Teachings vs. Experiences
The Law of Love vs. Sexual Autonomy: Consent, Pressure and Control in the Children of God
Did the Children of God's Law of Love respect members' freedom to say no to sex?
On paper the Law of Love required the willing consent of everyone involved, and from 1993 the group's policy banned any coercion. In practice sex was presented as a loving sacrifice and a test of commitment, leaders long had a say over relationships, and a 1995 English court found very great pressure on members to take part in Flirty Fishing and that the doctrine put pressure on the weak. Children could not consent at all: their abuse was a separate harm, banned from 1986 and later acknowledged by the leadership.
What the group taught: love, consent and sacrifice
The Law of Love was David Berg's teaching that, for believers, love replaced the law of Moses, so that sex outside marriage could be lawful if done in love (see the article on the Law of Love). From the start it was framed with conditions. The 1974 Letter "The Law of Love" said any sexual relationship outside the norm should have the willing consent of all concerned, including leaders, and a 1977 reply to a newspaper named "mutual consent" as a condition.
- Official teaching
any projected sexual associations SHOULD HAVE THE WILLING CONSENT OF ALL parties concerned or affected, including the approval of leadership and permission of the Body.
ML 302C, The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”! - Official teaching
As long therefore as it is in love with mutual consent and hurts no innocent one, it is lawful
ML 591, The 51 Errors of “Daily Notices”! – Of Santa Cruz, Tenerife, Canary Islands
Alongside consent, the publications presented sex as a sacrifice that a loving disciple should be willing to make. The 1995 court judgment quoted the scholar James Richardson's observation that Flirty Fishing was treated as "a test of commitment". A 1998 series, "Living the Lord's Law of Love", told members that the point of sexual sharing was "to share sacrificially, to share for unity", and a message presented as from Jesus said, "I want My young married couples to share."
- Legal finding
The FFing involvement is thought of as a test of commitment for the members.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Leadership instruction
The idea is to share God's love, to share sacrificially, to share for unity
ML 3205, Living the Lord's Law of Love - Leadership instruction
I want My young married couples to share.
ML 3208, Living the Lord's Law of Love
The group's formal policy statement on sex, first issued in 1993 and updated in 1998, put consent in plain terms: no sexual activity was compulsory and no one should "force or in any way coerce" a partner. The "Loving Jesus" teaching of 1995 to 1996, which asked members to imagine an intimate relationship with Jesus, was likewise described as a personal choice; but in 1998 Peter Amsterdam added that those who did not practise it would "forfeit some of these promised blessings".
- Later response by the group
No sexual activity is made compulsory in our communities.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Later response by the group
No one should force or in any way coerce a sexual partner to participate in any sexual activity that they do not desire to engage in.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Leadership instruction
Mama and I and the Lord Himself do not demand or require it of you.
ML 3160, Goals for 1998 - Leadership instruction
if you choose not to love Him in this new way, then you will forfeit some of these promised blessings.
ML 3160, Goals for 1998
What members were expected to do
For much of the group's history leaders had authority over members' relationships. The 1974 Letter required leadership approval for relationships outside the norm, and a 1983 question to Berg spoke of couples who had been "mated for the work's sake (or by old leaders)" and never fallen in love. A woman who joined around 1970, writing in 1999, described leaders arranging her marriage before sending the couple abroad. Berg briefly removed this control in 1978, declaring "no permission needed for sex"; in November 1996 Maria wrote that the 1995 Charter had been introduced partly because members wanted more control over their own lives and relationships.
- Official teaching
including the approval of leadership and permission of the Body.
ML 302C, The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”! - Reported practice
WHAT ADVICE CAN BE GIVEN TO MARRIAGES where those involved were mated for the work's sake (or by old leaders) & never were in love?
ML 1643, Answers to Your Questions! – No.9 - Firsthand account
to get to know Jubal before they married us and sent us off to South America.
My experience with the COG/Family - Legal finding
Family sex: no permission needed for sex! - if legal and with mutual consent.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Later response by the group
People wanted more control over their individual lives, decisions, moves, relationships, etc.
ML 3097, CELEBRATING OUR SECOND ANNIVERSARY OF THE LOVE CHARTER
Women were expected to consider Flirty Fishing (FFing), the use of sexual attraction and often sex to win converts and supporters, which ran from about 1974 to 1987. Lord Justice Ward accepted that it was formally voluntary, but found "very great pressure" on members to take part, and that almost all the adult women who gave evidence had done so.
- Legal finding
I accept that it was voluntary
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
There was, however, very great pressure on the disciples to take part in this "ministry."
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
the adult women who gave evidence practised FFing.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Within Homes, sexual "sharing" between members was expected as part of living the Law of Love fully, though how it was arranged changed over time. By the early 1990s in England, Ward found that sharing between adults was arranged between the couple, that married partners needed more discussion, and that "sharing schedules are not the norm". Members were also encouraged to take up the Loving Jesus practice even if it went against their "natural way of thinking".
- Legal finding
It can be voluntarily arranged between the couple
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Sharing schedules are not the norm.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Leadership instruction
Even if it still goes contrary to your natural way of thinking or looking at things, we hope you'll step out by faith and try it.
ML 3160, Goals for 1998
What adult members experienced
Firsthand accounts describe pressure that was hard to refuse. The woman who joined around 1970 recalled Letters rebuking members who would not share their partners, equating refusal "with not loving Jesus". When a new leader told her that members were now to share "with the brothers right in our communes", and leaders proposed separating her from her husband so that she could "grow spiritually", she felt she had little room to object.
- Firsthand account
He equated it with not loving Jesus, not being full of the love of God.
My experience with the COG/Family - Firsthand account
Mo was starting to demand that we too obey and not only share with "fish," but also start sharing with the brothers right in our communes.
My experience with the COG/Family - Firsthand account
should have a separation for a while, in order for me to grow spiritually, and accept the Lord's new revelations in the Mo letters.
My experience with the COG/Family
A man who was a member for ten years until 1979, writing in 1998, said that women in his Home were "absolutely scared of refusing" men who asked them for sex, and that women were pressured to accept payment in Flirty Fishing. Ward reached a general conclusion: by removing ordinary inhibitions, the Law of Love empowered people with strong urges and poor judgment and "put pressure upon the weak to succumb to that which does in fact harm them and infringe their freedom".
- Firsthand account
The women were absolutely scared of refusing the men who asked them for sex.
I Almost Didn't Make It - Firsthand account
The women were pressured to receive payment for sexual services rendered.
I Almost Didn't Make It - Legal finding
it put pressure upon the weak to succumb to that which does in fact harm them and infringe their freedom.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Other members described the same practices as freely chosen. The group's own history of its sexual policies spoke of members who "cheerfully and sometimes sacrificially" gave themselves to others, and a member writing in a Family magazine in 2000 said they had not shared because of "any pressure from Mama". Ward found that current members who had taken part in Flirty Fishing regarded it as "a sacred, sacrificial ministry", while some former members looked back on it with "deep horror and regret".
- The group’s own account
who cheerfully and sometimes sacrificially chose to give of themselves to help these brethren.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
We didn’t share sexually because there was any pressure from Mama to do so or because it was the “in thing.”
FSM 353, FSM 353 - Legal finding
For them it is a sacred, sacrificial ministry.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
She spoke convincingly of her deep horror and regret at having taken part
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
A separate harm: children and teenagers
Sexual contact between adults and children is not a question of autonomy, because children cannot consent. It is treated here separately from adult practice. The leadership later acknowledged that Berg's 1980 discourse "The Devil Hates Sex" opened the door to sexual behaviour between adults and minors, and in 1995 Lord Justice Ward found widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members. He also found that children had been exposed to adult sexual activity, which he called abusive.
- Later response by the group
in 1980 Father David's statements in his discourse entitled 'The Devil Hates Sex' opened the door for sexual behavior between adults and minors
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Legal finding
I am totally satisfied that there was widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members of The Family
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Children should not have been exposed to blatant and indiscriminate sexual activity.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The prohibitions came late and their reasons shifted. A 1985 internal memo told adults to stop, "mainly because it's illegal"; Family publications say adult-minor contact became an excommunicable offence in 1986 (other sources give 1985 or 1988); and in 1990 members agreed to forbid sexual contact between adults and anyone under 21. Yet a 1993 leadership statement still said such relationships were not all "inherently wrong in principle".
- Leadership instruction
The Family should just not do it, mainly because it's illegal.
Liberty or Stumblingblock - Later response by the group
In 1986 after some of our young people complained about some adult sexual contact, Dad and I slammed the door on any and all such activity by making it an excommunicable offense.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US - Later response by the group
Our members agreed to forbid any sexual contact between adults and anyone under the age of 21
OUR REPLIES TO ALLEGATIONS OF CHILD ABUSE - Leadership instruction
we do not believe that all such relationships are inherently wrong in principle, according to the Scriptures.
ML 2858, Our Beliefs Concerning the Lord's Law of Love!
Teenagers' own freedom to say no became an issue after the 1995 Charter allowed 16- and 17-year-olds sexual relations within their own age group. In 1998 Maria reported that some teens felt that "sexual activity is expected of them, even though they may not feel ready". In 2000 the leadership said a proposed "marriage of the generations" had been dropped partly because young second-generation women might feel pressured to have sex with older first-generation men.
- Leadership instruction
our 16- and 17-year-old members are allowed to have full sexual relations within the 16- through 20-year-old age group, if they so desire.
ML 2978, Serve One Another in Love!--Mama's Epilogue to the Love Charter - Reported practice
This constant reminder makes them feel pressured that people are watching them and that sexual activity is expected of them, even though they may not feel ready.
ML 3204, Living the Lord's Law of Love - Later response by the group
there was the possibility that young SGA women would feel pressured to have sex with FGA men.
ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me
Where teaching and experience diverged
Consent was written into the teaching from 1974, so coercion was formally prohibited. But the same teaching framed sharing as sacrificial love, tested commitment through Flirty Fishing and, for long periods, placed relationships under leaders' approval. That combination made pressure likely even where force was forbidden. The leadership's own 1998 rules show what had been happening: members were told not to accuse anyone who declined of "not living the Law of Love or of being selfish".
- Leadership instruction
you are not to accuse that person of not living the Law of Love or of being selfish, etc.
ML 3205, Living the Lord's Law of Love - Leadership instruction
There is definite freedom of choice regarding sex in our Family, and no one is to feel forced in any way.
ML 3202, Living the Lord's Law of Love
By 2001 the leadership admitted that "serious problems" remained in how the sexual side of the Law of Love was practised, including people "misusing the Law of Love to get what they want". It blamed members' implementation rather than the doctrine. Ward reached the opposite view: the Law of Love was "liable to be abused and was calculated to be abusive".
- Leadership instruction
Hundreds of pages have been published on the Law of Love, and yet there are some serious problems in the implementation of the sexual side of it.
GN 965, Personal Checklist -- GN965 - Leadership instruction
People misusing the Law of Love to get what they want.
GN 965, Personal Checklist -- GN965 - Leadership instruction
The doctrine is not on trial here; it's people's implementation of it that must be judged.
GN 965, Personal Checklist -- GN965 - Legal finding
In short the Law of Love was liable to be abused and was calculated to be abusive.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
For children the record is different again. Sexual contact with minors was not a misapplied adult freedom but a harm that some publications had opened the door to before 1986 and that policy then prohibited. Experiences of adults varied by decade, country and Home, and many members say they chose freely; that does not cancel the testimony of those who say they did not.
- Later response by the group
lit was published that challenged the barriers between adult/minor sexual contact, opening the door to some members crossing over that barrier.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US
How the organisation responded
Restrictions came in stages. Flirty Fishing ended in September 1987, when Berg banned sex with outsiders who were not already close friends, and the 1993/1998 policy limited sex to Charter members. The 1995 Charter gave members a "Right of Mobility" to change Homes without leadership permission, which reduced leaders' control over where and with whom members lived.
- Legal finding
Berg officially put an end to FFing in September 1987
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Later response by the group
members must refrain from having sexual contact with anyone other than another Charter member of The Family.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Later response by the group
This means that you could personally initiate a change of Homes or fields if you wish, as outlined in the Love Charter.
FSM 266, FSM 266 / FN 375 DO 1995 Family Birthday Celebration--Special Issue!
The leadership apologised in general terms. In September 1995 Maria told former members that "if any of you ex-members who may be reading this have had negative sexual experiences while with us", the Family was sorry; in the same letter she said sex with minors was wrong. Peter Amsterdam's 1996 open letter repeated the apology and accepted that Berg bore responsibility for harm to minors.
- Later response by the group
if any of you ex-members who may be reading this have had negative sexual experiences while with us, or you were treated unlovingly or harshly, either before or after you left the Family, we are sorry.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Later response by the group
the liberties we are granted under the Law of Love do not include sex with minors, that to have sex with minors is wrong.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US - Later response by the group
he must bear responsibility for that harm.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
The principle itself was not withdrawn. The 1998 series restated it while adding explicit rules against pressure, and after the 2010 Reboot, according to Eileen Barker and Sarah Harvey, sexual sharing outside marriage remained permissible between consenting adults but was no longer encouraged.
- Leadership instruction
You are responsible to not pressure anyone to have sex with you.
ML 3205, Living the Lord's Law of Love - Scholarly research
sexual sharing outside marriage, although still permissible between consenting adults, was not encouraged;
Children of God / The Family International ↗
Sources and the limits of the evidence
The main sources are Berg's Letters of 1974 to 1980, the 1993/1998 policy statement on sex, the 1993 leadership statement on the Law of Love, the 1998 series "Living the Lord's Law of Love", the Loving Jesus material of 1995 to 1998, and Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment, which heard testimony from current and former members. Firsthand accounts are from former members writing between 1998 and 2003, and from current members in Family magazines.
- Later response by the group
(Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex was first published March 1993 and updated November 1998.)
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Legal finding
THE RT. HON. LORD JUSTICE WARD DATED 19TH OCTOBER 1995
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The archive cannot show how often members agreed to sex they did not want, because no survey of the question exists, and both critics and the group have reasons to present the record in their own way. This article does not repeat the explicit wording of some sources. The history of the doctrine is in the article on the Law of Love; the protection of children is covered in its own article.
- Legal finding
I have no evidence to suggest and I do not find that sharing, as practised in this country at this time, is flagrantly conducted in public.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
From teaching to reform
How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.
The Law of Love requires willing consent but also presents sex as sacrificial love, needs leadership approval, and treats Flirty Fishing as a test of commitment.
- Official teaching
SHOULD HAVE THE WILLING CONSENT OF ALL parties concerned or affected, including the approval of leadership
ML 302C, The Law of Love! – Another Letter on “All Things”! - Legal finding
The FFing involvement is thought of as a test of commitment for the members.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- Official teaching
Women are pressed to take part in Flirty Fishing and members to share within Homes; leaders arrange or separate couples.
- Legal finding
There was, however, very great pressure on the disciples to take part in this "ministry."
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
start sharing with the brothers right in our communes.
My experience with the COG/Family
- Legal finding
Some adults agree to sex under pressure; children are abused and exposed to adult sexual activity.
- Legal finding
it put pressure upon the weak to succumb to that which does in fact harm them and infringe their freedom.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I am totally satisfied that there was widespread sexual abuse of young children and teenagers by adult members of The Family
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- Legal finding
Adult-minor contact banned (1986); Flirty Fishing ended (1987); the policy statement forbids coercion (1993/1998); the leadership apologises (1995–1996); after 2010 sharing is no longer encouraged.
- Later response by the group
No one should force or in any way coerce a sexual partner
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Scholarly research
sexual sharing outside marriage, although still permissible between consenting adults, was not encouraged;
Children of God / The Family International ↗
- Later response by the group
How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.