Beliefs and practices

Salvation, Grace and Eternal Security in the Children of God

What did the Children of God teach about salvation and "once saved, always saved"?

The Children of God taught that salvation is a free gift received by grace through faith in Jesus, and that once a person is truly saved the gift can never be lost ("once saved, always saved"). This is close to Baptist and other evangelical teaching. What set the group apart was how it separated salvation from discipleship: a backslider was still saved but would lose heavenly rewards and face God's chastening, and David Berg also taught a purging hell, a second chance after death and that water baptism was unnecessary.

Overview: what did the group teach about salvation?

The group's core teaching on salvation was mainstream evangelical. Salvation was a gift of God's grace, received by believing in Jesus and asking him into one's heart, and not earned by good works. Once received, it could never be lost. The Family's Statement of Faith puts it plainly: "Once saved, the believer shall be kept saved forever."

  • Leadership instruction Salvation is only by grace; and no one, by virtue of any goodness or mere work of their own, can become a child of God. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication
  • Leadership instruction Once saved, the believer shall be kept saved forever. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication

Around this evangelical core Berg built several distinctive ideas. He drew a sharp line between being saved and being a disciple, so that a member who left the group was still saved but would lose eternal rewards. He taught that God chastens believers who keep sinning, that hell purges rather than punishes for ever, that the unsaved may get a second chance after death, and that water baptism is not needed today. This article sets out each of these, noting where they agree with other Christian traditions and where they depart from them.

Historical origins: where did the teaching come from?

The archive documents Berg's teaching on salvation mainly through his own Letters. In 1971 he framed the great religious divide as one between self-help religions and faith that "God alone" can save. By 1974 he was attacking churches for not teaching eternal security, claiming they kept quiet about it so that people would keep needing the church.

The belief that salvation could not be lost marked a change from the tradition some early leaders had grown up in. Maria, recalling her youth in a 1978 Letter, wrote that in her church she had often gone forward to "regain my salvation", because her church taught that sin could cause it to be lost.

  • Firsthand account I would frequently go down to the altar in church to ask the Lord for forgiveness for my backsliding & to regain my salvation, as we believed that by sinning we could lose our salvation. ML 1358, Our Love Story! (1/4/78) · Maria's own account in the 1978 Letter "Our Love Story!"

Official doctrine: what did the documents say?

The Statement of Faith, the group's most formal summary of doctrine, is undated in the archive; a 1996 Family publication cites it as April 1992. Its article on salvation affirms that all people are sinners, that salvation comes only through Jesus Christ, and that a person is saved by "personally receiving Jesus Christ into our hearts" and so being born again.

  • Leadership instruction We are saved by believing on and personally receiving Jesus Christ into our hearts and lives, thus becoming spiritually regenerated or "born again". OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication
  • Leadership instruction "Statement of Faith," Point 12: "Spirits of Departed Saints"; 4/92 ML 3048, Communicating with Heavenly Messengers! (May 1996) · the 1996 citation that dates the Statement of Faith to April 1992

The same article adds a guard against misuse. Eternal security, it says, is "not a licence for sin": God will "chasten and correct" children who persist in sin. Berg had made the same point in 1981, warning that unconfessed and unrepented sins would bring suffering or loss "in this life or the Next".

  • Leadership instruction this is not a licence for sin to the believer. Because God is a holy and righteous Father Who cannot overlook the sins of His children, if they persistently sin, He will chasten and correct them. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication
  • Official teaching if you commit sins against the Lord & others which are unconfessed, unrepented, not made right in this life, that you will suffer for them in some way or be rewarded accordingly in some way, negatively, in this life or the Next ML 1045, Backsliders Beware! – The Hotel Marshal Dream! (29/6/81)

Discipleship was treated as a separate and higher calling. The Statement of Faith says the ideal was the path of the twelve apostles, who left everything, but accepts that "pursuing this course is not possible for everyone" and that people commit themselves to different degrees. Full-time discipleship was therefore not a condition of salvation, though it was presented as the response a grateful believer should make.

  • Leadership instruction However, we recognise that pursuing this course is not possible for everyone. OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication
  • Leadership instruction how can we give Him less than our all? OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication

Distinctive features: how did it differ from other Christians?

Theological analysis: on grace and faith the group stood squarely within Protestant teaching, which reads Ephesians 2:8-9 as saying that salvation is a gift and not earned. Its "once saved, always saved" position is close to the Reformed doctrine of the perseverance of the saints and to the view held in many Baptist and independent evangelical churches. It differs from Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, Methodist and other Arminian traditions, which teach that a believer can fall from grace and be restored by repentance; the Augsburg Confession explicitly rejects the claim that the justified cannot lose the Spirit. Most historic churches also see baptism and life in a church as part of how salvation is received, which the group's emphasis on a single prayer left out.

The group's most distinctive move was to tie eternal rewards to service in the group. In a 1980 Letter Berg told members that backsliders who went home would "lose everything there except your salvation": their crowns, stars and rewards. In 1982 he described ranks inside and outside the Heavenly City, with some saved people living in "everlasting shame & contempt" as "second-class citizens of Heaven".

Berg's teaching on hell also departed from the creeds. In 1974 he wrote that the Lake of Fire purges the wicked until God may forgive them; in 1980 he called himself "a firm believer in Purgatory", applied to the unsaved; and in 1981 he wrote "WE PREACH A SECOND CHANCE!" for those who had not believed in this life. In 1983 he suggested that prayer might release souls held in "Purgatory or Hell".

Theological analysis: the historic creeds teach that judgement follows death and ends in everlasting life or everlasting punishment. Catholic teaching on Purgatory concerns people who die in grace, not a second chance for the unsaved, and Protestant confessions reject Purgatory altogether. Some early writers, such as Origen, hoped all would finally be restored, but the creeds did not adopt this. The Statement of Faith itself describes the Great White Throne Judgement and the Lake of Fire in near-creedal language, without Berg's additions.

  • Theological analysis And as it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment: Hebrews 9:27 (King James Version) ↗
  • Theological analysis And they that have done good shall go into life everlasting and they that have done evil into everlasting fire. Athanasian Creed ↗
  • Leadership instruction The unsaved dead of all ages will then be raised to appear before God at the awesome "Great White Throne Judgement" OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication

Practical application: baptism, communion and soul-winning

Berg taught that water baptism was only an outward sign, then that it was a Jewish custom not required today, replaced by the baptism of the Holy Spirit. By 1982 he said the Family had "dispensed with" it. The Statement of Faith has an article on the baptism of the Holy Spirit but none on water baptism.

Communion was the one ceremony Berg kept. It was held informally in the Homes with bread and wine, and he described it as a witness of faith, not something that heals or saves in itself. The Statement of Faith adds that the bread represents healing of the body and the wine forgiveness of sins. In 1982 Berg told a member that young children could take part because a child with a saved parent was counted as saved until about age two.

  • Reported practice WE'VE DISPENSED WITH JUST ABOUT EVERY CEREMONY, EXCEPT COMMUNION. ML 1386, Our Only Ceremony! – Family Communion! (1/83)
  • Official teaching THE BREAD DOESN'T HEAL ANY MORE THAN THE WINE SAVES YOUR SOUL, but it's manifesting your faith, it's a witness. ML 337B, Communion! (March 30, 1975)
  • Leadership instruction The Supper consists of bread which is broken, representing how Jesus' body was broken for the healing of our bodies OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication
  • Official teaching IF EVEN ONE PARENT IS SAVED, THE CHILD IS "CLEAN" OR SAVED under the age of personal accountability ML 1334, Answers to Your Questions! – No.4/GN19 (11/82)

Theological analysis: Berg's view of baptism as a sign is close to Baptist and many evangelical churches, which treat it as an ordinance for believers, but almost all of them still practise it in obedience to Matthew 28:19; only a few groups, such as the Quakers and the Salvation Army, do not. His memorial view of communion also matches much evangelical teaching, while lay-led communion in a household setting and the link with bodily healing differ from the practice of the historic churches.

Because salvation was received by a simple prayer, witnessing focused on leading people to pray it, and the numbers "saved" were counted and published. A 1975 Letter reported 140 thousand souls saved in 1970-72; in recorded invitations Berg assured listeners that anyone who sincerely asked Jesus in was "SAVED FOREVER". In 1981 he himself asked where the "MILLIONS OF SOULS SAVED" were, admitting that many had been counted "en masse" by a show of hands.

Historical development: what changed over time?

The core doctrine of salvation by grace and eternal security did not change. Berg repeated it in 1981 in "The Helmet", a Letter addressed to backsliders, telling them that even if they had gone home they were "still saved". The 1990s Statement of Faith restated it in formal terms, and a 1994 compilation reprinted the Helmet passage.

What did shift was the surrounding teaching on the afterlife. The second-chance and purging-hell ideas were absent from the Statement of Faith, but they were not withdrawn. A prophecy published after the 11 September 2001 attacks, presented as the words of Jesus, said that some of those who died "have been given a choice in the spirit world to receive Me".

  • Leadership instruction Those who lost their lives are now with Me, or have been given a choice in the spirit world to receive Me ML 3367, Attack on America (9/01)

Communion also gained new meanings. In 1996 Maria introduced a prophecy listing its purposes as renewing fellowship, confessing sins, praise, claiming healing and uniting hearts, presenting it as a celebration of Jesus' life as well as his death.

  • Leadership instruction renew our fellowship with the Lord and one another, confess our sins and receive forgiveness, sing praises and give thanks, claim healing, and unite our hearts. ML 3100, COME TOGETHER--IN LOVE (12/96)

Controversies and consequences

The separation of salvation from reward gave leaders a powerful lever. Letters described backsliders as people who would face God's chastening: a 1981 Letter warned of "chastisement & chastening & punishment" and even death for the disobedient, and a 1983 Letter said that if strict discipline failed with a rebellious teenager, God would "hound'm for the rest of their lives until they repent". Lord Justice Ward, reviewing the literature in 1995, summarised the message as "a message of all or nothing".

Former members describe how this felt. An anonymous former member, writing in 1999, recalled being told by a leader, when thinking of going home to visit, that "God hates backsliders". A young woman raised in the group, writing in 1999-2000, recalled that during a long period of isolation "No one was sure about my salvation" and that "The thought of going to hell really distressed me."

  • Firsthand account He then told me, quoting Mo, God hates backsliders. My experience with the COG/Family (1999) · anonymous former member, 1999
  • Firsthand account No one was sure about my salvation. The thought of going to hell really distressed me. Merry's Story (1999-2000) · woman raised in the group, 1999-2000

Some members noticed contradictions with the doctrine of eternal security itself. An early member, writing in 2001, questioned a 1973 Letter, "The Green Door", that pictured in hell a sister the writer had known as a committed believer: "once we are saved, aren't we always saved?" A former World Services worker, apologising in 2005, said he regretted compiling Scripture lists "on how God would punish 'backsliders'", which he believed shepherds had used to pressure young people.

  • Firsthand account we are Christians and we do believe in eternal salvation and once we are saved, aren't we always saved? Thoughts on the Green Door (2001) · early member, 2001
  • Firsthand account Backsliding (which included lists of scriptures on how God would punish 'backsliders') My Apology and Accounting (2005) · former World Services staff member's 2005 apology

Critics have also questioned the counting of conversions. Lord Justice Ward noted that the group's own records claimed over ten million souls won in the decade to 1987. Berg's 1981 admission that many had been counted by a show of hands suggests that these figures recorded prayers prayed, not lasting converts.

Sources and the limits of the evidence

The key primary sources are Berg's Letters on salvation (1971-1983), his Letters to backsliders ("Expensive Bargains!", 1980; "Backsliders Beware!" and "The Helmet!", 1981), his Letters on the afterlife and the Heavenly City, and the Family's Statement of Faith. The Statement of Faith carries no date in the archive; the April 1992 date comes from a later citation, so it may have been revised.

The archive shows what was taught much more fully than how ordinary members understood it. Testimony on fear of losing reward or of hell comes from a small number of accounts, and experiences varied by decade, country and Home. The archive does not record whether post-2010 TFI materials still teach the second-chance and purging-hell ideas.

From teaching to reform

How this teaching moved from doctrine to practice, what followed, and how the group later responded. Each step links to its evidence.

  1. Doctrine · 1971–1992

    Salvation is by grace through faith and can never be lost; full-time discipleship is a separate, higher calling that earns eternal rewards.

  2. Practice · 1970s–1980s

    Witnessing centres on leading people to pray a short prayer; the numbers saved are counted and published. Water baptism is dropped; communion is kept as an informal Home ceremony.

  3. Consequence · 1980s–1990s

    Leaving the group is framed as keeping salvation but losing every reward and facing God's chastening, which some former members describe as a source of fear.

  4. Reform or response · 1992 onward

    The Statement of Faith restates salvation in mainstream evangelical terms and omits the purging hell and second chance, though later prophecies still speak of choices offered in the spirit world.

    • Leadership instruction The unsaved dead of all ages will then be raised to appear before God at the awesome "Great White Throne Judgement" OUR STATEMENT OF FAITH · undated Statement of Faith; cited as April 1992 in a 1996 Family publication
    • Leadership instruction have been given a choice in the spirit world to receive Me ML 3367, Attack on America (9/01)

How to read the labels: Official teaching is what the group’s publications said; it does not show that every Home put it into practice. Firsthand account is one person’s experience; experiences varied by decade, country and Home. Where sources disagree, the article says so. See our editorial standards.