Beliefs and practices

"The System": How the Children of God Separated from Society

What did the Children of God mean by "the System", and how did they separate from society?

"The System" was David Berg's name for mainstream society, including its churches, schools, jobs, governments and media, which he taught his followers to drop out of and replace with a communal missionary life. In practice this meant rejecting church membership and ordinary careers, schooling children at home, limiting outside reading and media, and allowing secrecy or misleading answers to outsiders for security. From 1979 the rules loosened in stages, and the 2010 Reboot ended the communal model altogether.

Overview: what was "the System"?

In the group's vocabulary, "the System" meant the whole of ordinary society: established churches (which Berg called "Churchianity"), schools and universities, paid employment, governments and the news and entertainment media. Outsiders were "Systemites", and by 1990 also "Flatlanders". From the movement's first months in 1968, Berg presented his group as a revolution against this System and a sample of what he called real Christianity.

  • Official teaching I'M HERE TO START A REVOLUTION! I'm here to turn that System upside down and do what Jesus did, and show you what real Christianity is ML 1336, Our Declaration of Revolution! (September 1968)
  • Official teaching the Family members had to flee with their children before the infuriated relative sicced the "Child Protection Agency" on them! ML 2572, Don't Fear the System! (1/90) · 1990 Letter using the term "Flatlander" for an outside relative

Separation was never total. The group's purpose was to evangelise, so members went out among outsiders every day to witness, distribute literature and ask for donations. What they withdrew from was the System's institutions and way of life. This article looks at what the publications taught, how members applied it, what courts and critics found, and how the group's attitude changed over time. Experiences varied by decade, country and Home.

Historical origins: where did the idea come from?

The idea grew out of the late-1960s counterculture that Berg's first converts came from. In 1970 he wrote that the group's real witness was not preaching sermons but dropping out of the System and building a new communal society, which he described as a new nation with its own economy and politics.

  • Official teaching THE IMPORTANCE OF OUR WITNESSING BY DROPPING OUT OF THE SYSTEM AND BUILDING A NEW GODLY COMMUNAL SOCIETY RATHER THAN SCATTERING TO PREACH SERMONS ML 0J, Not a Sermon, But a Sample (July 3, 1970)
  • Official teaching WE'RE A TOTALLY NEW SOCIETY, A TOTALLY NEW CULTURE, AN ALTOGETHER NEW NATION, A BRAND NEW PEOPLE. WE EVEN HAVE A NEW ECONOMY, EVEN A NEW POLITICS ML 0J, Not a Sermon, But a Sample (July 3, 1970)

Dropping out was what set the group apart from the wider Jesus People movement. In 1971 Berg criticised other young converts because they kept their ordinary jobs and stayed in their churches. In 1973 he hoped that children born in the group would grow up never knowing church, ordinary jobs or outside education, a passage Lord Justice Ward later quoted in his 1995 judgment.

  • Official teaching They haven't dropped out of the System! They're still working at System jobs, they haven't left their System churches ML 148, Jesus People?--Or Revolution (June, 1971)
  • Legal finding Your children will be totally revolutionary, never knowing what churchianity and system jobs and education are like! Judgement of Lord Justice Ward · Ward quoting Berg's Letter "New Bottles" (June 1973)

Official doctrine: what did the documents say?

The Statement of Faith (dated April 1992 in later Family citations) set out the doctrine in moderate terms. It quoted the Bible's call to "come out from among them", but said separation should follow the Bible and the Holy Spirit rather than the "legalistic mores" of men, and that members were "not of the world" but still in it to reach others.

  • we do not feel that this separation of the believer should be dictated by the sanctimonious or legalistic mores and morals of Man OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH
  • Although we are "not of the world" (John 17:16), we are nevertheless in the world OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH

On government, Berg taught in 1977 that laws made to stop witnessing were the devil's laws and need not be obeyed. The Statement of Faith accepted civil authority as ordained by God and asked members to obey the law, with an exception for matters of faith such as preaching. A 1993 leadership statement put the same test plainly: laws were to be obeyed when they did not hinder witnessing, giving the laws on sex with minors as an example of laws it was "wise" to obey.

The Statement of Faith also taught that committed Christians should expect persecution and that God used it for good. This expectation shaped how the group interpreted criticism, court cases and police raids.

  • We believe that Christians who actively witness and live for Jesus Christ will receive persecution. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH

Distinctive features: how did it differ from mainstream Christianity?

Many Christian groups teach some separation from "the world". What was distinctive here was that the church itself was counted as part of the System. Berg attacked church buildings and Sunday services as "Churchianity" from 1968, and in 1992 Maria still presented dropping out of the System as the only way churches could truly care for converts. A 2001 message, presented as Berg speaking from the spirit world, told members they were still "called out from the church system".

Theological analysis: the call not to be "conformed to this world" (Romans 12:2) is shared across Christian traditions, and the group's Statement of Faith quotes it. Most traditions, however, read separation as moral and spiritual rather than as withdrawal from work, citizenship and the local church. Jesus' prayer that his followers be kept from evil without being taken out of the world, and the second-century description of Christians who "share in all things with others" while living as sojourners, express that mainstream view. Many churches also see regular gathering as a Christian duty (Hebrews 10:25), where Berg rejected church attendance. On the other hand, the Statement of Faith's teaching on obeying the state except where it forbids preaching is close to historic Protestant teaching.

  • Theological analysis And be not conformed to this world: but be ye transformed by the renewing of your mind, that ye may prove what is that good, and acceptable, and perfect, will of God. Romans 12:2 (King James Version) ↗
  • Theological analysis I pray not that thou shouldest take them out of the world, but that thou shouldest keep them from the evil. John 17:15 (King James Version) ↗
  • Theological analysis They dwell in their own countries, but simply as sojourners. As citizens, they share in all things with others, and yet endure all things as if foreigners. Epistle to Diognetus, chapter 5 (2nd century) ↗
  • Theological analysis Not forsaking the assembling of ourselves together, as the manner of some is; but exhorting one another: and so much the more, as ye see the day approaching. Hebrews 10:25 (King James Version) ↗
  • Theological analysis Therefore, Christians are necessarily bound to obey their own magistrates and laws save only when commanded to sin; for then they ought to obey God rather than men. Augsburg Confession (1530), Article XVI ↗

A second distinctive feature was the treatment of honesty with outsiders. Berg's 1979 Letter "Deceivers, Yet True!", named after a phrase in 2 Corinthians 6:8, said deceit could be justified to protect God's work, and in extreme cases lying to save a life. Most Christian traditions, following passages such as Ephesians 4:25, treat lying as wrong; Augustine held that every lie is a sin.

Practical application: work, schooling, media and secrecy

Work. Full-time members did not take ordinary jobs. They lived from donated goods ("provisioning"), gifts and literature distribution. Berg allowed exceptions as early as 1970, but a "System job" was generally a sign of weak commitment. A 1997 prophecy still linked taking a System job with losing the vision to witness and leaving.

  • Official teaching THERE'S A TIME AND A PLACE FOR EVERYTHING--even holding a System job when you have nothing better to do--or if God wants to use it to help the Children of God! ML 27, Use It (December 15, 1970)
  • Leadership instruction They've lost their reason for living for Me, and they're then much more likely to take a System job, get into worldliness, or backslide. ML 3132, Why Witness? (5/97)

Schooling. Children were taught at home or in Family schools rather than in "System" schools. In 1975 Berg wrote that even a senior high school education was unnecessary for the group's children. In 1992 a public statement on "socialisation" said the group did not willingly expose its children to worldly influences, while insisting that they met many outsiders through witnessing. Schooling is covered fully in the article on children, family and education.

Reading and media. In "You Are What You Read!" and "Book Burning" (both August 1978) Berg told members that anything not written by a man of God was the devil's word, and that they should read nothing but the Bible, his Letters and assigned practical books. Lord Justice Ward found in 1995 that these early rules were not rigorously enforced or observed by young people, but that the children were still "not wholly free" in what they could study. Later material kept the theme: a 1995 prophecy compared the System to a well of poisonous water.

Names and security. New members took Bible names, which Berg discussed as early as 1970. Some colonies were kept secret ("Selah") from 1971, and from the late 1970s Berg issued security rules. In 1984 he defended using different names for the group and its work so that outsiders would not link them to its bad publicity, comparing this to early Christians changing their names for security. Maria added that the aim was to "get our foot in the door".

  • Official teaching GREATER PRAYER NEEDS TO BE TAKEN IN THE SELECTION OF BIBLE NAMES FOR NEW DISCIPLES! ML 24, General Epistle to Leaders (December 13, 1970)
  • Reported practice possibly because some of them were supposed to be Selah. These could have been reported without naming them ML 129, Details (November 16, 1971)
  • Official teaching a lot of it was for security, just like we do, so they wouldn't be known & recognised by the same names ML 1858, A Rose by Another Name (10/84)
  • Official teaching (Maria: We're just using a few different tactics & different names initially to get our foot in the door to be able to be accepted until we can give them the real Message!) ML 1858, A Rose by Another Name (10/84)

Historical development: how did attitudes change?

The first change came as members had families. In 1979, in "The Maturation of a Movement", Berg accepted that parents might need a System job and witness in their spare time. In 1983 he told members that honesty was the best policy, while repeating that they need not tell the whole truth for security reasons.

From the late 1980s many families returned to their home countries, and the leadership began teaching them how to deal with outside society rather than avoid it. A 1989 letter by Maria asked parents to explain to their children how the System worked, while still teaching that the group's way was better. A Letter by Berg from about 1992 (numbered DO 2826) complained that members took security warnings "too far".

The 1995 Love Charter gave Homes more say over their own affairs. World Services confirmed that a Home could choose to have members take well-paid secular jobs. In 1997 a second tier of membership was renamed "Fellow Members": people who did not keep all the Charter's rules but remained in the Family. A 1998 commentary invited Charter Members who wanted outside music and films to move to Fellow Member status instead. At the start of 1998 the Family reported 3,222 Fellow Members out of 13,943.

The largest change came in 2010. TFI's own history says that after a two-year review it ended its communal model in a reorganisation called the Reboot. Sociologists Eileen Barker and Sarah Harvey write that communal living was then no longer required, that members could take secular jobs, and that children were to receive formal education rather than home schooling. TFI now describes itself as an online Christian network.

  • TFI: Our History ↗ · States that in 2010, after a two-year review, TFI undertook the Reboot, ended its communal model and streamlined its charter.
  • Scholarly research members could seek secular employment; and children were to have a formal education rather than home schooling. Children of God / The Family International (CDAMM) ↗
  • TFI: About ↗ · Describes TFI as an online Christian network.

Controversies and consequences

Deception. The "deceivers yet true" teaching became one of the main criticisms of the group, which a 1994 publication acknowledged. In the 1995 English custody case, Lord Justice Ward found that the group allowed exceptions to truth-telling when it feared serious harm to itself, and that its written guidance went wider than the leadership admitted. He recorded Maria's instruction that members must be honest in court, but found that in many instances witnesses had not told the whole truth.

  • Leadership instruction Our enemies sure make a big deal about our little doctrine of "deceivers yet true"! ML 2935, Persecution Jewels!--No.15 (4/94)
  • Legal finding they permit an exception to telling the truth when doing so will result in tragic consequences to The Family. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Legal finding The Court is a place where they must be honest no matter how embarrassing or threatening to The Family they feel their answers are going to be Judgement of Lord Justice Ward · Maria's instruction as quoted to the court by Peter Amsterdam
  • Legal finding I regret to find that in many instances there has been a lack of frankness and a failure to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Persecution. Police and welfare raids on Family Homes in Argentina, Spain, Australia and France between 1989 and 1993 reinforced the group's view of the System as hostile. The Family's own 1992 account of the Australian raids says no charge was brought and the children were returned, and a 1993 press report says that arrests in several countries did not lead to successful prosecutions. Lord Justice Ward noted that the group counted the actions of courts, including his own, as persecution.

  • After holding our children for six days of intensive questioning, examination and evaluation, the Community Services were still unable to bring even one legal charge against us RELIGIOUS PERSECUTION (June, 1992)
  • Journalism though those cases were never successfully prosecuted. Houston Chronicle, Oct 10, 1993 (October 10, 1993) · Houston Chronicle, 1993
  • Legal finding Quite the most frightening persecution has been the action taken by the authorities in Argentina, Australia, Spain, France, and by me. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Isolation. Ward found that earlier literature "painted horrific pictures" of the System and of people who left, and among his findings on young people he listed that the children were socially isolated. He also found that the fear of being expelled "to the system" put pressure on children. Former members describe leaving with no work history or qualifications. The Family's leadership, for its part, argued in 1994 that it could not stop being "radical and controversial" to please outside advisers.

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The main primary sources are Berg's Letters "Not a Sermon, But a Sample" (1970), "You Are What You Read!" and "Book Burning" (1978), "Deceivers, Yet True!" (1979), "The Maturation of a Movement" (1979) and "A Rose By Another Name!" (1984); the Statement of Faith; the 1992 public statements on socialisation and persecution; the 1995 Charter and the 1998 commentary on it. The main outside source is Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment, which heard evidence from more than 30 members.

  • Legal finding One cannot have listened, as I have listened to over 30 members of The Family without being impressed by and in many ways filled with admiration for their total dedication to their discipleship Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Several limits apply. Publications show what members were told, not how strictly each Home kept the rules; Ward's finding that the reading rules were not rigorously observed is a reminder of that gap. Public position papers from 1992 and 1993 were written during court cases and present the group in the best light. The archive does not document how the Fellow Member category worked in daily life outside a few statistics, and post-2010 practice is known mainly from TFI's own websites and a small number of scholarly summaries.

  • Legal finding I am satisfied that the strident strictures in the early "You are what you read" and "Book Burning" letters are not rigorously enforced and nor rigorously observed by the young. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1968–1978

    Berg teaches converts to drop out of the System, its churches, jobs and schools, and to form a new communal society; outside reading is restricted to the Bible and his Letters.

  2. Practice · 1970s–1990s

    Members live without ordinary jobs, school their children at home, use Bible names and secret Homes, and are allowed to mislead outsiders for security.

    • Reported practice possibly because some of them were supposed to be Selah. ML 129, Details (November 16, 1971)
    • Official teaching a lot of it was for security, just like we do, so they wouldn't be known & recognised by the same names ML 1858, A Rose by Another Name (10/84)
  3. Consequence · 1989–1995

    Raids and court cases are read as persecution; a 1995 English court finds that children were socially isolated and that witnesses were not fully frank.

  4. Reform or response · 1995–2010

    The Charter lets Homes choose secular jobs; Fellow Member status is created in 1997; the 2010 Reboot ends the communal model and allows formal schooling.

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.