Teachings vs. Experiences
Protection of Children in the Children of God: Ideals, Abuse and Reform
Were children in the Children of God protected from abuse?
No, not consistently: although the Children of God said its children were especially loved and protected, a 1995 English High Court judgment found widespread sexual abuse of children by adults, excessive corporal punishment, abusive isolation and "silence restriction", and harsh teen camps, and held David Berg responsible for the teaching behind the sexual abuse. The group banned adult-minor sexual contact in the mid-1980s and introduced discipline rules from 1994. But between 1988 and 1993 it publicly denied abuse that it later admitted, and it apologised only in 1995 and 1996.
What the group taught
The group's public ideal was that children were a gift from God and that its communities gave them better care than the outside world. Its April 1992 statement "The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children" claimed "superior care and parenting" in every area and said that "no form of harsh, unloving discipline is allowed".
- The group’s own account
We believe that the children in our communities receive superior care and parenting in all areas when compared to society at large
The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children - The group’s own account
no form of harsh, unloving discipline is allowed
The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children
Berg's own childcare teaching was harsher. He cited Proverbs for the rod as early as 1972 and urged strict, army-like discipline in large Homes. From 1975 he wrote that his followers' children needed only a basic education and that even senior high school was "unnecessary".
- Official teaching
WHY DO YOU THINK GOD SAYS, "SPARE NOT THE ROD FOR HIS CRYING"? (Pr.19:18)
ML 1712, Home Discipline - Legal finding
Things have to be run like an army because you just can always treat each child individually in a large home with a lot of children
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Official teaching
EVEN A SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL EDUCATION IS SUPERFICIAL, extraneous and unnecessary for our kids. It's superfluous!
ML 371, The Education Revolution! – (From a Discussion on Child Education
The group's model for child-rearing was the upbringing of Davidito (Ricky Rodriguez), Maria's son, told in Letters from about 1975 and collected as "The Story of Davidito" in 1982. Berg announced it as a new childcare series meant to make the boy "an example to the world". The book described and pictured sexual contact between adult carers and the small child. The 1995 judgment found that the leadership "must have known and intended" that it be acted on.
- Official teaching
Davidito was to become an example to the world and inspire loads of childcare material!
ML 688, The Advantages of Having Children! - Legal finding
This was first printed in a series of letters from about 1975 to 1981 and then reprinted in 1982.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
The leadership must have known and intended that this book be acted upon by The Family.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Other Letters went further. In "The Devil Hates Sex" (May 1980) Berg wrote that there were "no relationship restrictions or age limitations" in the Law of Love. The group later named this discourse as the opening for sexual behaviour between adults and minors.
- Official teaching
There are no relationship restrictions or age limitations in His law of love.
ML 999, The Devil Hates Sex - Later response by the group
in 1980 Father David's statements in his discourse entitled 'The Devil Hates Sex' opened the door for sexual behavior between adults and minors
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
What members were expected to do
Discipline was shared across the Home: Berg's advice was that "anyone can discipline any of the children", not only their parents. From the late 1980s, children and teenagers in schools and teen Homes lived under demerit systems, wrote Open Heart Reports and could be placed on "silence restriction" (forbidden to speak), isolation or corporal punishment with a paddle.
- Legal finding
so that anyone can discipline any of the children and not just the particular mother or father of the offending child!
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
The corporal punishment meted out for obtaining too many demerits was by means of a "paddling"
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Teenagers who resisted the group's way of life were sent to special programmes. Teen Training Camps began in Mexico in 1986 and spread to other fields; a list of goals from one camp included learning "yieldedness". A teen detention Home operated in Macau from about 1987. "Victor" programmes for difficult young people followed from 1988-89, and in February 1991 Maria's "Discipleship Training Revolution" called for a Victor-style programme in every Home.
- Legal finding
1986 was the year of the Mexican Teen Training Camp
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
22. To learn yieldedness which is the opposite of rebelliousness and stubbornness.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Macau was a Teens Detention Camp.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
By 1988 there was so much concern about the difficulties in various field homes being experienced with the Jett age (11 to 13 years), that a council of people was called.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
We've got to somehow institute a Victor programme in all of our homes if we're going to truly reach and win our Jetts and Teens
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Schooling was done at home or in Family schools, with the Bible at the centre. A 1993 public statement described home schooling as "caring, concerned teaching and supervision". Outside schools were discouraged as worldly influence.
- The group’s own account
2. Through home schooling, our children receive caring, concerned teaching and supervision.
ADVANTAGES OF OUR FAMILY EDUCATION - Legal finding
Against the influence of system schools"
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
What members experienced
Sexual abuse. After hearing many witnesses, Lord Justice Ward found in 1995 that there had been "widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members", more than in society outside. He also found that it had been common in the 1970s and 1980s for children to be exposed to adult sexual activity. Experiences varied greatly by decade, country and Home, and the judge stressed that the group had worked since 1986 to stop such abuse.
- Legal finding
I am totally satisfied that there was widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members of The Family, and that this abuse occurred to a significantly greater extent within The Family than occurred in society outside it.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Children should not have been exposed to blatant and indiscriminate sexual activity.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
has since 1986 made determined and sustained efforts to stamp out child sexual abuse
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Discipline. The judge found corporal punishment "widespread", including severe beatings in Victor camps and in Macau, where children were also put to punitive hard labour. He found that silence restriction and isolation were "frequently carried to excess" and damaged children. In Britain in recent years, he found, children "have been harshly beaten and at times left bleeding and bruised".
- Legal finding
I am in no doubt at all that its use was widespread.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I am totally satisfied that children in the camp at Macau were put to hard labour.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
The use of isolation and silence restriction was frequently carried to excess and children were damaged by their experience of it.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
In this country and in recent years, children in the absence of their parents have been harshly beaten and at times left bleeding and bruised by indiscriminate, over-zealous applications of Family discipline.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Firsthand accounts match these findings. A young man raised in Thailand, writing in 2001, describes long periods of silence restriction from the age of about eight, and says the fear of being sent to a Victor programme was like the fear of prison. A young woman sent to the Macau Home as a teenager describes silence, paddlings, solitary confinement and nightly written confessions. Both also describe carers who were kind, and the young woman, writing in 1999-2000, says she had rebuilt her life and that her faith was "stronger than ever".
- Firsthand account
I was still on silence restriction and still wearing my mask.
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Firsthand account
the fear of being sent to a Victor Programme was similar to the fear of ever being sent to prison today.
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Firsthand account
Fear, restrictions (i.e. absolute silence), severe paddlings, and solitary confinement for "serious cases".
Merry's Story - Firsthand account
My faith is stronger than ever
Merry's Story
Education. The court found that young children were taught well, often learning to read and count earlier than children outside. Older children fared worse: education beyond primary level was narrow, aimed at missionary work, and offered no route to further education. Adults who left later describe the struggle to find work without qualifications, and also how many succeeded.
- Legal finding
I find that the young develop their reading, writing and arithmetic skills at an earlier age than their contemporaries outside the communities.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
The older the children become, the more unsatisfactory the education provision for them.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
I know many FG's who've come out in their 40's and 50's and went on to break in to the job market and make themselves very employable.
LEAVING AS AN OLDER FG MEMBER Worried about leaving The Family with no marketable skills?
Where teaching and experience diverged
Sexual abuse was not a departure from all teaching: it followed published doctrine. Berg's Letters on children and sex, the Davidito book and "The Devil Hates Sex" encouraged it, at least in the years from about 1976 to 1986, and the group's leaders later accepted that Berg must "bear responsibility for that harm". Rules against it came only from the mid-1980s. Treating this as separate from adult sexual practice matters: the judge found that children could never give the consent on which the Law of Love depended.
- Later response by the group
And we accept that as the author of ideas upon which some members acted to the harm of minors in the Family, he must bear responsibility for that harm.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Legal finding
Berg bears responsibility for propagating the doctrine which so grievously misled his flock and injured the children within it.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Harsh discipline was encouraged in general terms by Berg's Letters on the rod and by programmes designed at the top, though leaders also warned against injuring children. When the group's UK spokesman told the court that silence restriction was a local practice and "not Family policy", the judge found that evidence "neither full nor frank". He held the national leaders, not only individual carers, responsible for the Victor programmes.
- Legal finding
many who administered these punishments lost sight of the admonitions not to injure
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
It was not Family policy.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
That evidence was neither full nor frank.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
The Victor Programmes were excessively abusive but the responsibility for that lies with the National Shepherds.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The group's public statements in these years did not match what was happening. In 1992 it said its children were "mercifully spared" physical violence, that its rules were "rigorously adhered to" everywhere, and that no children had ever been involved in Flirty Fishing. Its 1993 statement against violence said it had "always abhorred" violence. The judgment found that Flirty Fishing had harmed children who knew what their mothers were doing, and that harsh beatings had continued in Britain into the 1990s.
- The group’s own account
They are mercifully spared having to endure verbal and physical violence
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE - Disputed allegation
No children or teenagers were ever involved at all in the practice of FFing.
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE - The group’s own account
The Family has always abhorred the use of violence
Our Stance Against Physical Violence - Legal finding
I also find it disturbing that The Family cannot see that the practice of FFing was harmful to the children in The Family.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Theological analysis: the group and most Christian traditions agree that parents should train and discipline children (Proverbs 13:24), and many churches have historically accepted corporal punishment. Mainstream teaching also stresses restraint, as in Ephesians 6:4 ("provoke not your children to wrath"). On sexual contact with children there is no ambiguity in historic Christianity: Jesus' warning about harming "these little ones" and the early Didache's ban on corrupting boys reflect a consistent prohibition, which Berg's "no age limitations" teaching directly contradicted.
- Theological analysis
He that spareth his rod hateth his son: but he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes.
Proverbs 13:24 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
And, ye fathers, provoke not your children to wrath: but bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.
Ephesians 6:4 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
But whoso shall offend one of these little ones which believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea.
Matthew 18:6 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
You shall do no murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not corrupt boys,
Didache, chapter 2 (J.B. Lightfoot translation, modern-English revision) ↗
How the organisation responded
1985-1989: first bans. An undated internal memo, which the group later dated to 1985, told adults not to have sex with children, "mainly because it's illegal". Later publications say adult-minor contact became an excommunicable offence in 1986, after young people at the Mexico teen camp reported it. In December 1988 Berg's "Child Abuse?!" renounced writings that seemed to approve sex with minors, while claiming the group had "never" practised it. In 1989 Maria still wrote that in "our loving Family" there would be "very little possibility of genuine abuse".
- Leadership instruction
we want to say that we do not agree with adults having sex with children. The Family should just not do it, mainly because it's illegal.
Liberty or Stumblingblock - Later response by the group
In 1986 after some of our young people complained about some adult sexual contact, Dad and I slammed the door on any and all such activity by making it an excommunicable offense.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US - Disputed allegation
but we do not advocate nor practice sex between adults & minors!—And never have!
CHILD ABUSE?! - Leadership instruction
Sex with minors, which they always term "child abuse," although in our loving Family there would be very little possibility of genuine abuse.
ML 2590, Flirty Little Teens, Beware!--"Flee Youthful Lusts!"--2Tim.2:22
1991-1993: purges and mixed messages. In June 1991 Homes were told to burn the Davidito book and cut pages from other publications. A June 1993 leadership statement banned all sexual contact between adults and anyone under 21 but said such relationships were not "inherently wrong in principle". In internal material from the leaders' summit that year, quoted by the court, Maria said she would "hate" members to act "as though Dad was wrong"; the judge found that attitude "extremely worrying".
- Leadership instruction
we are now initiating an extensive “purge” of our publications.
The Pubs Purge!--An Urgent Advisory to all Family Homes! - Leadership instruction
we do not believe that all such relationships are inherently wrong in principle, according to the Scriptures.
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love! - Legal finding
I'd just hate to have our Family members acting as though Dad was wrong when we know that is not the case.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I find that attitude extremely worrying.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
1994-1996: discipline rules and apologies. The "Family Discipline Guidelines" (May 1994) made corporal punishment the exception, advised against it after age 13 and limited silence restriction and time out. The 1995 Love Charter made violence towards one's children grounds for excommunication. In September 1995 Maria wrote that sex with minors is wrong and apologised to young people for sexual harm and for "excessive corporal punishment, prolonged 'silence restriction' and/or isolation". In a letter to the judge in October 1995, reprinted for members in 1996, Peter Amsterdam accepted Berg's responsibility, as the court had asked.
- Leadership instruction
Corporal punishment should be the exception and should only be resorted to if other approaches have not succeeded in bringing about the needed improvement,
ML 2919, Family Discipline Guidelines - Leadership instruction
We strongly suggest that after age 13 corporal punishment no longer be given,
ML 2919, Family Discipline Guidelines - Leadership instruction
If a Family member were to become violent with their mate or children, they would face excommunication.
Our Stance Against Physical Violence - Later response by the group
We have heard a number of testimonies of past excessive corporal punishment, prolonged "silence restriction" and/or isolation,
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US - Later response by the group
It was wrong, and we are truly sorry that any of you received any such treatment.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US
The court's view of these reforms was mixed. Ward found the sexual excesses eradicated and gave Maria credit for that change, but said the leadership had not fully acknowledged its responsibility, and that the new discipline rules were "still not tight enough". As a condition of the child in the case staying with his mother, he required that no one be allowed to use corporal punishment on him.
- Legal finding
Whereas the blame for the abuse which has occurred is to be laid at Berg's door, the credit for effecting change most probably can be given to Maria.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
the new discipline guidelines, well-intentioned though they are, still harp back to old Letters and are still not tight enough in their control to protect children who remain at the mercy of those in charge of them.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
to inflict corporal punishment on S
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
1998-2000: policy. The group's policy statement on sex (first issued March 1993, updated November 1998) forbids any sexual activity under 14 and excommunicates adults who have sex with anyone under 21. In July 2000 Maria wrote that "all adult/minor sexual contact is sin" and that this overrode anything written earlier. The Charter, last updated in 2020, remains TFI's governing document.
- Later response by the group
No sexual activity is permitted for those under the age of 14.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Later response by the group
members over the age of 21 will be excommunicated for engaging in sexual activity with those under the age of 21.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Later response by the group
all adult/minor sexual contact is sin. We consider it as such. It is wrong and results in excommunication.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me - The group’s own account Administration (The Family International website) ↗
Sources and the limits of the evidence
The group's own sources disagree about when adult-minor sexual contact was banned and made an offence for expulsion. Its 1992 statement says expulsion began in 1985; Maria (1995) and Peter Amsterdam (1996) say 1986; and Maria in 2000 says it was banned in 1986 and made excommunicable in 1988. The judge also noted that the 1985 memo was quoted in different versions and was never produced in court. This article gives the range, 1985 to 1988.
- The group’s own account
From that point on (1985), any adult member found guilty of having any kind of sexual contact with a minor was excommunicated from our fellowships.
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE - Later response by the group
Sexual contact between adults and minors has been an excommunicable offense since 1986.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Later response by the group
In 1988, 12 years ago, we made it excommunicable and it has remained so since then.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me - Legal finding
a slightly different version of the same document was quoted by The Family in April 1992
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Other dates also differ: the archive's copy of the Discipline Guidelines is dated May 1994, while the judgment says June 1994, and the judgment gives April 1992 for "Our Replies to Allegations of Child Abuse", whose archive copy is headed June 1992. The judge also found that the group had not always told the court the whole truth, believing itself free to deceive persecutors. The archive does not contain the group's internal records of how many adults were expelled for abuse, so the scale of enforcement cannot be measured.
- Legal finding
Some progress has been made by "The Family Discipline Guidelines" published in June 1994.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Consequently they regard themselves free to deceive the authorities and I have not always had the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth from The Family in the evidence they have presented to me.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
From teaching to reform
How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.
Berg teaches the rod, a basic education, and (1980) that the Law of Love has no age limits; the Davidito book is held up as the childcare model.
- Official teaching
There are no relationship restrictions or age limitations in His law of love.
ML 999, The Devil Hates Sex - Official teaching
Davidito was to become an example to the world and inspire loads of childcare material!
ML 688, The Advantages of Having Children!
- Official teaching
Sexual contact between adults and children in some Homes; from 1986, teen camps, the Macau detention Home and Victor programmes with paddling, silence and isolation.
- Legal finding
Macau was a Teens Detention Camp.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Silence restriction - this was widely practised as a form of punishment
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- Legal finding
The 1995 judgment finds widespread sexual abuse, excessive corporal punishment and abusive silence and isolation, and holds Berg responsible.
- Legal finding
I am totally satisfied that there was widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members of The Family
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Berg bears responsibility for propagating the doctrine which so grievously misled his flock and injured the children within it.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- Legal finding
Adult-minor contact banned (dates given range from 1985 to 1988); publications purged (1991); discipline guidelines (1994); apologies (1995–96); 1998 age rules; 2000 statement that all adult-minor contact is sin.
- Later response by the group
It was wrong, and we are truly sorry that any of you received any such treatment.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US - Later response by the group
all adult/minor sexual contact is sin.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me
- Later response by the group
How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.