firsthand account if even ONE of their stories is the least bit true, then that’s enough proof for me to make the decision to leave a group who says they protect their children. Amazing Thoughts Since I Left the Family
  • Later response by the group The Family International has a zero-tolerance policy regarding the abusive treatment of children Belief Letters ↗ (2018)

Access to outside information

Children grew up with limited access to the outside world's media, books and schools, which Berg's Letters called "the System". The group's 1992 statement on socialisation cited Scripture on staying separate from worldly people. Lord Justice Ward found that curiosity was generally frowned upon as a sign of a doubting mind, though he also found that the strictest early rules on reading were not rigorously enforced or observed by the young.

  • Believers are warned not to become too involved with or participate in the activities of mockers and Christ-rejecting non-believers and worldly people outside the faith. SOCIALISATION (August 1992)
  • Legal finding enquiries are frowned upon on the basis that curiosity is the product of a doubting mind Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding I am satisfied that the strident strictures in the early "You are what you read" and "Book Burning" letters are not rigorously enforced and nor rigorously observed by the young. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Restrictions on films, television and music were used as discipline: from 1998 partially excommunicated members, including teenagers, lost access to television and films. A former member described reading ex-member websites as "taboo" in the early 2000s.

Autonomy and choice

Teenagers had little say over where they lived, what they studied or how they looked, and even questions about earrings, long hair and baggy clothes were decided through prophecy in 1997. Lord Justice Ward found that a teenager had told an Australian court he was happy because he could not tell his shepherd he wanted to leave, an example of emotional pressure on young members.

At the same time, the group said teenagers must choose for themselves. A 1994 study published in a collection edited by James R. Lewis and J. Gordon Melton reported members' view that the "age of decision" was between 14 and 16, and that some teenagers spent time with less committed families to see life outside. At 18, Charter membership required signing a commitment.

  • Scholarly research The age of decision is between the ages of 14 and 16, and some decide as early as 12. Sex, Slander, and Salvation · 1994 collection edited by Lewis and Melton, distributed by The Family
  • Scholarly research Members I talked to emphasized that teens themselves have to decide what they want to do. Sex, Slander, and Salvation
  • Leadership instruction Those of you in the CM Family, age 18 and over, who wish to retain your CM status, must prayerfully read and make a commitment to these CM requirements and sign the contract ML 3257, The Shakeup 2000 – the S2K (7/99)

Leaving

Many second-generation members left as teenagers or young adults, especially in the 1990s. In 1992 Maria told parents not to force teenagers to stay, and in 1996 she told them not to blame the Family when young people left. The 1994 study cited a member's guess that about 10 per cent of teenagers left, some later returning; the archive holds no reliable figures.

Some left after trying to change things from inside. A young man born in the group wrote in 2003 that he had repeatedly asked his Homes for time to study and was refused, before leaving to enrol at a community college; he added that no one was forced to stay. Former second-generation members set up MovingOn.org in 2001 to support one another. The 2005 deaths involving Ricky Rodriguez, Maria's son who had been raised as the group's heir apparent and had left in 2000, brought public attention to the experiences of those raised in the group.

Education, work and life afterwards

Those who left often had to start again with few formal qualifications. The young man who left to study had only a high school equivalency certificate (GED) and was placed at pre-algebra level, though he did better in English. Lord Justice Ward observed that young people who had left had the ability but struggled to meet the formal requirements for university.

Many went on to build careers and public lives. Former members raised in the group have published memoirs and essays: Lauren Hough's collection "Leaving Isn't the Hardest Thing" (2021), Faith Jones's "Sex Cult Nun" (2021) and Daniella Mestyanek Young's "Uncultured" (2022), whose author later served in the army. Three sisters raised in the group published "Not Without My Sister" in 2007.

Long-term consequences and recovery

Former members describe effects that lasted for years: guilt, low self-worth and difficulty making decisions. A former member who left in 1979 wrote that much of the indoctrination stays with people for years. An email circulated among ex-members in 2002 noted that few studies had looked at the needs of people born and raised in such groups.

Recovery is also a strong theme. A mother who left in 1986 wrote of her daughter, raised in the group, that each passing year took her further from her past and closer to the future waiting for her. The group's leaders apologised in 1995 to young people who had been hurt, and TFI repeated its apology in 2018.

  • Firsthand account every year that goes by, her past recedes further and further into the distance and she takes one more step into the future that's waiting for her. There is Life After the Family (May 2002)
  • Later response by the group We have prayed and asked the Lord to forgive us for not doing more in the past to prevent any such behavior, and we ask you to forgive us too. ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US (9/95)
  • Later response by the group we wish to express our sincere apologies to anyone who experienced anything negative or hurtful during their childhood or time as members of the Family International. Belief Letters ↗ (2018)

Diversity of experiences

Second-generation experiences were not uniform. Some who stayed speak positively: a 23-year-old woman who had lived in the group since the age of three wrote in 2002 that she had nearly left many times but chose to stay as a missionary, and a 1994 study found that children of less committed families described the life of full-time teens in positive terms. Lord Justice Ward found that life in one English Home was, generally speaking, happy for the children.

Even critical accounts often include good memories and people who helped. The young man raised in Thailand wrote that his early years were happy and that there were people who cared for him whom he trusted. Lord Justice Ward found that most former members looked back "more in sorrow than in anger". Experiences varied by decade, by country and by Home, and the late 1980s and early 1990s, the period of the teen programmes, appear in many accounts as the hardest.

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The evidence comes from four kinds of source that rarely agree: the group's publications, which show policy and its own accounts; Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment, which tested evidence from both sides; firsthand accounts by former members, mostly written for ex-member websites around 1998 to 2003; and positive testimonies printed in the group's magazines. The judgment covered mainly the 1980s and early 1990s and Homes in England and Asia.

  • Legal finding the scope of the enquiry expanded into issues of education, medical neglect, isolation both from the outside world and from members of the natural family. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Anonymous contributors are referred to here by role only. The archive does not hold systematic data on how many children grew up in the group, how many left, or how they fared afterwards, and memoirs published since 2007 are known here only through reviews and publishers' notices. A 2007 documentary by a former member, shown at the Slamdance festival, drew protests from people connected with the group.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1972–1975

    Berg teaches that children belong to the whole Family, that the group comes before the private family, and that children need only a basic education.

  2. Practice · 1976–early 1990s

    Children are home-schooled, take part in witnessing and fund-raising, are often grouped apart from parents, and rebellious teens are sent to Victor Programmes with silence restriction and isolation.

  3. Consequence · 1995 (court findings)

    An English court finds widespread sexual abuse of children, harsh and isolating discipline, and a limitation on secondary and further education.

  4. Reform or response · 1995–2010

    The Charter gives children rights to education and to live with a parent; Maria apologises in 1995; schooling to diploma level becomes compulsory in 2003; formal education replaces home schooling after the 2010 Reboot.

    • Later response by the group It was wrong, and we are truly sorry that any of you received any such treatment. ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US (9/95)
    • Later response by the group it is now compulsory that Family young people receive an education enabling them to obtain a high school diploma. GV 157, Grape Vine #157 (June 15, 2003)

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.