Teachings vs. Experiences

Leaving the Children of God: Backsliders, Excommunication and Life After

What happened to people who left the Children of God?

People who left the Children of God were free to go in principle, but Berg's Letters called them "backsliders", warned of God's judgment and often described them as traitors, and members could also be expelled through excommunication. Many who left, especially those born in the group, faced the loss of their whole community, strained family ties, and practical obstacles such as having no school qualifications, work history or money. From the 1990s the group softened its stance, apologised to former members and by 2010 dissolved its communal Homes, while former members built their own support networks such as MovingOn.org.

What the group taught

Berg's teaching on leaving pulled in two directions. In 1977 he wrote that every member knew they were free to leave at any time. In early pastoral Letters he urged leaders to remember the prodigal son, and he said he had coined the word "graduate" for those who left after basic training, rather than calling them backsliders.

Much more often, though, the Letters described those who left as a danger. Berg wrote in 1974 that God was angry with backsliders because they set a bad example and drew others with them, and in 1975 that those who rejected the truth usually became "Judases" and traitors. A 1976 Letter pictured some backsliders turning into "bitter enemies".

Some Letters linked leaving with God's judgment. Lord Justice Ward, in the 1995 English custody judgment, cited the Letter "IRFers Beware", which told the story of a former member who came to harm after she lapsed, as an example of what members were told befell those who stopped being members. He also cited a 1983 Letter in which Berg called backsliders "God's vomit", and found that its threatening tone had added to a teenager's fear of leaving.

Excommunication was the formal way of removing someone. A 1982 compilation quoted Berg that Letters would be withheld from those who refused to cooperate, and listed failure to tithe among the grounds. Under the 1995 Charter, continental officers decided between partial and full excommunication, and a 1998 Letter insisted that anyone committing an excommunicable offence must be excommunicated.

  • Leadership instruction I CANNOT FORCE YOU TO OBEY, BUT I HOLD A FEW TRUMP CARDS--& THOSE ARE THE LORD'S LETTERS, which we shall withhold from those who refuse to cooperate ML 1323, Excommunication Rules & Procedures! (November 1982)
  • Leadership instruction Everyone needs to realize that if someone commits an excommunicable offense, the Charter demands they be excommunicated. ML 3197, Charter Responsibilities (7/98)

What members were expected to do

Members were expected to stay, and to treat leaving as spiritual failure. A former member writing in 2003 recalled that people were made to feel they were "weaker sisters" or "old bottles" who would be judged for leaving "His best". Group publications in the 1990s described former members who spoke to the press as "backsliders" stabbing the group in the back, and told members that their accounts contradicted those of people still inside.

  • Firsthand account We were led to believe that we were either “weaker sisters” or “old bottles” or that God will judge us for leaving “His best”. Amazing Thoughts Since I Left the Family · former member, 2003
  • Official teaching Just think, after all we did for them, these backsliders are stabbing us in the back! ML 2855, Persecution Jewels!--No.2! (1/93)
  • Official teaching Our backsliders usually relate lurid accounts of life in the Family that directly contradict the accounts of those who are still within the Family ML 2912, PERSECUTION JEWELS (2/94)

Contact with critical former members was discouraged. The same former member asked why reading ex-member websites was "taboo", and wrote that hearing "the other side" was what had freed them. A 1993 public statement by the group argued that former members who became hostile had usually been influenced by deprogrammers or anti-cult groups, while noting that most people who leave new religions do so as easily as they joined.

For young people the expectations shifted in the 1990s. In 1992 Maria told parents not to treat a teenager's decision to leave as the end of the world or to try to force them to stay. In 1997 she wrote of her distress at young people leaving and gave Homes advice on keeping them. In 1999 every Charter member aged 18 or over had to sign a contract or move to a less committed Home, or leave.

What members experienced

Former members describe fear as a barrier to leaving. A man who left in 1979 wrote that many stayed because they feared God would strike them dead if they left. A woman who left in 1986 wrote that fear of an unknown future in the world was the main thing that had kept her in for so many years. Lord Justice Ward found that a teenager in the case had told an Australian court he was happy because he could not face telling his shepherd he wanted to leave.

  • Firsthand account Many are afraid that God may strike them dead if they leave the group, or judge them severely in some other way. I Almost Didn't Make It (March 1998) · former member, 1998
  • Firsthand account I knew that fear of an unknown future out in the world by myself was the major thing that kept me in The Family for so many years. There is Life After the Family (May 2002) · former member, 2002
  • Legal finding He lied because he could not stand up to the shepherd and tell them that in fact he wished to leave The Family. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward

Leaving meant losing a whole world. A former member who left after 28 years wrote of feeling uncertain, discouraged and lost after leaving. The man who left over the Kohoutek prophecy wrote that after six months outside he felt so lonely and lost that he went back. A text on the emotional pain of leaving, posted in 2001 by an Australian cult-awareness centre and circulated among ex-members, compared it to bereavement.

  • Firsthand account when we left the Family, we felt uncertain, discouraged, lost and felt like Jesus didn't love us so much anymore. Amazing Thoughts Since I Left the Family
  • Firsthand account I felt so lonely and lost that I had returned back to the COG I Almost Didn't Make It (March 1998)
  • Firsthand account Leaving a cult is like experiencing the death of a close relative or a broken relationship. The Emotional Pain of Leaving a Cult (November 13, 2001) · general text by a cult-awareness centre, not specific to this group

Practical problems were severe, especially for those who had joined young or were born in the group. A first-generation member writing in 2003 described arriving in the job market in their forties with "no tax returns filed, no employment history". A woman who left in 1986 counted herself fortunate that her family had saved money for her, and asked what would happen to young people who did not know their parents or which country was home.

Family relationships could be split. Lord Justice Ward described the acute tension that arose when someone left close relatives behind in the group, including a father who rang his daughter to berate her for her evidence. The woman who left in 1986 wrote that her son, who left with his father, still held his father's beliefs and struggled at college.

  • Legal finding Another form of tension, perhaps more acute, arises when a person defects from The Family leaving close relatives in the group. Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
  • Firsthand account my son on the phone seems very other worldly as he tries to make it in college while still holding onto his father's beliefs There is Life After the Family (May 2002)

Many describe a life rebuilt. The 2003 writer listed former members who had become nurses, teachers, academics, scientists, lawyers and musicians. The woman who left in 1986 learned project management at an engineering firm and later worked as an assistant to company presidents. Not all former members are hostile: Lord Justice Ward accepted expert evidence that most "look back more in sorrow than in anger".

Where teaching and experience diverged

The formal position that members were free to leave was true in the sense that no one was legally held. But the Letters' warnings of judgment, the language of traitors and Judases, and the absence of education or savings made leaving costly. These harms were not imposed by a rule against leaving. They followed from doctrines of separation from "the System" and forsaking all, which left many members, and especially their children, without the means to live outside.

The leadership itself admitted mistakes in how people were removed. In 1987 Maria wrote that some people had been excommunicated who should not have been, and that such cases should be put right. In 1992 she noted that Berg had, in her view, let individuals leave without threats even when his talks came down hard on backsliders, which acknowledges the gap between his rhetoric and some of his personal dealings.

Theological analysis: most Christian churches practise some form of church discipline, and Jesus' instruction in Matthew 18 has long been read as allowing a persistently unrepentant member to be treated as an outsider. Churches also stress restoration, as in Paul's call to restore those at fault "in the spirit of meekness", an emphasis Berg himself drew on when he pointed to the prodigal son. Where the group departed from most traditions was in treating leaving the group itself, rather than leaving the Christian faith, as backsliding from God.

  • Theological analysis And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican. Matthew 18:17 (King James Version) ↗
  • Theological analysis Brethren, if a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted. Galatians 6:1 (King James Version) ↗

How the organisation responded

In September 1995, as the English case ended, Maria apologised to former members who had been treated unlovingly or harshly "either before or after" they left. She also agreed with the judge that a child in the group should receive enough education to live outside it, and keep loving contact with his mother, if he chose to leave.

Practical help followed slowly. In 2000 Maria wrote that the group was looking for better ways to help young people who left adjust to new careers and studies, and had published guidance for parents and an open letter to those who had left. In 2003 a Charter amendment made it compulsory for young people to receive an education leading to a high school diploma, partly to prepare those who might leave.

  • Later response by the group We continue to find better ways of helping our young people who choose to leave the Family adjust to their new careers, studies, living conditions, etc. ML 3307, None of These Things Move Me (7/00)
  • Later response by the group it will also better prepare those who might eventually choose to leave the Family for their lives outside of the Family. GV 157, Grape Vine #157 (June 15, 2003)

Former members also built their own networks. MovingOn.org was set up in 2001 by a former second-generation member, and press reports in 2005 mention a website run by people who had left. A former member writing in 2003 urged those still inside to read the testimonies posted there.

The deaths in January 2005 involving Ricky Rodriguez, Maria's son, who had been raised as the group's heir apparent, became a public moment for these tensions. He killed a long-time member and then himself. Friends and former members said he had been abused as a child in the group and that other former members had been a support group for him. The group's spokeswoman said it had given him financial and emotional support after he left in 2000, and that it was not responsible for his death.

  • Journalism In January 2005, Ricky Rodriguez, the one-time heir apparent to The Family, fatally stabbed his former nanny and then shot himself dead. Revenge Against Religious Sect ↗ · the group disputed that the woman had been his nanny
  • Journalism But friends said the former members had served as a support group for Rodriguez to move on from his past. Sect rebuts claims in murder (Published: 01.13.2005)
  • Disputed allegation The Family gave him "ample financial and emotional support" to help him with the difficult transition from the group to independence Sect rebuts claims in murder (Published: 01.13.2005) · the group's account, reported in the press; contested by his friends and former members
  • Journalism In 2005, The Family spokeswoman Claire Borowik told ABC News that while she was deeply saddened by the murder/suicide, the group was not responsible for Rodriguez's death. Revenge Against Religious Sect ↗

Structural change made leaving less stark. The 1995 Charter's "Right of Mobility" let members change Homes on their own decision. In 2010 TFI ended its communal model in the Reboot; scholars report that members could then take secular jobs. Claire Borowik, a TFI spokeswoman, writes that a 2012 programme gave senior members a one-time retirement gift for the move out of communal support. In 2009 the group acknowledged that "mistakes were made", and in 2018 it apologised to anyone hurt during their time as members.

Sources and the limits of the evidence

Most firsthand accounts of leaving in the archive were written for ex-member websites between 1998 and 2003, and come from people who left and chose to write about it. Those who left quietly, or who later returned, are less represented. Published memoirs by former members, such as Perry Bulwer's "Misguided" (2023) and Faith Jones's "Sex Cult Nun" (2021), are known here only through publishers' notices and reviews.

The group's statistics on departures are not available in the archive, and the 1993 statement's claims about former members rely on scholarship it selected. Lord Justice Ward dated "IRFers Beware" to February 1988, but the group's own chronology places a Letter of that title in early 1980, so the date should be treated with caution.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1974–1983

    Berg says members are free to leave but calls those who leave backsliders, Judases and enemies, and warns of God's judgment.

  2. Practice · 1982–1998

    Excommunication is used against those who break rules, and members are discouraged from listening to former members.

  3. Consequence · 1980s–2000s

    People who leave, especially those raised in the group, face fear, loss of community, family splits and no papers, work history or money.

  4. Reform or response · 1995–2018

    Maria apologises to former members; education is required from 2003; communal Homes end in 2010; TFI apologises in 2018. Former members build their own networks such as MovingOn.org.

    • Later response by the group either before or after you left the Family, we are sorry. ML 3016, "AN ANSWER TO HIM THAT ASKETH US (9/95)
    • Later response by the group we wish to express our sincere apologies to anyone who experienced anything negative or hurtful during their childhood or time as members of the Family International. Belief Letters ↗ (2018)

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.