Teachings vs. Experiences
Missionary Service vs. Childhood: How the Children of God's Mission Shaped Its Children
How did the missionary lifestyle of the Children of God affect the children raised in it?
Children raised in the Children of God (later The Family) were brought up to be missionaries: they moved often between Homes and countries, were schooled at home on the group's own curriculum, and took part in witnessing, singing and fundraising from an early age. Inspectors and a 1995 English court found that young children were well taught, but that teenagers received a narrow secondary education, were socially isolated and were poorly prepared for further study or work outside. Many also gained languages and experience of other cultures, and the group widened education rights from 1995 and ended home schooling as the norm in 2010.
What the group taught: children as the next generation of missionaries
From the early 1970s David Berg taught that children born into the movement would be raised entirely for its mission. In the 1973 Letter "New Bottles", quoted in the 1995 English High Court judgment, he hoped they would grow up "never knowing what churchianity and system jobs and education are like". In 1975 he wrote that they needed only a basic education and that even senior high school was unnecessary.
- Legal finding
Your children will be totally revolutionary, never knowing what churchianity and system jobs and education are like!
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Official teaching
OUR CHILDREN NEED ONLY WHAT IS KNOWN AS A BASIC EDUCATION which used to be the common thing in the old days.
ML 371, The Education Revolution! – (From a Discussion on Child Education - Official teaching
EVEN A SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL EDUCATION IS SUPERFICIAL, extraneous and unnecessary for our kids. It's superfluous!
ML 371, The Education Revolution! – (From a Discussion on Child Education
Berg also taught that children should learn through the group's work rather than through schools. In "The Advantages of Having Children" (1978), as the judgment records, he told parents to take their children out witnessing with literature ("litnessing") and asking for donated goods ("provisioning"). The call to "forsake all" applied to children too: Berg's 1972 Letter "One Wife" said it "means your children also".
- Legal finding
Take the children litnessing take the children provisioning in every single home.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
don't forget this means your children also.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
In the early 1990s, under police and welfare investigations, the group set out its view publicly. Its stated aim was to foster "total dedication to God and Christian discipleship" in its children. Its 1993 statement on education presented travel and languages as advantages of missionary life, saying travel was "a natural part of being a missionary" and that most adults in a Home spoke more than one language.
- Legal finding
To foster total dedication to God and Christian discipleship in all of our children
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - The group’s own account
Travel is not only for the privileged few, it is a natural part of being a missionary.
ADVANTAGES OF OUR FAMILY EDUCATION - The group’s own account
The majority of adult members in a typical Family Home are proficient in more than one language and many of these language skills are passed on to the children.
ADVANTAGES OF OUR FAMILY EDUCATION
What children were expected to do
Children took part in the group's outreach. The 1993 education statement describes children singing, dancing and putting on puppet shows in orphanages and old people's homes. Berg recalled his own children singing "in the parks, streets, cafes, hotels", and a 1990 Letter shows Maria asking whether children should go busking with an open guitar case for donations.
- The group’s own account
they often participate in witnessing through performances such as singing, dancing, and even puppet shows in institutions, orphanages, senior citizens' rest homes, etc.
ADVANTAGES OF OUR FAMILY EDUCATION - Official teaching
the kids played & sang in the parks, streets, cafes, hotels, etc.
ML 769, Door-To-Door Witnessing! – NRS 13 - Official teaching
What do you think about taking children out busking & having them sing & putting out a guitar case for donations, or having some of them collect donations with little cans?
ML 2627, Can the Canning!
Formal study took a limited share of a teenager's week. Rules issued in 1991 required at least 12 hours of "scholastics" a week for pre-teens ("JETTs", aged 11 to 13) and teens, or 6 hours for teens who were up to standard, and released teens of 16 and over who were doing fairly well from scholastics altogether. After Summit '93 the requirement was cut from 12 to 8 hours.
- Legal finding
teens 16 years of age or older, who are doing fairly well scholastically, are no longer required to have scholastics, but could possibly use the 6 hours weekly for ministry training.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
This was reduced from 12 to 8 hours a week.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Teenagers were also expected to work in the Home. The group described child care as practical training for older teens, and listed secretarial work, translating, mechanics and music among their vocational skills. A man raised in the group, writing in 2003, listed the work that filled members' time: "cleaning bathrooms, fund-raising, proselytizing, office work, childcare or shepherding". In 1990 Maria acknowledged that many parents had "virtually had to" hand the care of their children to others in order to carry out their ministries.
- The group’s own account
Older teens & young adults, if they choose, may become actively involved in child care as part of their vocational training.
ADVANTAGES OF OUR FAMILY EDUCATION - The group’s own account
including secretarial work, word processing, computer skills, translating, mechanics, drama, music, construction, audio and video recording
The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children - Firsthand account
cleaning bathrooms, fund-raising, proselytizing, office work, childcare or shepherding
Want Higher Education? Getting Smarter and Making It Pay! - Legal finding
You may have been able to commit the care of your children to other teachers, helpers and overseers, and in many cases, you've virtually had to do that in order to fulfil the different ministries to which the Lord has called you.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Children went where their parents or leaders were sent. Until the 1995 Charter, leadership decided where Homes moved and approved transfers of members; in 1975 moving disciples between cities needed clearance at "Prime Ministry level". After Berg's 1988 "School Vision", children from several Homes were often gathered into school Homes away from their parents.
- Leadership instruction
Clearance on a Prime Ministry level would be necessary to transfer disciples from one city to another
ML 335C, The French Connection! - Later response by the group
Leadership would counsel Homes as to whether they should or shouldn't move their Home, or what Area they should move to
FSM 278, FSM 278 CHARTER QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS--PART ONE DO --QUESTIONS RELATING TO THE CHARTER, ANSWERED BY WS LEADERSHIP - Legal finding
The Family responded by tending either to open schools or to gather the children from several homes together to form a school home.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
What children experienced
Frequent moves are a constant theme in firsthand accounts. A man born into the group in 1980, writing in 2001, moved from England to Hong Kong, Macau and Thailand before he was two, and as a child of eight to ten was sent with his age group to a school Home where they saw their parents once a month. A woman interviewed by The Telegraph in 2002 spent her first years "travelling round South America in a caravan" and once went three years without seeing her mother. Lord Justice Ward found it uncontradicted that many young children were separated from their parents and moved from one country to another.
- Firsthand account
we moved to Hong Kong and Macau when I was very young and then to Thailand when I was 2 years old.
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Firsthand account
This meant that I would be moving away from my parents for the first time, and we were to get to see our parents once a month
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Journalism
Sarah spent her first few years travelling round South America in a caravan.
'THEY TOLD US WE MIGHT HAVE TO DIE' - Journalism
I once went three years without seeing her.
'THEY TOLD US WE MIGHT HAVE TO DIE' - Legal finding
many, many young children were separated from their parents, and were moved from one foreign field to another.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The group's uniform home-schooling programme gave some continuity. The judgment noted that records and a common curriculum allowed children to move "from country to country" without changing their approach to study. For young children the results were good: Ward found that they learned to read, write and count earlier than children outside, and local education inspectors in England described the arrangement as "a small private school with a particular religious emphasis".
- Legal finding
this had the great advantage of enabling children to move from home to home, indeed from country to country whilst still maintaining uniformity of approach.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I find that the young develop their reading, writing and arithmetic skills at an earlier age than their contemporaries outside the communities.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
In many ways the arrangement is that of a small private school with a particular religious emphasis.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Secondary education was another matter. A young man who had left told the court that children grew up "in a one way street" with no thought of doing anything except being a missionary. Ward found that teaching for older children leaned heavily on the group's own literature, that some material was prohibited, and that the children were "not wholly free to pursue their intellectual interests".
- Legal finding
Children suffer - you grow up in a one way street with no other thought of anything else to do except to be a missionary.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I am, however, equally satisfied that the children are not wholly free to pursue their intellectual interests as they wish.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
On socialisation the group and the court disagreed. The Family's 1992 statement "Socialisation" answered agencies' concerns by arguing that its children were more highly socialised than most, living in a fellowship of "close to 100 nationalities" and meeting many kinds of people while witnessing. The inspectors found that most of the children's friendships were within the group, and Ward concluded that "the children were socially isolated".
- The group’s own account
The concern has been raised by certain agencies that our children may not be receiving sufficient opportunity to socialise with their peers and persons outside our communities.
SOCIALISATION - The group’s own account
Ours is a multi-national fellowship of close to 100 nationalities.
SOCIALISATION - Legal finding
Although children from the village visit the home, most friendships are within The Family.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
4. The children were socially isolated.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Some benefits are also on record. The inspectors saw older children giving musical performances in other towns, including at Diwali celebrations in Leicester. The man raised in the group who wrote about college in 2003 found his English stronger than his maths, "probably from all the writing and reporting we were used to doing", and the man born in 1980 described one of his schools as "run very professionally and well". The group's claim that its children commonly learned several languages comes from its own publications; the firsthand accounts in the archive say little about this either way.
- Legal finding
Some of the older children give musical entertainment in other towns and some have performed in the recent Diwali celebrations in Leicester.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
I did better in English though, probably from all the writing and reporting we were used to doing
Want Higher Education? Getting Smarter and Making It Pay! - Firsthand account
I must say at this point that the Junior JeTT school was run very professionally and well.
My Life Growing Up in the Family
Identity and preparation for adulthood were the most lasting concerns. Ward listed "the loss of identity, self esteem and self respect and loss of freedom" among the issues affecting teenagers, and found that "self was subjugated to service to The Family". A former member writing in 2002 worried about young people who "don't even know what country they can call home". The man who wrote about college had only a high-school equivalency certificate (GED) when he left in 2000 and was placed in pre-algebra; he enrolled at a community college anyway and went on studying.
- Legal finding
the loss of identity, self esteem and self respect and loss of freedom
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
6. Self was subjugated to service to The Family.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
Or don't even know what country they can call home and belong to?
There is Life After the Family - Firsthand account
All I had was a GED, and I didn't know if colleges accepted that piece of paper.
Want Higher Education? Getting Smarter and Making It Pay! - Firsthand account
I was placed at pre-algebra status.
Want Higher Education? Getting Smarter and Making It Pay!
Where teaching and experience diverged
The limits on education were not an accident of circumstance but followed from doctrine. Berg's teaching that a basic education was enough, and the expectation that the end was near, made further study look unnecessary. Ward drew that connection directly: parents who had themselves been to college did not permit it to their children because of "their conviction that the essential training is for the End-time". He found no evidence of any child going on to further education, and noted that those who left had the ability but struggled to meet university entry requirements.
- Legal finding
an indication still of their conviction that the essential training is for the End-time and that the end is nigh.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
So far as tertiary education is concerned, I do not recall evidence of any child who has gone on to further education.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I was left in little doubt that they have the ability but struggle to catch up with the formal requirements for entry to University.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The group's public accounts of moving were more positive than the court's findings. Its 1993 statement said moving between Homes was "not usually an 'uprooting' experience at all". Ward found the opposite risk: separations were more likely in the group because of its missionary work and the forsake-all doctrine, and "long separations and/or frequent separations" harmed children's security.
- The group’s own account
Moving from one Family community to another is not usually an "uprooting" experience at all
ADVANTAGES OF OUR FAMILY EDUCATION - Legal finding
2. The heavy compulsion of the forsake all doctrine makes separations in fact even more likely to occur.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
3. Long separations and/or frequent separations are a threat to childrens' security and stability and therefore harmful.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Some harms went beyond what policy described. The teen training camps and "Victor" programmes of the late 1980s and early 1990s, set up to deal with disaffected teenagers, used isolation and "silence restriction". Ward found these were often carried to excess and damaged children, and that curiosity was discouraged as a sign of doubt. These practices are covered more fully in the article on protecting children.
- Legal finding
1. The use of isolation and silence restriction was frequently carried to excess and children were damaged by their experience of it.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
enquiries are frowned upon on the basis that curiosity is the product of a doubting mind and doubt allows the Devil to take it over.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Experiences varied by decade, country and Home. The same man who described strict schools and punishment also remembered an early childhood Home in Bangkok as a happy one, and the inspectors who visited English Homes in 1993 and 1994 found children who were open, well taught and keen to learn. The firsthand accounts in the archive come mostly from people who left, and the court heard mainly about English Homes in the early 1990s, so neither should be taken as the whole picture.
- Firsthand account
I remember the Combo vividly, and my memories of it were happy ones, I was a happy and content child.
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Legal finding
Most of the children seen were open, they relate well to each other and to the adults who teach them and are only too happy to talk about themselves and their work.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
How the organisation responded
The leadership recognised problems from the mid-1980s. At the time of the 1988 "School Vision" Berg admitted that most parents did not feel qualified to teach their children. In January 1994 Maria convened educational representatives, who recommended helping children take national secondary examinations and making more use of local educational opportunities.
- Legal finding
most of our parents don't feel very qualified to teach their children.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
facilitate participation in local national secondary education examinations
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The 1995 Love Charter gave children under 16 a right to an adequate education, and every child the right to live with at least one parent if they wished. In 1996 Maria told members that home schooling was best "but it is by no means the only way", and that Homes unable to educate their children would have to find another way or lose their status. In 1995 she also apologised to young people who had suffered prolonged silence restriction or isolation.
- Later response by the group
Children under the age of 16 have the right to sufficient time, opportunity and educational materials to receive an adequate education
ML 3066, OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION - Later response by the group
Every Family child has the right to live with their parents, or at least one parent if their parents are not living together, if they wish to
ML 2862, Forsaking Your Children for the Lord and His Work! - Later response by the group
we have found that home schooling is the best method of teaching our children, but it is by no means the only way to do it.
ML 3066, OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION - Later response by the group
It was wrong, and we are truly sorry that any of you received any such treatment.
ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US
Higher education remained hard to combine with full membership. Peter Amsterdam told the court that extended post-secondary study would probably mean temporarily leaving full-time (DO) status, and a 2001 leadership checklist still said that for a full-time disciple "there isn't room for pursuing higher education".
- Legal finding
It is likely that the pursuit of extended post-secondary educational qualifications will entail temporarily stepping out of D.O. status.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Leadership instruction
then there isn't room for pursuing higher education, just like there wasn't in the earlier years of the Family.
GN 965, Personal Checklist -- GN965
The decisive change came with the 2010 reorganisation known as the Reboot. Sociologists Eileen Barker and Sarah Harvey write that communal living was no longer required and that children were to receive a formal education rather than home schooling. TFI's own history page describes the end of its communal model.
- Scholarly research
members could seek secular employment; and children were to have a formal education rather than home schooling.
Children of God / The Family International ↗ - The group’s own account History ↗
Sources and the limits of the evidence
The main sources are Berg's Letters on children and education, the Family's public statements of 1992 and 1993 ("Socialisation", "Advantages of Our Family Education", "The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children"), Maria's 1996 letter on education, and Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment, which includes two reports by local education inspectors. The public statements were written to answer official investigations and present the group's best case; the judgment examined one country's Homes in detail.
- The group’s own account
ISSUED BY WORLD SERVICES ON THE COLLECTIVE BEHALF OF THE FELLOWSHIP OF INDEPENDENT MISSIONARY COMMUNITIES COMMONLY REFERRED TO AS THE FAMILY
SOCIALISATION - Legal finding
As part of that investigation officers of the Local Education Authority visited The Family for one school day.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Firsthand accounts come from people raised in the group who wrote after leaving, mostly between 1998 and 2003, and from press interviews. They describe particular Homes and years. The archive holds few accounts from second-generation members who stayed, and no systematic data on how many young people later gained qualifications or how many spoke several languages.
- Firsthand account
My experience as an ex-Family member trying to make college work.
Want Higher Education? Getting Smarter and Making It Pay!
From teaching to reform
How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.
Berg teaches that children will be raised as revolutionaries without System education, that a basic education is enough, and that children should learn by witnessing and provisioning.
- Legal finding
Your children will be totally revolutionary, never knowing what churchianity and system jobs and education are like!
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Official teaching
OUR CHILDREN NEED ONLY WHAT IS KNOWN AS A BASIC EDUCATION
ML 371, The Education Revolution! – (From a Discussion on Child Education
- Legal finding
Children move with their parents or are gathered into school Homes, are home schooled on a uniform curriculum, and take part in singing, witnessing and fundraising; teens have limited weekly study and help with child care and work.
- Legal finding
many, many young children were separated from their parents, and were moved from one foreign field to another.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - The group’s own account
they often participate in witnessing through performances such as singing, dancing, and even puppet shows
ADVANTAGES OF OUR FAMILY EDUCATION
- Legal finding
Young children are well taught, but teenagers are socially isolated, have a narrow secondary education and leave without the qualifications needed for further study or work.
- Legal finding
4. The children were socially isolated.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
All I had was a GED
Want Higher Education? Getting Smarter and Making It Pay!
- Legal finding
The leadership encourages external examinations (1994), the Charter gives children a right to an adequate education (1995), outside schooling is allowed (1996), and after the 2010 Reboot children are to receive formal education.
- Later response by the group
Children under the age of 16 have the right to sufficient time, opportunity and educational materials to receive an adequate education
ML 3066, OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION - Scholarly research
children were to have a formal education rather than home schooling.
Children of God / The Family International ↗
- Later response by the group
How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.