Teachings vs. Experiences
Love and Family in the Children of God: Teaching vs. Experience
How did the Children of God treat families and children?
The Children of God taught that its members were one large loving Family and that this Family came before "selfish" private families, so parents were expected to put the group's work ahead of their own children and, from the mid-1970s, to share spouses. Many children were separated from their parents for long periods, a pattern the 1995 English High Court judgment found harmful. The 1995 Love Charter gave every child the right to live with at least one parent, and in 1995 and 1996 leaders apologised for harsh and unloving treatment in the past.
What the group taught
The movement's ideal was love: members were to live as one Christian community, sharing everything like the early church, and to treat every member as a brother or sister. In "One Wife" (October 1972) David Berg turned this ideal against the private household. God, he wrote, was "in the business of breaking up little selfish private worldly families" to make one larger Family, the Bride of Christ.
- Official teaching
We believe that the New Testament's account of the pristine lifestyle of the Early Church offers us not only an historical narrative, but an exemplary pattern and model which God intended succeeding generations of believers to follow.
OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH - Official teaching
BUT GOD'S IN THE BUSINESS OF BREAKING UP LITTLE SELFISH PRIVATE WORLDLY FAMILIES TO MAKE OF THEIR YIELDED BROKEN PIECES A LARGER UNIT--ONE FAMILY!
ML 249, One Wife - Official teaching
We are adopting the larger Family as The Family unit: The Family of God and His Bride and Children!
ML 249, One Wife
The same Letter applied this to children. Loving one's own children more than others was called selfish partiality, and parents were told that the children in the nursery were "all 'our' children". Berg repeated the point in 1973 and 1975: the larger Family came first, before "the tiny private selfish family unit of two and their own children".
- Official teaching
DON'T FORGET THIS MEANS YOUR CHILDREN, ALSO!
ML 249, One Wife - Official teaching
They're all "our" children!
ML 249, One Wife - Official teaching
They're our children! Not your children or my children--they are our children, God's children!
ML 292, Women In Love - Official teaching
THE LARGER FAMILY UNITY COMES FIRST and is far more important than the tiny private selfish family unit of two and their own children.
ML 359, Divorce! – The Marriage Revolution!
The teaching was not one-sided. In November 1975 Berg also told mothers that caring for their own children was itself service to God, and in 1988 he insisted that he had "always advocated mates, marriages, fathers, mothers & children". The group's public Statement of Faith presents discipleship as putting God's will first "even when compliance with Scriptural injunction may conflict with the desires and designs of family", citing Luke 14:26.
- Official teaching
you need to take care of your own kids as a service to God
ML 389, Real Mothers! – From a Real Family Discussion! - Official teaching
I have always advocated mates, marriages, fathers, mothers & children! Just read my Letters!--Not promiscuity!
ML 2433, Make It Work!--Marriage Is God's Answer to Teenage Sex Problems! - Official teaching
Making God's revealed will absolutely paramount in one's life, even when compliance with Scriptural injunction may conflict with the desires and designs of family, friends and loved ones.
OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH
"One Wife" also opened the door to sexual sharing between married members. In 1976 Berg wrote that marriage made "NO difference" to sharing with others, and by 1980 he described the ideal as all members "sexually sharing mates". (The wider sexual teaching is covered in the Law of Love article.)
- Official teaching
Marriage makes NO difference whatsoever when it comes to sharing each other with the Lord & His work & others.
ML 1395, Real Love! – Sharing All! – Even Tho’ Married! - Official teaching
all of us mated together & all of us sharing in every way, including sexually sharing mates & lovers & brothers & sisters & everything.
ML 928, Tithing & the FN! – Or Weaning the Baby! – 100%ers, 10%ers, 110%ers?
What members were expected to do
Members were expected to "forsake all" for the work, and this could include leaving children in the care of others. In a 1983 Letter written "for those who've forsaken children for the Lord", Berg called giving up one's children "the supreme sacrifice" and said he had done so himself.
- Official teaching
I think that's the supreme sacrifice--to give up your children.
ML 1367, No More Tears! – For Those Who’ve Forsaken Children for the Lord & Others! - Official teaching
Now I'm too busy to spend time with my own children, spending it with other people's children. I have to give up my own.
ML 1367, No More Tears! – For Those Who’ve Forsaken Children for the Lord & Others!
The expectation lasted into the 1990s. In March 1993 Maria answered a shepherdess who was kept apart from her children by her work: this, she wrote, was part of "forsaking mothers & fathers and children" for the work, and the children's own forsaking of their parents was a "very high privilege".
- Leadership instruction
forsaking mothers & fathers and children so we can put His Work first--& our children having to forsake their mothers & fathers for the very high privilege of being a member of this Family
ML 2862, Forsaking Your Children for the Lord and His Work!
Choosing family over an assignment could bring public rebuke. The 1995 judgment describes a 1983 Letter, "God's Vomit", aimed at a young man who turned down a World Services job to return to his wife and children. Berg called this "a ridiculous decision". The judge, who saw the Letter in evidence, called it "very heavy pressure indeed".
- Legal finding
A ridiculous decision ... to choose his family over the Lord and God's work
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I find that to be very heavy pressure indeed.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Within communal Homes, discipline and childcare were shared. A collection of Berg's childcare advice quoted in the judgment said that "anyone can discipline any of the children and not just the particular mother or father". Sexual sharing between adults was presented as unselfish love; a World Services history quoted in court described married couples who "broke out of their own private personal marriage relationships".
- Legal finding
so that anyone can discipline any of the children and not just the particular mother or father of the offending child!
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - The group’s own account
Married couples who ventured to occasionally swap partners with other married couples broke out of their own private personal marriage relationships
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
What members experienced
Experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Some Homes were small family-sized units (the group's own statistics put the average Home at 4.4 people in 1982), while others were large schools and combined Homes; before the 1995 Charter the average Charter Home had 33 members. Separation from parents was far more common in the large institutions of the late 1980s and early 1990s than in small Homes.
- Reported practice
AND OUR AVERAGE SIZE TRF HOME, SAD TO SAY, HAS DWINDLED DOWN TO ONLY 4.4
ML 1083, The 7 F’s of FFing! – Dad’s New Year’s Day Keynote Address for the Year! - Reported practice
CM Home size has gone down dramatically, from 33 members per Home just prior to the Charter to its present 13.3.
ML 3159, Victory Review '97
Lord Justice Ward heard months of evidence in 1994 and 1995. He found it "uncontradicted" that many young children were separated from their parents and moved between countries, and quoted a leader of the period saying that the Lord was requiring forsaking "even of toddlers and babies". He also noted that this was written at the time of the "School Vision" (from 1988), and that things had since moved on.
- Legal finding
Another feature of the evidence was the uncontradicted fact that many, many young children were separated from their parents, and were moved from one foreign field to another.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Forsaking all is not exactly easy for our kids but the Lord is even requiring it now of many of our children, even toddlers and babies.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
I must not forget that that was written at the time of the "School Vision" and that things have moved away from that since then.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Firsthand accounts describe what this meant. A young man born in 1980 and raised in Thailand, writing in 2001, recalls being moved to a children's school at about eight and seeing his parents once a month. A woman who left in Bangkok in 1986 says she left partly because children were then "being dealt with harshly" and separated from their parents. A young woman separated from her mother as a child, writing in 1999-2000, was still trying to find her eleven years later.
- Firsthand account
This meant that I would be moving away from my parents for the first time, and we were to get to see our parents once a month
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Firsthand account
It was a time when The Family children were really being dealt with harshly for any kind of aberrance and separated from their parents
There is Life After the Family - Firsthand account
At present, I'm looking for my mother whom I haven't seen in 11 years when I was separated from her.
Merry's Story
The pressure could reach into the closest bonds. The judgment describes a young father placed on a "Victor" correction programme in 1991, whose two-year-old son was moved to a nearby school while he and his wife were separated. In a published confession he wrote that he had been "making a god out of" his son and now had to "forsake him".
- Legal finding
For this same reason their 2 year old son went to live at the school nearby, rather than living in the Victor house.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
So now I feel I have to forsake him and really prove to the Lord that I am willing to put God first
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Accounts are not uniformly negative. Many witnesses who remained in the group showed the court photographs of good relationships with their outside relatives, and the same Thai-raised writer remembers his early years in a combined Home as happy and some later carers as people who "did care about me". Spouse sharing among adults was, by 1995, found to be arranged voluntarily between couples in Britain rather than by schedule.
- Legal finding
witness after witness produced bundles of photographs to convince me of the good relationship maintained with their system families.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Firsthand account
I remember the Combo vividly, and my memories of it were happy ones, I was a happy and content child.
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Firsthand account
there were nevertheless people there who did care about me and who I trusted, so I'm not going to paint the picture blacker than it was.
My Life Growing Up in the Family - Legal finding
Sharing between adults over 21 does take place within the United Kingdom.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
It can be voluntarily arranged between the couple
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Sharing schedules are not the norm.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Where teaching and experience diverged
Here harm was not a misreading of doctrine. The teaching itself told members to place the Family above their own spouses and children, and leaders applied it directly, as Maria's 1993 letter shows. The separation of children from parents was therefore encouraged, not merely permitted, during much of the period from the 1970s to the early 1990s. The judge concluded that "Forsaking all was harmful" and that long or frequent separations threatened children's security.
- Legal finding
Forsaking all was harmful.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Long separations and/or frequent separations are a threat to childrens' security and stability and therefore harmful.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The group's public statements described something different. "The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children" (April 1992) claimed that its children received "superior care and parenting" and were no more separated from their parents than children of working parents elsewhere. It also said parents were required to spend time with their children daily. That last rule was real: it came from Maria's Discipleship Training Revolution of 1991. But the claim that separation was no greater than elsewhere is hard to square with the court's findings and with testimony from the same years.
- The group’s own account
We believe that the children in our communities receive superior care and parenting in all areas when compared to society at large
The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children - The group’s own account
Our children are not any more "separated from their parents" than any other children of working parents in society.
The Heritage and Home Life of Our Children - Legal finding
She achieved much good by the DTR because she insisted that there must be a "Family time" when parents spend at least an hour of each day with their children
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Spouse sharing shows a similar gap between ideal and effect. It was taught as unselfish love, and the group's own history says it brought "a degree of unity". Ward found that the One Wife message was "not widely received" at first and that sexual liberty was taken only by leaders until 1978, when it spread to all members. The leadership itself later linked the sexualised atmosphere that followed to harm to children.
- Legal finding
The message was not widely received.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
the liberty to engage in sexual relationships outside marriage was one taken only by the leaders
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Later response by the group
this significantly contributed to the development of an overly sexualized atmosphere in a number of Family communities, of which children were a part.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS
Theological analysis: the group was right that Jesus called disciples to put God before family (Matthew 19:29), and many Christian traditions honour those who leave home for mission or religious life. Mainstream teaching, however, reads such passages alongside duties to one's own household, such as 1 Timothy 5:8 and the command not to provoke children (Ephesians 6:4), and treats marriage as exclusive (Matthew 19:6). Berg's claim that God breaks up marriages and that loving one's own children more than others is selfish has no close parallel in historic churches, though Christian traditions differ on many questions of family and vocation.
- Theological analysis
And every one that hath forsaken houses, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for my name's sake, shall receive an hundredfold, and shall inherit everlasting life.
Matthew 19:29 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
But if any provide not for his own, and specially for those of his own house, he hath denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel.
1 Timothy 5:8 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
And, ye fathers, provoke not your children to wrath: but bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.
Ephesians 6:4 (King James Version) ↗ - Theological analysis
Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.
Matthew 19:6 (King James Version) ↗
How the organisation responded
The first change came through the Discipleship Training Revolution of February 1991, which required daily family time and a weekly family day. Ward described this as "a far cry from 'One Wife'". In the same years, however, the large schools and teen programmes that separated many children from their parents were still running.
- Legal finding
It is a far cry from "One Wife" and earlier attempts to undermine the cohesion of the nuclear Family in order to strengthen the communal tie.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The 1995 Love Charter, in force from 1 April 1995, gave every child the right to live with at least one parent if they wished, with an exception for children of couples who both served in World Services. In announcing the Charter in January 1995, Maria wrote that the Lord had seen members' "tears of desire to be closer to your children".
- Leadership instruction
Every Family child has the right to live with their parents, or at least one parent if their parents are not living together, if they wish to
ML 2862, Forsaking Your Children for the Lord and His Work! - Leadership instruction
He has seen your tears of desire to be closer to your children and have a stronger bond of love with them.
ML 2963, THE LOVE CHARTER
The court went further for the child in its care. Ward found that the risks were serious enough to justify removing the boy from his mother, but suspended that order so that the mother and the leadership could meet conditions. One condition was that she never live apart from him for more than two weeks at a time, and another was that he keep in contact with his grandmother.
- Legal finding
My judgment is that the risks of harm as matters presently stand are significant enough to dictate in his interests that he be removed from his mother.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
She must undertake never to live separate and apart from S for any period exceeding 2 weeks in duration
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
She must undertake unstintingly to allow S contact, including staying contact with his grandmother and with other relatives.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
Apologies followed in 1995 and 1996, addressed especially to former members. Maria wrote that the group could have been "more tolerant" and "more gentle". The 1998 policy statement on sex keeps legal monogamous marriage as the norm but still allows a married member sexual relations with another adult member if the spouse consents. In 2010 TFI ended its communal model altogether (see the community articles).
- Later response by the group
We could have been more tolerant, more accepting of other people's opinions.
ML 3091, AN OPEN LETTER TO ALL CURRENT AND FORMER FAMILY MEMBERS - Later response by the group
Legally contracted monogamous marriages are the norm for permanent relationships among our membership, and marriage is expected to be a lifelong commitment.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - Later response by the group
Our communities do not prohibit sexual relations between a married person and someone other than that person's spouse.
Attitudes, Conduct, Current Beliefs and Teachings Regarding Sex - The group’s own account History (The Family International website) ↗
Sources and the limits of the evidence
The main teaching sources are "One Wife" (1972), "Divorce! - The Marriage Revolution" (1975), "No More Tears" (1983) and Maria's "Forsaking Your Children for the Lord and His Work" (1993). The main legal source is Lord Justice Ward's 1995 judgment, which dealt with one custody case in England but reviewed evidence from many countries. Its findings bind no one else, as the judge himself said.
- Legal finding
even though these findings are of course not binding on any of them.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
The archive holds no group statistics on how many children lived apart from their parents, or for how long, so this article cannot give numbers. Testimony comes mostly from people who later left, and the judge warned against blaming the whole group for faults of individuals or particular communes. The 1992 "Heritage" statement and the 1993 letter by Maria were written in the same years and contradict each other on separation; both are cited so readers can compare.
- Legal finding
I must not fall into the trap of attributing collective responsibility to The Family as a group when the faults and failings are those of an individual or individuals or even a commune or more than one commune.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
From teaching to reform
How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.
Berg teaches that God breaks up "selfish" private families and that the larger Family comes before one's own spouse and children.
- Official teaching
He's breaking up private families!
ML 249, One Wife - Official teaching
THE LARGER FAMILY UNITY COMES FIRST and is far more important than the tiny private selfish family unit of two and their own children.
ML 359, Divorce! – The Marriage Revolution!
- Official teaching
Spouses are shared; parents leave children with others for the work, and from 1988 many children live in schools and teen programmes away from their parents.
- Official teaching
I think that's the supreme sacrifice--to give up your children.
ML 1367, No More Tears! – For Those Who’ve Forsaken Children for the Lord & Others! - Leadership instruction
forsaking mothers & fathers and children so we can put His Work first
ML 2862, Forsaking Your Children for the Lord and His Work!
- Official teaching
Children are separated from parents for long periods and moved between countries; the 1995 judgment finds forsaking all harmful.
- Legal finding
many, many young children were separated from their parents
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward - Legal finding
Forsaking all was harmful.
Judgement of Lord Justice Ward
- Legal finding
Daily family time (1991); a child's right to live with a parent under the Love Charter (1995); apologies in 1995–96; end of the communal model in 2010.
- Leadership instruction
Every Family child has the right to live with their parents, or at least one parent if their parents are not living together, if they wish to
ML 2862, Forsaking Your Children for the Lord and His Work! - The group’s own account History (The Family International website) ↗
- Leadership instruction
How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.